Lets not make this a nanny state for PFDs as well......
Greg
Hey Greg - unfortunately it is too late. We are already a nanny state for PFDs. These races have to get NSW Maritime approval and they (NM) have stipulated PFDs have to be "worn".
I asked Dean Gardiner (who is probably the most experienced organiser of ocean races in Australia ala The Doctor, Fenn Cup, Austalian Ocean Racing series etc) and he directed me to his the rules for his series:
"All paddlers must wear lifejackets capable of supporting their own weight (can not be blow up type unless they are fitted with a cannister that inflates the jacket)."Greg, you might be a great swimmer but many paddlers are not. There will be over 300 paddlers in the 20 Beaches and I am sure some of them are not proficient swimmers. Paddlers wearing PFDs give the race organisers the confidance (and legal assurances) to put on races in extreme downwind conditions.
I find it a pain in the arse too but I would much rather do awesome and interesting races than to dumb the whole thing down so we don't have to wear PFDs.
I have raced surf skis in South Africa and those events are extreme. I did a race in Durban 2007. Of the 150 starters, around 20 of them lost their skis...even though they had leashes - the leashes just snapped. The whole French team lost thier skis. One of the skis was found 400km up the coast in Mozambique! Luckily all paddlers were rescued, however, some spent up to half an hour bobbing around in pretty wild conditions without PFDs.
So there was a choice to be made. Tone down the races or wear PFDs and keep them extreme. From that point, all ocean paddling races in SA require PFDs to be worn.
Here is some video of the race I was talking about.