Onvi's ... are not a boat designed to sailed close hauled for a significant passage.
Sounds like one might as well buy a catamaran.
Burke Seabrake arrived in the post today, keen to have a go at using it for emergency steering. I'll pick a suitable day and go out in the bay and play around with different points of sail and see if I could use it in anger if needed. hopefully just having it onboard ensures I never need it.
The info around seems to indicate that there is no inherent structural advantage in a skeg over a spade. Large ships have spade rudders, not skeg-hung ones. If you can built a spade rudder that will steer a destroyer, aircraft carrier or supertanker and not get knocked off then you can build a spade rudder that will steer a yacht and not get knocked off. Ship designers don't use spade rudders because they are idiots who like losing rudders.