Piros said..
Great question. I'm all over this at 90 kg at 183cm . For proning I ride he 890 BSC most days and 880 HPS . I also ride both these wings on my ding , these are my pair of go to wings in most conditions. In super light winds I'll break out my 1010 & 1150. For dinging I am open ocean dead down wind rider , trying to go as fast as a I can without reaching ,which is the basis to my feedback on these wings. So let's drop in the ART 999 where does it fit . Not as low start speed as the 890 BSC but better than the 880 HPS , very low stall speed like the 890 but much higher speed and up there with the 880 HPS. I'm at home on the 880 & 890 on the prone with the 890 definitely the one of the best/easiest I've used. The 880 is faster and a bit more unforgiving but man this thing flies and pumps super quick. The ART on the prone is an unsteady roller coaster at first but man this thing goes , it has some wing flex and if you are a larger unit like me , it can be a handful. It's a no for me on the prone .
Back on the Ding the ART 999 lights up like the orient express on a reach and running DW in the ocean it breaths on a breach letting you adjust and survive. It's really fast but the 880 HPS can match it , the 890 BSC is left in both their wakes and blows and dies when you force it overspeed. Recommend the 380 over the 420 tail when you are dinging the 890 in solid wind but sub 20kn & moderate swell on a 5m you'll enjoy a packed lunch and not break any speed records.
So back to the question what wing will the ART 999 replace ? For me I find the 880 HPS matches it at both ends & more maneuverable at 4" narrower , the 999 really does have amazing lift ...actually too much for me , I'm waiting for the 899 & 799 ART so at this stage I'm still rocking and rolling on the 880 & 890 as my fav 2 wing set . IMHO the 880 HPS punches way above its weight and knocks the ART999 out of the ring.
I've been riding 890 and 740 BSC and 880 HPS this year.. I'm 67kg .. 890 for dock starting, flat water winging to learn new tricks and small wave prone.. 740 when its bigger prone, and winging in strong winds / bigger waves / swell / downwinding in 30knots + and the 880 for winging downwinders, winging in lighter wind / smaller waves and as a goto 75% of the time (if i can get it back off my wife..)
Finally got a go on the 999 today .. ( 5m Mantis, 8- 14 knots 33L Autopilot Short Fuze, 380 stab 82 mast) .. hmmm .. I felt like a beginner learning to gybe again.. I'm not convinced it got up quicker than the 880 and nowhere near as early as the 890 Was almost as fast as the 880 and much faster than 890.. Stall speed was impressively low though, and i could ride ankle high wind chop right up to overhead groundswell in control. It definitely tacked beautifully but back to my first point, i was just so different to gybe than anything I'd used. Maybe I needed a shorter fuze ?!
I really don't see it fitting into my quiver and doing anything better than the HPS 880 does.. Its not as fast (IMHO) .. doesn't turn as tight (with my weight and mediocre skills) and doesn't foil up any quicker. The 880 however does all that and more in a more compact package.
The only time i think I'd choose a 999 over the others is if i was going to do a prone surf downwinder.. and then I'd bolt a 420 stab on the back..
880 definitely gets my vote as a 1 foil does all well over the 999.. Will be interested to try the smaller ones...