stub nosed SUPs like the surf slate & raptor

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
burleighlocal
burleighlocal
255 posts
255 posts
22 Sep 2015 7:14am
IMO are average at best and never ridden by the pros for that very reason.

I've now ridden 4 different brands and all are rubbish imo. I know this goes against the usual exurberance often seen on sea breeze but the whole market for these seems more as a result of customer demand rather than a surf design. I watch the way they surf and I see a product that wallows in the water and displaces more water than usual is slow and never really get onto a plane as a more accepted style of board does. The board companies even seem embarrassed by the product as their marketing is low key and their sponsored riders never promote the product.

…then again I could be 100% wrong. Did I mention this is all IMO?
MickMc
MickMc
VIC
456 posts
VIC, 456 posts
22 Sep 2015 9:18am
It's opposites day!
Stev0
Stev0
422 posts
422 posts
22 Sep 2015 8:08am
The Deep Minion is by far the fastest and most fun board I have ridden and I have had 4 different traditional shapes from Naish, Fanatic, LSD, Starboard…IMO.
HGFish
HGFish
NSW
148 posts
NSW, 148 posts
22 Sep 2015 11:34am
Horses for courses IMO, there is no one board perfect for all conditions. Pro's not riding them might be a bit more about the conditions they get to surf / film in rather than the design (a quick search on YouTube will show a few pro's enjoying and making these boards look good in less than perfect conditions). If we were blessed with perfect smooth 3'- 4'+ waves all the time, then maybe I wouldn't own one, but for what we have most of the time, I haven't had a more fun board (9 in the last 2 years and quiver is now down to 2).

is slow and never really get onto a plane as a more accepted style of board does.



Here I have to disagree - the 3 different manufacturers versions that I have ridden all accelerate with the slightest pressure on the front foot, it's in fact one of the things I enjoy about this style of board, fast and responsive, then there's the extra stability factor as well.

I can't ride a 7'1" x 24" or even a 7'4" x 25" (maybe should clarify, could probably surf them OK, but would have to be a prone start) zero chance of standing in the line up waiting for a wave but I can stand pretty comfortably on my 7'2" x 27" and have a heap of fun in most conditions.
wazza66
wazza66
QLD
622 posts
QLD, 622 posts
22 Sep 2015 7:33pm
That is what makes the world such an interesting place ....imagine if we all liked the same boards.

I have a Deep minion on my rack and it is not the ultimate board for everything and I use a traditional short board shape 7'8 as well. I also surf a 10'6 when the need arises. I find that the minionit is fast and loose but you have to change the way you surf a bit. They are a fragile tail shape as I have knocked both points of mine off just getting caught on the rail saver. I do believe the Minion mk 11 model will have a more user friendly, less points tail. They are a fun type of board which is still to be tested in anything bigger than 3/4 foot as yet.

I still don't think there is a 1 board does it all board and sometimes people get swept along with a new shape , non traditional style board.

Some guys love them and some guys don't .There is still more boards out there to try till you find your pearl. Happy board hunting
Zeusman
Zeusman
QLD
1363 posts
QLD, 1363 posts
22 Sep 2015 7:53pm
I believe Zane Schweitzer has been using the Hypernut in most contests of late. And in one of the latest mags there are several pics of him ripping on one.
Towny
Towny
NSW
903 posts
NSW, 903 posts
23 Sep 2015 5:37am
The pros are all young and ultra fit, they ride 7.0ft boards anyway, I personally reckon these vanguard style of boards suit the middle aged gent that wants a board that's small, easy to handle and can still throw it around in the surf
Kami
Kami
1566 posts
1566 posts
23 Sep 2015 4:39am
Towny said..
The pros are all young and ultra fit, they ride 7.0ft boards anyway, I personally reckon these vanguard style of boards suit the middle aged gent that wants a board that's small, easy to handle and can still throw it around in the surf

100% agree with you, Vangard style of boards are the ones to get fun and be radical too.
Stev0
Stev0
422 posts
422 posts
23 Sep 2015 6:44am
Towny said..
The pros are all young and ultra fit, they ride 7.0ft boards anyway, I personally reckon these vanguard style of boards suit the middle aged gent that wants a board that's small, easy to handle and can still throw it around in the surf


Um…I was going to say that too but was too embarrassed

Saying that I love the Mininion, I also have a larger more traditional Fish style board for the choppy sessions and would LOVE to have a full-on trad surf shape for larger faster primo waves on reef breaks - but I don't get to surf those conditions very often to make the investment. So the Minion/Vanguard shape rips for me as an experienced 'gentleman surfer' in waist to head high beach breaks.
JeanG
JeanG
161 posts
161 posts
23 Sep 2015 7:53am
Curvature of a 9'6 board, stability of an 8'6.

I'll pass.
hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
23 Sep 2015 8:43am
burleighlocal said..
IMO are average at best and never ridden by the pros for that very reason.

I've now ridden 4 different brands and all are rubbish imo. I know this goes against the usual exurberance often seen on sea breeze but the whole market for these seems more as a result of customer demand rather than a surf design. I watch the way they surf and I see a product that wallows in the water and displaces more water than usual is slow and never really get onto a plane as a more accepted style of board does. The board companies even seem embarrassed by the product as their marketing is low key and their sponsored riders never promote the product.

…then again I could be 100% wrong. Did I mention this is all IMO?



Gold! best post for a while :) Agree 100% they may feel good but they look like sh1t on a wave with anyone less than a pro on them.
stm
stm
VIC
165 posts
stm stm
VIC, 165 posts
23 Sep 2015 1:11pm
hilly said..

burleighlocal said..
IMO are average at best and never ridden by the pros for that very reason.

I've now ridden 4 different brands and all are rubbish imo. I know this goes against the usual exurberance often seen on sea breeze but the whole market for these seems more as a result of customer demand rather than a surf design. I watch the way they surf and I see a product that wallows in the water and displaces more water than usual is slow and never really get onto a plane as a more accepted style of board does. The board companies even seem embarrassed by the product as their marketing is low key and their sponsored riders never promote the product.

…then again I could be 100% wrong. Did I mention this is all IMO?




Gold! best post for a while :) Agree 100% they may feel good but they look like sh1t on a wave with anyone less than a pro on them.


Hilly , that's why we use them cause they feel good. Isn't that what its about. I haven't seen to many pro looking surfers on performance SUP on these forums either champ
bobajob
bobajob
QLD
1535 posts
QLD, 1535 posts
23 Sep 2015 4:33pm
I don't know how many pros ride a JP 10' 2" by 32, probably none. I wonder how I ever managed to have fun on it?
I guess the fun I've been having on the minion is all delusional as well.

.....So can anyone recommend me a board that a pro surfs really well so I can start to have some damned fun and look respectable!


Zeusman
Zeusman
QLD
1363 posts
QLD, 1363 posts
23 Sep 2015 4:37pm
bobajob said..
I don't know how many pros ride a JP 10' 2" by 32, probably none. I wonder how I ever managed to have fun on it?
I guess the fun I've been having on the minion is all delusional as well.

.....So can anyone recommend me a board that a pro surfs really well so I can start to have some damned fun and look respectable!




Gold!!
Brenno
Brenno
QLD
907 posts
QLD, 907 posts
23 Sep 2015 4:55pm
Zeusman said...
bobajob said..
I don't know how many pros ride a JP 10' 2" by 32, probably none. I wonder how I ever managed to have fun on it?
I guess the fun I've been having on the minion is all delusional as well.

.....So can anyone recommend me a board that a pro surfs really well so I can start to have some damned fun and look respectable!




Gold!!


Haha. Guess i was imagining my fun on my minion today too. Maybe i was still asleep in bed?!
I have both traditional and "ironing board" shapes and they excel in different conditions. The minion has made me a better sup surfer and if i ever manage to break it (doubt it), i'll be lining up for another one.
I don't choose a board cause i give a crap about what the "pros" are on, i go for a board that makes my middle aged life f'n great fun.
colas
colas
5379 posts
5379 posts
23 Sep 2015 3:56pm
A side effect of the stability of the "Tomo" ("Vanguard" actually... Tomo makes many different shapes) shape for SUPers is that you can drastically reduce the volume and width without struggling too much. At 100kg I am as stable on my 105l "Tomo" than a traditional shaped 125l (on which 110l is hell for me), and you can really feel the safety of a low volume board in hollow conditions, with the carving stability of a longer board.

burleighlocal, by reading you I think you only tried oversized boards for your weight & abilities? "never really get onto a plane" seems to indicate a too long board for example...
hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
23 Sep 2015 9:01pm


I haven't seen to many pro looking surfers on performance SUP on these forums either champ

Have to agree there
hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
23 Sep 2015 9:11pm
Stick your fat arsed board into this :)

tightlines
tightlines
WA
3509 posts
WA, 3509 posts
23 Sep 2015 9:28pm
See that's the thing if the crew on the fat arsed boards (yep I have one too) were lucky enough and good enough to surf waves like that they would be on boards for those conditions.
I mainly surf within a 100ks or so of Perth but mostly just the fat little reef break in front of my place so my 7'10 x 28 wide arsed door gets used most.
As soon as there is a bit of size and power I'm on the Stun Gun.
Jeroensurf
Jeroensurf
1122 posts
1122 posts
25 Sep 2015 2:11am
hilly said..
Stick your fat arsed board into this :)



The waves at my homespot feel like that when i,m on a wave, but somehow never look like that.

I think that is something a lot of us experience
All i can say is that i hope for the riders of the vid there waves don,t feel like mine
Slab
Slab
1125 posts
1125 posts
25 Sep 2015 4:54am
Review of the JP Slate by a very good surfer. Reckons they are for intermediates.

www.supgower.com/2015/03/jp-slate-review/
damo666
damo666
NSW
160 posts
NSW, 160 posts
25 Sep 2015 7:38am
I reckon it is the size people are riding?

In surfboard form these are design to be ridden super short. I'm 6ft & 80kg and the recommended size is a 5'4"-5'6", thats so you can overcome the parallel rails that dont really want to turn, and they feel pretty boaty otherwise.

In SUP form you see guys on 8ft+ boards, I reckon you need to go well under 7'5" to really get the benefit of these?
Tux
Tux
VIC
3829 posts
Tux Tux
VIC, 3829 posts
25 Sep 2015 7:50am
hilly said..
Stick your fat arsed board into this :)



I think you have missed the point of the boards...they don't have a fat ass at all (I am talking the surf ones)...my 5'10 x 19 x 3 has less tail area then my usual 6'4.....just saying
cantSUPenough
cantSUPenough
VIC
2131 posts
VIC, 2131 posts
25 Sep 2015 2:54pm
Nobody likes me.

Most proners don't like my SUP.

Some SUPers don't like my Minion.

And people who aren't color blind don't like my design.

Yet somehow I still manage to have fun.
warwickl
warwickl
NSW
2360 posts
NSW, 2360 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:41pm




This my 7'4"×28.75 with eyes called the "Hammer Head " and its perfect for my surf conditions
warwickl
warwickl
NSW
2360 posts
NSW, 2360 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:45pm



Sorry the pic should have been these
warwickl
warwickl
NSW
2360 posts
NSW, 2360 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:48pm




Eyes front corners really adds a lot to my skill
cantSUPenough
cantSUPenough
VIC
2131 posts
VIC, 2131 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:51pm
Are its eyes closed in the first photo?
warwickl
warwickl
NSW
2360 posts
NSW, 2360 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:54pm
I stuffed up adding photo.
The first is my 8' ×31" pocket rocket.
warwickl
warwickl
NSW
2360 posts
NSW, 2360 posts
25 Sep 2015 9:56pm
And yes still manage to have fun on them like you
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
25 Sep 2015 10:05pm
cantSUPenough said...
Nobody likes me.

Most proners don't like my SUP.

Some SUPers don't like my Minion.

And people who aren't color blind don't like my design.

Yet somehow I still manage to have fun.

Now that's a great post!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅