Kitesurfers = 65 dead. Windsurfing fatalities?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
mrrt
mrrt
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
31 Jan 2008 2:30pm
Hey guys,
Anyone know what the statistics are for windsurfing fatalities worldwide? I just posted this to the kitesurfing forum:

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=34752

As at June last year, kitesurfing fatalities were at approx 65 according to Ricki Lossi's sobering statistics:

kiteforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2331754&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=40

...with the spread being:

2007 - 3 (up till June)
2006 - 13, possibly 16
2005 - 16
2004 - 11
2003 - 5
2002 - 10
2001 - 3
2000 - 1

(note these are just the deaths Ricki has been able to track so the figures are apparently likely higher again)

Which makes it twice as dangerous as scuba diving (in terms of deaths per 100,000 people) though a lot less dangerous than paragliding. Apparently snow skiing and snow-boarding are actually safer than walking!

Does anyone know how many more deaths there have been in the last 8 months?

Also, what I haven't been able to find out are the statistics on major yet non-lethal injuries (spinal, head etc) amongst kite surfers. Does anyone have those sorts of figures?

I have to admit that after a near death experience myself, my 12m Airush has been sitting in our garage and I've gone back to windsurfing. I haven't found any stats on windsurfing fatalities since the 70's but to my knowledge it is a blip in comparison.



No I only got a bit winded after this bail-out

-Mart
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
31 Jan 2008 5:50pm
Kiters will have the response that you have to die of something so it may as well be something you like.

Same response smokers have.

mathew
mathew
QLD
2167 posts
QLD, 2167 posts
31 Jan 2008 4:57pm
Was at St Kilda beach last night talking to the lads, when one of them said...

The other day (which was about two weeks ago) an experienced kiter lost control of his kite, and so was heading for some girls on the beach. Did the right thing an dumped his kite to avoid hitting them; ended up head-first in the sand. He is now in traction from head to waist.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
31 Jan 2008 6:40pm
Whats the deal with the connection between the kiter and his kite? Do they use a harness like windsurfers and can hook in and out reasonably easily or are they more firmly linked to their kite and its a big deal to disconnect?

nitai
nitai
QLD
62 posts
QLD, 62 posts
31 Jan 2008 5:41pm
Bloody gnarly picture man! love it
mrrt
mrrt
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
31 Jan 2008 5:04pm
Mobydisc said...

Whats the deal with the connection between the kiter and his kite? Do they use a harness like windsurfers and can hook in and out reasonably easily or are they more firmly linked to their kite and its a big deal to disconnect?


Yes kitesurfers do use a harness though with several safety release mechanisms. In my case though, I was dragged under/thru the water at speed towards rocks so couldn't release myself and was only saved by my kite hitting the beach and de-powering before I hit the rocks.

Very easy to get head injuries kiting, or be suddenly lofted 30 feet in the air before you have a chance to do anything and then you get dropped on a concrete ablution block or hit powerlines etc. My cousin is an OT and sees heaps of kiters with bad ankle/leg/back injuries etc.

nitai said...

Bloody gnarly picture man! love it




A friend took a whole sequence of photos of this particular "incident". You'll find the first here:

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=8734

-Mart
CJW
CJW
NSW
1731 posts
CJW CJW
NSW, 1731 posts
31 Jan 2008 7:28pm
They have a clip on their hook so the loop doesn't come off I believe. There is also a 'chicken loop' between the loop and the bar and it has a quick release so you just pull it and the whole kite/lines flys away. It sounds good in principle but in reality things happen so fast there is often not time, it's too highly loaded or you can't reach it.
yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
31 Jan 2008 5:28pm
Kitesurfers = 65 dead. Windsurfing fatalities?

I found about 30 with google. 17 since 2004 and 5 last year and of course that surely is not complete.

So wear a helmet, watch out for powerboats and sail with a buddy.
aus301
aus301
QLD
2039 posts
QLD, 2039 posts
31 Jan 2008 7:29pm
it is very easy for all the saftey measures to fail as well.

I had a lesson a few years ago in moderate winds and ended up all hooked in heading towards rocks and road with no way out.

I had all the quick release devices, but I bounced off the water at one stage and actually wrapped everything around the bar, once I did that the QR devices no longer worked and I had absolutly no control over the kite. It was only for the force of what was going on actually breaking the part that was keeping me hooked up that I didn't come to a very nasty end. An experienced person may have got out of the situation but I couldn't.

Thought that was enough, kites aren't for me after that.
jp747
jp747
1553 posts
1553 posts
31 Jan 2008 7:17pm
am not surprised at all no pun intended for kitersi learned by teaching myself with a trusty mate to launch and retrieve kite. all i ever learned from an instructor friend was 30mins. of body dragging and that was it..to top it all am a hard headed nitwit who practiced near rocky oyster beds and lots of kids..sure i did learn slowly and a lot of bruises to knees and nipsbut with hard work i finally made it to a smaller board and tackled hiwinds..learned to jump by instinctively pulling bar opposite to where i was going or it was thorny bushes..now as i became better i kite even closer to shore and am calling it luck on my side one single mistake and i become part of the coco nuts..but i've become more responsible doing everything opposite..i give allowances by 3lenghths no matter what and with the latest in punch out depower still if you stumble and skip like a stone it sure is hard to push forward to depower and even if you've done that there's still a few meters of pull..so i guess the point am trying to make is part of the stats are from self-taught and non-iko instructed guys form half of the fatalities, just my guess
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
31 Jan 2008 8:29pm
That's interesting mrrt. All the Kities I've talked to say its not dangerous any more. All those death and disaster stories date back to the bad old days when the kites didn't have the range or the depower (not sure if thats a tautology) that they have today. However most of those accidents are recent.

I wonder how the stats compare with other sports, cycling for instance. Windsurfing I think is pretty damn safe. Hagar might disagree...
I wonder if the insurance industry agrees.
mrrt
mrrt
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
31 Jan 2008 7:47pm
yoyo said...

Kitesurfers = 65 dead. Windsurfing fatalities?

I found about 30 with google. 17 since 2004 and 5 last year and of course that surely is not complete.


That's more than I thought would be the case. However, apparently the estimated total number of windsurfers worldwide is 20 million so I guess that's not bad considering the estimated number of kitesurfers is somewhere around the 200,000 mark, or about 1% the number of windsurfers:

answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=747323

Assuming a pretty generous doubling in kitesurfer numbers since 2006 and if both fatality totals are anywhere near the ballpark, the 47 kitesurf fataliites since 2004 would make kitesurfing deaths possibly 100 x greater per capita than windsurfing.

Of course it's pretty hard to make any really reliable estimations with these rubbery figures but I guess it gives us some very rough ballparks to go with.

-Mart
mrrt
mrrt
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
31 Jan 2008 8:15pm
Another interesting factoid from Ricki's research is the fact that it isn't mainly newbies who are getting themselves killed, but experienced kiters:

Experience level of deceased:
4 or more years = 42%
3 years = 23 %
2 years = 15%
up to 1 year = 17%

kiteforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2331754&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=40

-Mart
elmo
elmo
WA
8890 posts
WA, 8890 posts
31 Jan 2008 9:46pm
A lot more people die from Bee stings and Asthma in Australia.

At least these poor buggers went out doing what they were enjoying a couple of seconds previously.

65 around the world is minor even giving the small number of people who kite vs population, most likely more people die driving to the beach world wide.
yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
31 Jan 2008 10:24pm
total number of windsurfers worldwide is 20 million

I find that hard to believe. I'm sure Auswind would say the numbers are even or kiting has the edge. Certainly at most beaches there are more kites than windsurfers so where do you get the idea that there are 100x more windsurfers than kiters? Maybe you are thinking of the boom years of the late 70s.

Still it's a lot safer than going shopping in Bagdad.

www.abc.net.au/news/2008-01-31/million-iraqis-dead-since-invasion-study/1028878
aus301
aus301
QLD
2039 posts
QLD, 2039 posts
31 Jan 2008 11:28pm
the figures could also be very subjective, all depends on how it is measured.

I mean, have they included people that were killed in a car on the way to kitesurfing, what about the difference between rigging and actually having the kite in the air, Land vs water based. And what about those that drowned that had very little to do with the fact they were kiting and the same thing could have happened no matter what the activity.

Most statistics can be swayed to make what ever point you want, the devil is in the details.
Wet Willy
Wet Willy
TAS
2317 posts
TAS, 2317 posts
1 Feb 2008 12:29am
"Dying doing something you love" is all well and good but don't forget you leave loved ones behind...plus it'd be better to survive the session and do that thing you love another day, wouldn't it???

Spinal injury would be worse than death in many ways, and that's a real danger in kiting...

Windsurfing can be dangerous, sure, but you make a choice, to sail in dangerous conditions, very high wind, reefs, rocks, big waves etc. In more sedate conditions - flattish water, maybe 20 knots of wind - no problemo. You're not gonna be unexpectedly slammed into the ground from 30 feet up.

I think it would be fair to say that kiting seems to be more dangerous in fairly normal conditions - a gust and a fumble, and you can be beach pizza...
yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
31 Jan 2008 11:06pm
You're not gonna be unexpectedly slammed into the ground from 30 feet up.

No, but 30% of windsurfers died after being hit/run down/chopped up by power boats, unexpectedly I presume.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12873 posts
WA, 12873 posts
31 Jan 2008 11:29pm
yoyo said...


No, but 30% of windsurfers died after being hit/run down/chopped up by power boats, unexpectedly I presume.


So I guess it isn't smart to try and force the "power gives way to sail" rule!
Wet Willy
Wet Willy
TAS
2317 posts
TAS, 2317 posts
1 Feb 2008 1:39am
Time for some lateral thinking... surely kite strings pose just a big a danger to jetskiers as to anyone else?

All we have to do is pit the kiters and jetskiers against each other, and with a little luck they'll wipe each other out.

And VOILA! Clear, safe waterways once again!
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
31 Jan 2008 11:54pm
Wet Willy I can see it now:

A big circle is marked out on an estuary, with entrances on the north for jetskiers, and on the south for kiters. Floating grandstands line the circumference, with hawkers selling hot dogs and suncream.

A loud hubbub gradually gives way to an expectant hush as the competitors gather outside the arena...

Then, 50 badly-distorted speakers screech out:
Gladiators, READY!
elmo
elmo
WA
8890 posts
WA, 8890 posts
1 Feb 2008 12:01am
yoyo said...

You're not gonna be unexpectedly slammed into the ground from 30 feet up.

No, but 30% of windsurfers died after being hit/run down/chopped up by power boats, unexpectedly I presume.


After having to dodge the ignorant pr1cks in their monstrous big cruisers on the weekend

I can believe it, they just didn't give a sh1t how close they got to you just as long as they didn't have to touch the throttle or change their line.
kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
1 Feb 2008 12:07am
65? thats pretty good going. statistically far better than driving in perth...
based on average 200,000 kiters over 7 years [1/10 perths population i think], 7 years so with say 200 people dead on wa roads per year so 650 Vs 1400
well its twice as dangerous in your car by those statistics.
mrrt
mrrt
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
1 Feb 2008 2:45am
yoyo said...

total number of windsurfers worldwide is 20 million

I find that hard to believe. I'm sure Auswind would say the numbers are even or kiting has the edge. Certainly at most beaches there are more kites than windsurfers


Not at Safety Bay or at Lucky Bay or Corronations (if I recall) from what I've seen. However, there are certainly more at Woodmans Point. What have others found? I think it probably varies a lot depending on the location. Because the kites take up so much more room they do seem to swamp the smaller windsurfers, but when you actually count the numbers I've usually found it's not as large a number as I first thought.


so where do you get the idea that there are 100x more windsurfers than kiters? Maybe you are thinking of the boom years of the late 70s.


All I can do is go by the statistics from these sources (who knows how correct they are (they are certainly all over the shop!), but I do admit I was surprised by the 20 million figure):

Number of windsurfers worldwide from an article published Sept. 2004

20 million windsurfers
"Windsurfing is a growing sport with over 20 million windsurfers
worldwide mostly aged between 15 and 40 years old."
Westcountrynow.com: September 2004
www.westcountrynow.com/?r=0.15720977&ref=417&month=9&year=2004

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of Boardsailing/Windsurfing participants (U.S.) 2000

Boardsailing/Windsurfing 655,000

Date: 08/22/01
Author: SGMA Press Release
www.wakeworld.com/news/2001/SGMA.asp

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of Boardsailing/Windsurfing participants (U.S.) 2003

Boardsailing/Windsurfing 779,000

Parks & Recreation, Oct, 2004
www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1145/is_10_39/ai_n6335474

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of Boardsailing/Windsurfing participants (U.S.) 2004

Boardsailing/Windsurfing 418,000
(participated at least once in 2004)

Ski Press Media : June 6, 2005
www.skipressworld.com/us/en/daily_news/2005/06/extreme_sgma_says_inline_skating_still_rules.html?cat=Snowlife

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of windsurfers in the U.S. from a 2002 article

"Windsurfing Industry.250,000 participants" (page 8)

US windsurfing News Newsletter
January February 2002
www.uswindsurfing.org/usw_library/newsletter/jan_feb02.pdf

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of kitesurfers worldwide 2006

"The population of kitesurfers is growing rapidly to around 150,000 to
200,000 kitesurfers world wide in 2006."
kitesurfingschool.org/faqs.htm#What%20is%20kitesurfing%20or%20kiteskiing%20or%20flysurfing

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of kitesurfers worldwide 2004

100,000 and 250,000 kite surfers worldwide.
userinnovation.mit.edu/papers/Working_Paper.pdf

"There are an estimated 200,000 kitesurfers worldwide."

Times Online: October 15, 2005
www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-1826946,00.html
www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-1826946,00.html

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of kitesurfers in the U.S. from a 2006 article.

U.S. more than 35,000

Number of kitesurfers in the UK from a 2006 article

UK 7,000 kite surfers

"Kite Surfing is the fastest growing water sport in the world. It is
not wind surfing, it is not wakeboarding, it is not surfing; it is not
kite flying. It is the fusion of these disciplines with other
influences to create the wildest new water sport for years.
Popularized by French and Hawaian stars in early 1999, The UK scene
now has approximately 7,000 kite surfers. The U.S. has more than five
times the number of kite surfers."

June 4, 2006 72.14.209.104/search?q=cache:tAhlmOzA24sJ:www.theopenpress.com/index.php%3Fa%3Dpress%26id%3D9999+%225000..300000+kite+surfers+%22&hl=en&gl=cl&ct=clnk&cd=3

As they say, lies, damned lies and statistics.

-Mart
roberto
roberto
NSW
190 posts
NSW, 190 posts
1 Feb 2008 9:32am
Robbo busted his wrist kiting a few days ago in Syd I heard through the grapevine.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
1 Feb 2008 9:52am
elmo said...


After having to dodge the ignorant pr1cks in their monstrous big cruisers on the weekend

I can believe it, they just didn't give a sh1t how close they got to you just as long as they didn't have to touch the throttle or change their line.


Time to fix an armour piercing tip to your board, puncture their hull below the waterline and sink the bastards



Haircut
Haircut
QLD
6491 posts
QLD, 6491 posts
1 Feb 2008 12:09pm
i'd reckon many of the kite accidents occur because people learn it very quickly and get to the point of zipping back and forth & jumping before they've had the opportunity to experience a broad range of wind conditions, particularly those folk with no sailing experience of any kind
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
1 Feb 2008 4:17pm
elmo said...

yoyo said...

You're not gonna be unexpectedly slammed into the ground from 30 feet up.

No, but 30% of windsurfers died after being hit/run down/chopped up by power boats, unexpectedly I presume.


After having to dodge the ignorant pr1cks in their monstrous big cruisers on the weekend

I can believe it, they just didn't give a sh1t how close they got to you just as long as they didn't have to touch the throttle or change their line.


Yeah agreed, some of them have even been on a collision course with me with nobody at the helm. The things are on auto-pilot in a tight channel! Then they wave to you from the back deck.

I think, on the Gold Coast at least, there are a lot of twats with more money than sense. The fact that you'd buy a $500K, 50ft, 20gallon/mile sports cruiser to go for short day trips kinda proves the point. His and hers matching jet-skis complete the picture.

BUT..., and I only learnt this recently, be aware that in a restricted channel YOU have to give way to THEM.

"Responsibilities between vessels

A vessel under power gives way to:
• blah blah blah...
• A sailing vessel (but see below).

A sailing vessel must keep clear of:
• A vessel not under command (evlPanda: open to debate or what?)
• A vessel unable to manoeuvre easily (including large vessels navigating in or near a channel or fairway)
• blah blah blah...
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14956 posts
QLD, 14956 posts
1 Feb 2008 3:39pm
this is why so many kitesurfers die.

some say stupid others say foolish!


Chris 249
Chris 249
NSW
3576 posts
NSW, 3576 posts
1 Feb 2008 4:50pm
If I wanted big air that much, I'd just go hang gliding or skydiving. I often wonder whether they look at kiters and windsurfers, and our "massive" 30 feet high jumps, and go - what the hell are they getting so excited about?

Sure, the sports are very different, but if big air is what it's all about - which is what some kiters seem to say when they say that's kiting's advantage over windsurfing - then why not get 25,000 feet of air instead of 30?
elmo
elmo
WA
8890 posts
WA, 8890 posts
1 Feb 2008 3:05pm
evlPanda said...

elmo said...

yoyo said...

You're not gonna be unexpectedly slammed into the ground from 30 feet up.

No, but 30% of windsurfers died after being hit/run down/chopped up by power boats, unexpectedly I presume.


After having to dodge the ignorant pr1cks in their monstrous big cruisers on the weekend

I can believe it, they just didn't give a sh1t how close they got to you just as long as they didn't have to touch the throttle or change their line.


Yeah agreed, some of them have even been on a collision course with me with nobody at the helm. The things are on auto-pilot in a tight channel! Then they wave to you from the back deck.

I think, on the Gold Coast at least, there are a lot of twats with more money than sense. The fact that you'd buy a $500K, 50ft, 20gallon/mile sports cruiser to go for short day trips kinda proves the point. His and hers matching jet-skis complete the picture.

BUT..., and I only learnt this recently, be aware that in a restricted channel YOU have to give way to THEM.

"Responsibilities between vessels

A vessel under power gives way to:
• blah blah blah...
• A sailing vessel (but see below).

A sailing vessel must keep clear of:
• A vessel not under command (evlPanda: open to debate or what?)
• A vessel unable to manoeuvre easily (including large vessels navigating in or near a channel or fairway)
• blah blah blah...



I tend to work of the principle of trying to avoid a collision with something which is not going to feel me as it goes over the top of me.

There lots of people in the afterlife muttering to themselves "But I had the right of way"
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅