Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

Electric cars.... convince me

Reply
Created by Tonz > 9 months ago, 16 May 2022
Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
3 Dec 2022 5:06PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

They forget to include disposable drinking straws on that graph. Or is their contribution so small that they're not worth considering?

Rango
WA, 828 posts
3 Dec 2022 2:29PM
Thumbs Up

0.03% but 200% virtue.

cisco
QLD, 12361 posts
3 Dec 2022 5:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Pcdefender said..

decrepit said.


And the amount of damage caused by climate change?



Shame on you Cisco for not factoring in 'climate change'

Start drinking the Kool aid asap.


Another calculation I would like to see is the amount of electricity that could be generated from the hot air coming from the mouths of the greenies.

FormulaNova
WA, 15086 posts
3 Dec 2022 4:50PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Harrow said..
However, a combined cycle gas turbine generator is around 60% efficient, so that beats the internal combustion engine hands down.


That's why I have one in my batmobile. It keeps the atomic batteries charged nicely.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
3 Dec 2022 6:32PM
Thumbs Up

financialpost.com/opinion/bjorn-lomborg-the-muddled-reality-of-electric-cars

I guess to some owning one would be an act of self purification.

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
4 Dec 2022 9:05AM
Thumbs Up

Hydrogen ICE cars don't necessarily look so good either from a practical point of view if you want decent range, but a hydrogen fuel cell powered EV seems plausible.

Pcdefender
WA, 1607 posts
10 Dec 2022 8:49PM
Thumbs Up

Pcdefender
WA, 1607 posts
11 Dec 2022 9:12PM
Thumbs Up

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
12 Dec 2022 7:49AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Pcdefender said..

Or by combined cycle gas turbine in the interim.

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
12 Dec 2022 9:47AM
Thumbs Up

It's not a meme (if that's what you call a few words written over a block coloured background or a picture), but an article from the USA touching upon the market for used EVs made a few points

insideevs.com/news/625666/lessons-10000-electric-cars-100-million-miles/

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
12 Dec 2022 10:13AM
Thumbs Up

I've heard the rules for novated leasing, electric cars and fringe benefits taxes are changing. There will be around a $9k saving on leasing an electric car worth around $70K and on an income of around $100K compared to leasing a combustion engine car of around the same price over the period of the lease. I've never leased a car like this so I'm unsure of exactly how it works.

It looks like the federal government is going to use the old carrot and stick approach to push people to buy electric cars. If so it is probable we will see a lot more electric cars for sale from different brands.

AUS1111
WA, 3621 posts
22 Dec 2022 7:37AM
Thumbs Up

If the government offers a $3000 subsidy for every EV, and this increases sales of EVs by 10%, how much is it costing the taxpayer for each additional EV?

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
22 Dec 2022 10:56AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
AUS1111 said..
If the government offers a $3000 subsidy for every EV, and this increases sales of EVs by 10%, how much is it costing the taxpayer for each additional EV?

Are you suggesting this as the incremental subsidy cost of the additional 10% of EV sales... $3,000 * 1.1/0.1 = $33,000 ?

Although, if it only boosted sales by 1%, you'd get this... $3,000 * 1.01/0.1 = $303,000 !

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
22 Dec 2022 11:37AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
AUS1111 said..
If the government offers a $3000 subsidy for every EV, and this increases sales of EVs by 10%, how much is it costing the taxpayer for each additional EV?


The GST on the car would be more than $3000 in most cases.

UncleBob
NSW, 1300 posts
22 Dec 2022 11:58AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mr Milk said..

AUS1111 said..
If the government offers a $3000 subsidy for every EV, and this increases sales of EVs by 10%, how much is it costing the taxpayer for each additional EV?



The GST on the car would be more than $3000 in most cases.


Not to mention the road tax paid via fuel sales that EV's don't at the moment pay.

Pcdefender
WA, 1607 posts
22 Dec 2022 12:54PM
Thumbs Up

In Norway the cost of electricity is more than fuel.

A sign of things to come perhaps.

AUS1111
WA, 3621 posts
22 Dec 2022 12:56PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Harrow said..

AUS1111 said..
If the government offers a $3000 subsidy for every EV, and this increases sales of EVs by 10%, how much is it costing the taxpayer for each additional EV?


Are you suggesting this as the incremental subsidy cost of the additional 10% of EV sales... $3,000 * 1.1/0.1 = $33,000 ?

Although, if it only boosted sales by 1%, you'd get this... $3,000 * 1.01/0.1 = $303,000 !


Spot on. To put it another way, we can sell 10,000 EVs at $0 cost to the taxpayer, or we can sell 11,000 EVs at a cost of $33,000,000.

So are EV subsidies best use of taxpayer funds to reduce carbon emmissions, or an extremely inefficient feel-good populist vote-winner?

Mr Milk, I don't understand how the GST component is relevant?

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
22 Dec 2022 3:18PM
Thumbs Up

It is almost like you are saying the best way to deal with unwanted carbon dioxide emissions is via direct action with the largest polluters and not via economy wide or broad based taxes and subsidies ?

{insert side-eye kid meme}

Then again I also heard the other day that the best way to wean the economy off gas was to cap the price everyone pays for it and so make it as cheap as possible.

Maybe next week the great flash-plan idea of the day's cost of living news headline will be to subside all fossil fuels to consumers using money raised from a tax on...... mining fossil fuels.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
30 Dec 2022 2:51PM
Thumbs Up



How will the EV luvies cope with it.

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
30 Dec 2022 6:59PM
Thumbs Up

Australia has large cobalt-bearing nickel laterite deposits including Glencore's Murrin Murrin Mine in the north-eastern Goldfields of WA and CleanTeQ's undeveloped Syerston Project in central NSW. In 2019, Murrin Murrin was the country's largest single cobalt producer with 3,400 tonnes per year of cobalt and it accounted for the majority of Australian cobalt output.The Broken Hill Cobalt ProjectCobalt Blue's BHCP is 23 kilometres west of Broken Hill in Far West NSW. The resource is not a laterite but rather a sulphide (pyrite) cobalt deposit with no copper, negligible nickel and very distinctive mineralogy which enable a mine design with substantially lower outlay and high cobalt recoveries (85-90%).The company intends to produce 3,500 to 4,000 tonnes per year of cobalt using a very different metallurgical process than laterite treatment and this is expected to be a healthy investment for stakeholders and the environment.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
30 Dec 2022 4:14PM
Thumbs Up

Thats a piddle China dominates.

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
30 Dec 2022 11:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rango said..
Thats a piddle China dominates.


Actually, China doesn't mine cobalt at home. DRC does have the world's largest reserves, but Australia is the number 3 producer

Rango
WA, 828 posts
30 Dec 2022 8:41PM
Thumbs Up

They own the mines in the congo actually.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
30 Dec 2022 8:59PM
Thumbs Up

hir.harvard.edu/not-so-green-technology-the-complicated-legacy-of-rare-earth-mining/

These nations should be able to benefit from being resource rich but clearly not.

Pcdefender
WA, 1607 posts
30 Dec 2022 10:19PM
Thumbs Up

Getting harder by the day to conclude anything other than it is immoral to own one.

Where is the moral outrage by the media and Govt to their development?

All we seem to hear about these days is Ukraine.


You'll own nothing and be happy - soon to be the most infamous words ever spoken

Rango
WA, 828 posts
31 Dec 2022 6:27PM
Thumbs Up

www.businessinsider.com/holiday-travel-long-wait-times-for-tesla-chargers-2019-12

I'm not convinced.Hybrid?.... maybe.
Not enough time on the weekend to deal with this.

GavGav
VIC, 193 posts
13 Jan 2023 9:44PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rango said..
How will the EV luvies cope with it.



Do you drive a petrol car? There is cobalt in the catalytic converter...
Do you drive a diesel? They use cobalt to remove the Sulphur.
Do you own a mobile... There is probably cobalt in that.
I hope you can cope with that...

Yes, EVs currently use more, but that is changing.
LiFePo4 chemistry does not use cobalt.
thenextweb.com/news/the-cobalt-free-electric-vehicle-batteries-are-here

Rango
WA, 828 posts
14 Jan 2023 10:06AM
Thumbs Up



Dose of reality .
Not enough metal to even supply first generation of EVs let alone everything else in the zero carbon economy they want to enforce and turn into a materials economy.

Ian K
WA, 4162 posts
14 Jan 2023 11:40AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rango said..


Dose of reality .
Not enough metal to even supply first generation of EVs let alone everything else in the zero carbon economy they want to enforce and turn into a materials economy.


Thanks Rango, He's straightforward with what we know and don't know. Looks like the planet will have to cope with fossil fuel burning for a good while yet.

Ian K
WA, 4162 posts
15 Jan 2023 1:58PM
Thumbs Up



Even hydrogen fuel cells are difficult. Makes you realise just how handy fossil fuels are as energy sources. Is Co2 all that bad? Is Co2 poisoning the insects? Or is it Jim's mowing and lawn care?

Remember when the intrepid Aussie outbacker drove an eh ute around town, proudly displaying his canvas water bag on the bumper and the insect screen over the radiator still with a couple of splattered dragon flies? Don't need insect screens any more, but with a 2.2 tonne HiLux with a bull bar and orange tow hooks you can attempt to strike the same image.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"Electric cars.... convince me" started by Tonz