CMC said...
Logman. I love these discussions, the best bit is there are no wrongs and rights. I wish we were sitting around a table with beer though.
I have never spoken about scaling up Mick Fannings 6'1 x 18 1/4. The result would be too low volumed.
Take for example the board above. Let's say it is 6'0 x 19 3/4. If you simply multiply the vital dimensions x 1.4 you end up with 8'4 x 28. If you took the nose and tail rocker of say 5 inches in the nose and 2 1/4 in the tail you end up with 7 inches nose rocker and 3.5 tail. They sound like they could be performance SUP dimensions to me.
I worked for a very respected shaper for a long time and he always taught me that if you take similar curves in rockers and outline they will react in a similar way in the same parts of the wave.
If the benchmark of performance is shortboarding then why would you not look at shortboard design if you intend to surf in a similar way?? I know for a fact that some popular SUP designs have been directly scaled up from shortboard fishes already. To say it holds no water at all is a little off the mark. Even that guy in Hawaii Jimmy Lewis said in his interview he just copied his sons shortboard.
The difference is we need to stand up to paddle and that takes allowances in the design, the challenge and what people are dealing with is making boards that perform while still being stable.
Can things be better? I hope so. Can Blane, Dale, DTM, DMS etc etc find better ways to blend performance with paddleability? Of course but to not look at what already works is like trying to invent a round thing that you can put on a car to let it go down the road. Hang on we have one already, it's called a wheel........
as usual total frog **** CMC,

sorry I was getting all conciliatory before, as I just got back from the pub after a steak and bottle of red with Loglady it seems to have made me all misty eyed and agreeable

Anyhow history has taught me that the influence of red wine tends to wear off over time and turns me back into the same old grumpy krunt that always looks back at me from the bath room mirror in the morning. OK so I'm a little bit tipsy but here's my idea of SUP nirvana : we get Blane Dale, DTM, dms, Hocker, etc,etc, in a Sup shoot out, where they all talk about they're boards ,then everybody elses boards before riding them and talking about the pro's and cons of each design.........then we eat more steak and red wine!!! deal?