NRL season 2013

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
NewScotty
NewScotty
2350 posts
2350 posts
13 Sep 2013 6:52pm
Cheers Mac.
Chrispy, not wrong about the adds.
My daughter just said Waterhouse has a head like a spoon.
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
13 Sep 2013 6:56pm
afl already playing. Shame on you nrl
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
13 Sep 2013 7:15pm
you farken beeewwwdy smash em crowds' in full voice you ripper
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
13 Sep 2013 7:25pm
haven't seen slater do that before geez and how many penalties are souths forcing wow yeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
13 Sep 2013 8:33pm
geez could that be a crucial no try call



ahhhhhhhh that's a huge try brilliant
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
13 Sep 2013 8:38pm
Two poor video ref decisions have cost Melbourne tonight. Disappointing when games are like that
Ted the Kiwi
Ted the Kiwi
NSW
14256 posts
NSW, 14256 posts
13 Sep 2013 11:08pm
Ted the Kiwi said..

NewScotty said..

Bunnies to break the Storm hoodoo Friday night.


We have spoken about this before....maybe its time you took an emotional hedge Scotty - Storm are paying $1.97 Lets hope they study how Manly smashed them a few weeks back - that will help you.


Glad your boys took the advice on board

You boys must be stoked...enjoy your moment but do not forget there is still a long way to go
NewScotty
NewScotty
2350 posts
2350 posts
13 Sep 2013 9:14pm
^^^* Yes Ted, 2 games to go.
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
13 Sep 2013 9:18pm
4 point game that one Jen scotty ... fark you've got nice melons
weiry
weiry
QLD
5396 posts
QLD, 5396 posts
14 Sep 2013 12:09am
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
13 Sep 2013 10:29pm
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:13am
chrispy said..

Two poor video ref decisions have cost Melbourne tonight. Disappointing when games are like that


I agree ref too hasty calling one a no try before review,Melbourne could not have played worse.

Not taking anything away from the rabbits the best team won on the night,Scotty must be doing cartwheels
NewScotty
NewScotty
2350 posts
2350 posts
14 Sep 2013 7:59am
62mac said...
chrispy said..

Two poor video ref decisions have cost Melbourne tonight. Disappointing when games are like that


I agree ref too hasty calling one a no try before review,Melbourne could not have played worse.

Not taking anything away from the rabbits the best team won on the night,Scotty must be doing cartwheels


Not doing cartwheels just yet but happy we are closer to GF.
Cliche alert: "We just want to take it a week at a time" & "We don't want to get too far ahead of ourselves".
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
14 Sep 2013 8:13am
haha Scotty great start to the weekend for ya mate enjoy,another couple of great match ups today
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
14 Sep 2013 8:18am
good game though Melbo will feel some of those hits they copped .... hoodoo buried maybe
SP
SP
10982 posts
SP SP
10982 posts
14 Sep 2013 8:18am
^ the boys done good.
Is my favourite

But the vid ref is a joke... The ref calling it, then they go upstairs and there has to be enough evidence to change is crap IMO. Just as many bad decisions as before. Remeber benefit of the doubt...

I reckon do away with the third official, I mean

Shouldn't the onfield ref decide, he has seen it probably better than anyone.
I can get 23 camera angles on my computer during the game or some stupid number on Fango, jump in or whatever the **** rabs tells me to be part of....

So The point is, couldn't they just get the onfield officials to look on a iPad or similar at all the angles and decide, in gridiron the have a tv sideline which is viewed by the onfield ref and he decides.
NewScotty
NewScotty
2350 posts
2350 posts
14 Sep 2013 9:42am
SP,
like a lot of things in life, you can't please everybody.
I like the new system where more responsibility lies with the on field ref/s.
I thinks it great they have to give their opinion before going to video ref.
Previous system was just passing the buck upstairs.
weiry
weiry
QLD
5396 posts
QLD, 5396 posts
14 Sep 2013 2:19pm
NewScotty said..

SP,
like a lot of things in life, you can't please everybody.
I like the new system where more responsibility lies with the on field ref/s.
I thinks it great they have to give their opinion before going to video ref.
Previous system was just passing the buck upstairs.


i totally agree with you on this one scotty.
SP
SP
10982 posts
SP SP
10982 posts
14 Sep 2013 1:21pm
So do I, the ref should be responsible, my idea is give him the replay and let him see it. Take the upstairs bit out altogether, give the onfield ref the replay like gridiron. I agree they have been better this year than previous but

My problem at the moment is it starts from a place of ambiguity, ie the ref doesn't know so why does he make a call, the point of the replay is he didn't see it properly so give him the replay to decide, don't start the decision making process on a blokes word who doesn't know and hope that channel 9 were good enough with the camera to prove you right or wrong. Just give the bloke who had the best view a better view, more replays and let him decide if n the balance of probability it looked like a try.




weiry
weiry
QLD
5396 posts
QLD, 5396 posts
14 Sep 2013 3:38pm
SP the biggest problem with the ref reviewing on field would be the crowd impact, you imagine a QLD suncorp stadium going off at the ref reviewing a NSW try IMO we dont wont that in the game, it would turn the pecker heads that go into bigger pecker heads if thats possible.
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
14 Sep 2013 3:15pm
hahaha how was that first cowboys try hahahaha
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:01pm
C'Mon sharkies
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:03pm
chrispy said..

C'Mon sharkies


7 tackle try wtf its the finals NRL not some under 5's game
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:09pm
62mac said...
chrispy said..

C'Mon sharkies


7 tackle try wtf its the finals NRL not some under 5's game


Hand of God and now this for the cowboys....was it a zero tackle to start with. Was listening on the rradio when that happened.
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:12pm
Wow they have admitted it, as a mistake already .
ucking poor
thePup
thePup
13831 posts
13831 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:26pm
hahahaaaaaaa a Ref forgetting how to count to 7 .... fark sakes
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:55pm
WOW
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 4:57pm
The NRL have sunk again to New lows
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
14 Sep 2013 5:09pm
What's the score I had to duck out
chrispy
chrispy
WA
9675 posts
WA, 9675 posts
14 Sep 2013 5:19pm
62mac said...
What's the score I had to duck out


Mate you have to try and watch it. The game turned into a total debacle and all officials should be fined,suspended and not one of them should be near grand final day. Sharks won.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅