Another fatal shark attack in WA

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
GPA
GPA
WA
2529 posts
GPA GPA
WA, 2529 posts
23 Oct 2011 10:38am
jbshack said...

Dawn Patrol said...

WestAussie said...

Yet another shark attack in Perth's shark 'Attack Zone'.




Gotta say, I'm not too sure I agree with that zone thing.
I could do a similar thing with car accidents. Highlight all the main roads and we have an attack zone.
There is a decent map of all the attacks i think in the kite forum. It clearly shows that more attacks occur in populated areas.


Works for me as i surf outside the zone so i'm fine..




hey JB...

Not sure about you... but I have been 'uneasy' far more times at Mullaz than Trigg or Scarbs... particularly at the northern end when the skies are grey and the water is murky... I was once down there mid week and there was a nice head high wave coming through and no one else out... I went to Trigg! Same with the reef break a touch further north...
Woodo
Woodo
WA
792 posts
WA, 792 posts
23 Oct 2011 10:50am
Was taken about a month ago as far as I'm aware. Definitly not a week ago.

jbshack said...

Woodo said...

Zuke said...

Thanks Woodo, I knew it was Rotto but wasn't sure about it being "real".

Suba, you're right. From the photo you can't be 100% sure, but if people were there and got a good look!


Apparantly it was a horse of a thing.


How long ago was it taken. It so another thread saying it was only last week? I'm sure i saw that pick about a month ago on Fishwrecked?


WestAussie
WestAussie
11 posts
11 posts
23 Oct 2011 11:02am
Really... you can't see the pattern emerging?

The 3 attacks that occurred at Rockingham, Garden Island and Rottnest Island (500m offshore) were in areas where very few people frequent the water. Compare this with WA's most crowded beaches (Scarborough to Mullaloo) that have had no attacks to date.

The reef habitat in the image provides an abundance of marine life which attract large sharks including seals, large fish and whales etc. The Swan River mouth opens up into the Attack Zone which happens to be close proximity to Cottesloe beach which would explain the attacks there. Mandurah also has an estuary in close proximity to the Attack Zone which would suggest that an attack may be more likely occur there also.

I don't believe sharks go around randomly attacking people. They are already in attack mode when they come across humans. If a shark comes to certain area chasing food they will be in attack mode and if humans happen to be in that area, there is an increased likelihood of attack. The area in the Google Earth image is arguably one such area. Other 'more popular' beaches in Perth outside of the area do not provide a food source which is why attacks are less likely to occur there.

Another point I'd like to make is why the hell is Colin Barnett trying to catch the shark responsible by baiting the waters of Rottnest? Firstly it is highly unlikely that the same shark will be caught. Secondly do we really wnt to be 'baiting' already aggressive sharks at our favourite holiday destination? This could result in a human and environmental tragedy. Nice going Col'n!


Dawn Patrol said...



There it is. I wonder what the chances of Perth, Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane all being located in 'attack zones'. Huge conspiracy


WATER MAN
WATER MAN
WA
139 posts
WA, 139 posts
23 Oct 2011 5:01pm
I wrote to the Sunday Times a few years ago about sharks on the coast. My point and theory back then was one I have only noticed due to fishing and being in the ocean weekly sometimes daily. I was informed that the big lady's will come into Tims Thicket to breed, I have then noticed the activity stays on or around the 5 Fathom bank. We have not seen any sharks of any great size inside of the 5 Fathom. I have had a shark follow behind our boat from James Service all the way to Coventry reef, I think it was just looking for fish we were throwing back or an easy bite of a hooked fish. I know they are following the Snapper, maybe the Snapper are following the reef too.
I have read by some people on Perth Now that the diver wasn't the best taste for the shark that is why it only bit and spat. I think the steel tank and sudden blast of air must have scared the living crap out of it and had second thoughts about the big bite. That shark would have nicked off real quick and deep. My thoughts would bee 100Km North/South or the shipping lane Gauge Roads into Cockburn. Don't think it will be seen for a few day's if not weeks.
jbshack
jbshack
WA
6913 posts
WA, 6913 posts
23 Oct 2011 6:55pm
Woodo said...

Was taken about a month ago as far as I'm aware. Definitly not a week ago.

jbshack said...

Woodo said...

Zuke said...

Thanks Woodo, I knew it was Rotto but wasn't sure about it being "real".

Suba, you're right. From the photo you can't be 100% sure, but if people were there and got a good look!


Apparantly it was a horse of a thing.


How long ago was it taken. It so another thread saying it was only last week? I'm sure i saw that pick about a month ago on Fishwrecked?





That just shows that people talk crap. I saw this on SB on another thread saying it was taken only last week.[}:)] All just media and ignorance. Thanks for the info.
Great shot by the way.


Woodo
Woodo
WA
792 posts
WA, 792 posts
23 Oct 2011 7:29pm
^yep there are plenty of people out there who talk shlt.
I personally don't know the guy who's photo it is but have a few good mates who do and I can garauntee it was taken before the 30th of September.
weiry
weiry
QLD
5396 posts
QLD, 5396 posts
23 Oct 2011 11:59pm
Do Great white shark cage diving operators play a part in any of this?
my thinking is, if a gws is burleyd to a boat and finds a human surrounded by food 5 or 6 times a year for 5 years, then the shark swims around the coast and finds the same shape in the water, he's got to think tucker time.
1, GWS have some intelligence
2. GWS may then associate humans with food
3. GWS travel long distance's
4. this type of shark cage operations have been going on for 30 years now.

all i am saying is that it could play a small part .
WATER MAN
WATER MAN
WA
139 posts
WA, 139 posts
24 Oct 2011 10:00am
Does Rodney Fox ever get back in the water with out the cage?
jbshack
jbshack
WA
6913 posts
WA, 6913 posts
24 Oct 2011 5:54pm
WATER MAN said...

Does Rodney Fox ever get back in the water with out the cage?


Man he was hit twice..

A question would you perfer to die from a shark attack whilst surfing or on bleading out on the roadside driving to work?
WATER MAN
WATER MAN
WA
139 posts
WA, 139 posts
27 Oct 2011 7:05pm
Road side.
I might be different to others, but I might be bleeding but I still would be breathing, although slowly. If a shark gets you, you drown too. My big fear.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅