Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...

When Soothsayers and Prophets are called 'Scientists'

Reply
Created by Carantoc > 9 months ago, 11 Nov 2021
This topic has been locked
Rango
WA, 828 posts
3 Jan 2023 5:52PM
Thumbs Up

theconversation.com/we-found-a-secret-history-of-megadroughts-written-in-tree-rings-the-wheatbelts-future-may-be-drier-than-we-thought-160526

This is about the best study Ive seen on the subject.
If you can find the paper there's a cool chart in it (no hockey sticks).
Don't think its ever possible to predict the future though.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
4 Jan 2023 10:06AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Carantoc said..

Carantoc said..
If the computer models are right then drought conditions will become permanent...

says Tim Flannery, director of the South Australian Museum and Australia's most high profile scientist




Been a bit busy to flog a dead horse, so haven't been noting the daily situation across the country for the last few months.

But suffice to say that record flooding on the Murray-Darling from Menindee to coast and beyond to the largest flows ever recorded on the Fitzroy River in the north and widespread flooding across the Kimberley seems to provide some evidence the models are wrong (at least) stand corrected.

Is a peer reviewed paper required to prove that Tim Flannery, director of the South Australian Museum and Australia's most high profile scientist was wrong ?


michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/cbs-60-minutes-promotes-scientist?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

Flannery is a lightweight in failed predictions but it does'nt stop them , the more they make the more attention they get.

myscreenname
2283 posts
4 Jan 2023 3:41PM
Thumbs Up

www.abc.net.au/news/2023-01-04/bom-forecasts-40-per-cent-chance-el-nino-august-drought-fears/101826780

You do understand there is a difference between 'climate' and 'weather'?

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
4 Jan 2023 4:53PM
Thumbs Up

Yeah, I understand the difference between climate and weather.

Timescale and averaging. That's the difference.

Climate is the weather averaged out over periods of time and areas or regions.



I guess we could argue forever what the minimum timescale and area is for weather to become climate. 10 years, 30 years, 100 years, 1 million years ?

But I ain't got time to argue about that forever, too many threads about bitcoin to keep me busy.


Anyways you'se say BOM predicting 40% chance of upcoming el-nino making dryer than average weather eh ?

So that's 60% chance of not upcoming el-nino then.


40% dryer than average / 60% not dryer than average. Wows. Pretty good models they got.

I could have forecast 50% dryer than average / 50% not dryer than average at some time in the future using nothing but my magic wand. I wouldn't be that far off what the BOM supercomputer says. And Macro recons AI is smarter than the ol' Carantoc. Seems not so much eh ?

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
4 Jan 2023 5:00PM
Thumbs Up

Fears drought could follow floods as BOM forecasts chance of El Ni?o arriving off back of La Ni?a

www.abc.net.au/news/2023-01-04/bom-forecasts-40-per-cent-chance-el-nino-august-drought-fears/101826780


Just read your climate weather climate weather news article MSN.

Wowsers,

Hot Australian headline news. Drought may follow flood ?

Whoa. this is news.

Also, can anyone confirm if the recently deceased pope was catholic and if bears do **** in the wood because the floods has washed all the **** away and I can't see any.

myscreenname
2283 posts
4 Jan 2023 5:19PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Carantoc said..
Fears drought could follow floods as BOM forecasts chance of El Ni?o arriving off back of La Ni?a

www.abc.net.au/news/2023-01-04/bom-forecasts-40-per-cent-chance-el-nino-august-drought-fears/101826780


Just read your climate weather climate weather news article MSN.

Wowsers,

Hot Australian headline news. Drought may follow flood ?

Whoa. this is news.

Also, can anyone confirm if the recently deceased pope was catholic and if bears do **** in the wood because the floods has washed all the **** away and I can't see any.


Two posts in a row, lol!

I'm glad my post got you all triggered. Take it easy on those angry pills.

Pcdefender
WA, 1607 posts
4 Jan 2023 5:21PM
Thumbs Up

I wonder if blocking sunshine would have anything to do with all this strange weather we are having.


When a rookie co-pilot flipped the chemtrail switch before taking off - GoyimTV

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
4 Jan 2023 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
myscreenname said..
I'm glad my post got you all triggered. Take it easy on those angry pills.



Angry ?

Sincere apologies if my posts come across as angry.

I'd offer the opinion Carantoc is one of the least angry people in the world. Although that hasn't been peer reviewed so can't be trusted.


No, no. The theme I am trying to capture is extreme sarcasm and over-inflated self-righteousness.

And this stems from sanctimony, not anger.


Peace and love to all, and may your bitcoins forever expand in heaven.

myscreenname
2283 posts
4 Jan 2023 8:02PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Carantoc said..
Angry ?

Sincere apologies if my posts come across as angry.

I'd offer the opinion Carantoc is one of the least angry people in the world. Although that hasn't been peer reviewed so can't be trusted.


No, no. The theme I am trying to capture is extreme sarcasm and over-inflated self-righteousness.

And this stems from sanctimony, not anger.


Peace and love to all, and may your bitcoins forever expand in heaven.

Who needs red thumbs?

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
9 Mar 2023 7:00PM
Thumbs Up

Anyways back on the subject. Which was I recall :

If the computer models are right then drought conditions will become permanent in eastern Australia



Mmm, how east does it need to be the east ?

www.abc.net.au/news/2023-03-09/evacuations-amid-unprecedented-gulf-flooding/102074770

The Gregory River at Riversleigh, near Lawn Hill, reached 18 metres high, surpassing the 1971 flood record of 10.8m.

18m up from 10.8m record seems like a fair old whack, although maybe this isn't a permanent drought, it is just weather and not in the east..


remery
WA, 3709 posts
9 Mar 2023 10:11PM
Thumbs Up

"Climate is the long-term pattern of weather in a particular area. Weather can change from hour-to-hour, day-to-day, month-to-month or even year-to-year. A region's weather patterns, usually tracked for at least 30 years, are considered its climate."

Rango
WA, 828 posts
10 Mar 2023 3:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Carantoc said..
Anyways back on the subject. Which was I recall :

If the computer models are right then drought conditions will become permanent in eastern Australia



Mmm, how east does it need to be the east ?

www.abc.net.au/news/2023-03-09/evacuations-amid-unprecedented-gulf-flooding/102074770

The Gregory River at Riversleigh, near Lawn Hill, reached 18 metres high, surpassing the 1971 flood record of 10.8m.

18m up from 10.8m record seems like a fair old whack, although maybe this isn't a permanent drought, it is just weather and not in the east..




Don't worry WA has new super computer to predict the apocalypse,
will sleep well tonight.

remery
WA, 3709 posts
10 Mar 2023 10:00PM
Thumbs Up

Facts... Truth.

Planes flying at high altitude produce oxidane which falls to earth and impacts organisms.

Few planes fly at high altitude over the south west of Western Australia, so contrails are rarely seen.

The south west of Western Australia is low on oxidane.

Tonz
522 posts
11 Mar 2023 6:03AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
remery said..
Facts... Truth.

Planes flying at high altitude produce oxidane which falls to earth and impacts orgasims

Few planes fly at high altitude over the south west of Western Australia, so contrails are rarely seen.

The south west of Western Australia is low on oxidane.

UncleBob
NSW, 1300 posts
11 Mar 2023 9:34AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
remery said..
Facts... Truth.

Planes flying at high altitude produce oxidane which falls to earth and impacts organisms.

Few planes fly at high altitude over the south west of Western Australia, so contrails are rarely seen.

The south west of Western Australia is low on oxidane.


oxidane (uncountable) (inorganic chemistry) An IUPAC-compliant name for water, H2O.

TonyAbbott
924 posts
12 Mar 2023 10:12AM
Thumbs Up

Repent, the end is nigh





Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
12 Mar 2023 3:34PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
TonyAbbott said..
Repent, the end is nigh





No problem, we've got 3 months up our sleeves.

Buster fin
WA, 2596 posts
12 Mar 2023 4:31PM
Thumbs Up

Last chance to make a killing on crypto?

Carantoc
WA, 7186 posts
12 Mar 2023 5:34PM
Thumbs Up

Bitcoin and Greta.

When you think of those things you can't help also wondering about handbrakes on canoes, chocolate fireguards and tits on bulls.

myscreenname
2283 posts
13 Mar 2023 4:35PM
Thumbs Up

And Shooting the breeze

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
13 Mar 2023 8:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

So, would it be feasible and effective to just cover a large expanse of the earth with reflective polyester film?

CH3MTR4IL5
WA, 938 posts
13 Mar 2023 7:30PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
TonyAbbott said..
Repent, the end is nigh






The end could still be a while away, just unavoidable if we don't stop using fossil fuels by June. a comma would have helped with some clarity but probably too late now

did your hear the one about the comma and the apostrophe that went to couples counselling, the apostrophe was possessive but the comma wouldn't end things

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
14 Mar 2023 12:15AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Harrow said..



So, would it be feasible and effective to just cover a large expanse of the earth with reflective polyester film?


If you have the time to waste on one of your office commutes, you might read Termination Shock, Neal Stephenson. Near future, say 2030s, oil billionaire decides to solve global warming by shooting sulphur into the stratosphere. Fights follow. About 700 pages

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
14 Mar 2023 9:05AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Mr Milk said..
If you have the time to waste on one of your office commutes, you might read Termination Shock, Neal Stephenson. Near future, say 2030s, oil billionaire decides to solve global warming by shooting sulphur into the stratosphere. Fights follow. About 700 pages.

My initial reaction is, "Solve global warming with acid rain?"

Mr Milk
NSW, 3115 posts
14 Mar 2023 9:19AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Harrow said..

Mr Milk said..
If you have the time to waste on one of your office commutes, you might read Termination Shock, Neal Stephenson. Near future, say 2030s, oil billionaire decides to solve global warming by shooting sulphur into the stratosphere. Fights follow. About 700 pages.


My initial reaction is, "Solve global warming with acid rain?"


The theory is albedo increases due to sulphate aerosols. Real world evidence came from Pinatubo eruption that was correlated with a small pause in warming.

Rango
WA, 828 posts
14 Mar 2023 6:34AM
Thumbs Up



surely Spock would know...

Harrow
NSW, 4521 posts
14 Mar 2023 12:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rango said..

surely Spock would know...

The "In Search Of..." theme music brought back unexpected memories.

Paradox
QLD, 1326 posts
19 Mar 2023 1:43PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Rango said..
theconversation.com/we-found-a-secret-history-of-megadroughts-written-in-tree-rings-the-wheatbelts-future-may-be-drier-than-we-thought-160526

This is about the best study Ive seen on the subject.
If you can find the paper there's a cool chart in it (no hockey sticks).
Don't think its ever possible to predict the future though.


I have been aware of that one for a while. lots of other studies support it. Natural changes to the worlds climate are significant if you simply look back a little, and you don't have to go far back to see it.

We don't appear to be doing anything in comparision to the background changes that happen, in fact there is no actual observed changes to the worlds climate apart from the slight warming we have seen in the last 40 years and perhaps a slight increase in global percipitation (not extreme, just wetter in general). The data is pretty clear on that. www.news.com.au/national/study-suggests-1500-year-long-mega-drought-killed-off-original-australians/news-story/125f5ee0fed2295bc7f2453624f08ca8?sv=13fab1a7cfaffa2253b06e28ce857b7e

remery
WA, 3709 posts
19 Mar 2023 5:05PM
Thumbs Up






Subscribe
Topic Is Locked

This topic has been locked

Forums > General Discussion   Shooting the breeze...


"When Soothsayers and Prophets are called 'Scientists'" started by Carantoc