international Mini 5.6 rule question

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
19 Dec 2015 12:20pm
Are 16" bicycle wheels legal or illegal for the international mini 5.6 landsailing class?
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Dec 2015 4:57pm
From the current discussion on the rules NO, In the original rules they just got through as a front wheel because they can't take the forces as a real wheel but the proposed defined rues they are quoting 'tyre size'.

So don't waste your thoughts on bicycle wheels.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Dec 2015 9:46pm
oops sorry 'rear wheel' (auto correct)

JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
20 Dec 2015 2:14am
Thanks Gizmo, I just recently got finished building a landsailer of my own design without planning on racing it. After the fact I realized that it might fit in the mini 5.6 class but it has 16" bike wheels and tires all around (the back ones flex a ton and have a limited lifespan). If I ever decide to race it then it'll need some modification. I do live hundreds of miles from the nearest landyacht races so it's not a huge deal at the moment.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
20 Dec 2015 5:52am
Yes many years ago I also tried 16" bike wheels the problem is the tyre tends to roll off the rim when pushed hard, and I know of others that also had used them where the metal spokes broke after a short time of use.
As a general rule with land yachts is do it with proven designs it will save time and money in the long run, there isn't much people haven't tried at one point or another in this sport.
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
20 Dec 2015 3:50am
I currently have plastic bike wheels that just bend. I was planning on upgrading to metal spoked wheels but I may just go straight to something sturdier instead. I'm tempted to try making one with two wheels in front and single rear wheel steering sometime. Is that just a bad crazy idea?
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
20 Dec 2015 12:19pm
JAronstein said..
I'm tempted to try making one with two wheels in front and single rear wheel steering sometime. Is that just a bad crazy idea?


Yeh I'm currently running a stern steerer. You can check it out along with the discussion here.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Land-Yacht-Sailing/Construction/56-sternsteer-land-yacht-idea-a-bad-idea/?page=1

Great to have you on board too JAonstein. Welcome.
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
20 Dec 2015 8:30pm
even when you build a really strong 16" wheel with a maxed out tyre(16x2.3) and have a heavy tube and 2" wide rimscarbon reinforced the tyre simply doesnt have enough contact are to prevent lateral movement on the rear. 8x4.00 wheelbarrow wheels solve that
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
22 Dec 2015 12:31am
Thanks Chook2, It's good to be here! I'm gonna sail the wheels off of mine,(might not take that long) then i'll be installing some wheelbarrow wheels. Is it possible to use the same axle mounts that I'm using for bike wheels or will I need to cut them off and make something new? my bike wheels are mounted identically to how bikes have their wheels mounted, with a fork going over the wheel and an axle mount on each side.
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
23 Dec 2015 9:47pm
All my yachts have stub axles that take 20mm ID bearings. (6204 2RS) 47mm OD x 20mm ID x 14mm wide.

I'm slowly turning them over to 6204 2RS SS, which are in stainless steel to ease the corrosion hassles.
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
25 Dec 2015 4:29am
Chook2 said..
All my yachts have stub axles that take 20mm ID bearings. (6204 2RS) 47mm OD x 20mm ID x 14mm wide.

I'm slowly turning them over to 6204 2RS SS, which are in stainless steel to ease the corrosion hassles.


I'm sorry. Can you explain what 6204 2rs means?
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
25 Dec 2015 5:13am
The 6204 is a universal bearing numbering system that most manufacturers use that refers to type and sizing The 2rs means 2 rubber seals (the black ones one each side) you can also have metal shielded non contact seals ZZ that have lower friction but less sealing against grit etc (serious racing?) or LLU which are usually red coloured seals and are recommended for dusty environments etc These carry a penalty of even more friction

It is possible to buy say a ZZ sealed bearing and an RS sealed bearing of the same size and swap one seal out of each and keep the rubber seals to the outside of the wheel to give a little less friction over the all rubber sealed bearings (They pick out easily)

You can get a lot of info online from the bearing manufacturers but thats the essence of it

Chooks method of sticking to 20mm axles is a good one as that size has proven to be strong enough and the metric size fits metric bearings which because of
the volume made in that size usually are cheaper and easily obtainable
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
25 Dec 2015 1:48pm
thanks hiko for all the great info. hope that wasn't a dumb question.
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
29 Dec 2015 11:26am
JAronstein said..
thanks hiko for all the great info. hope that wasn't a dumb question.


no such thing. only dumb mistakes.
thats exactly the kind of reason we come here.
if however you make a dumb mistake please tell us about it. even better a video .
with all the wheels ive built ive settled on 6004 bearings . still a 20mm centre ,but narrower OD. seem to get a better life out of them
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
29 Dec 2015 2:50pm
landyacht said..





JAronstein said..
thanks hiko for all the great info. hope that wasn't a dumb question.







no such thing. only dumb mistakes.
thats exactly the kind of reason we come here.
if however you make a dumb mistake please tell us about it. even better a video .
with all the wheels ive built ive settled on 6004 bearings . still a 20mm centre ,but narrower OD. seem to get a better life out of them






Well I made a dumb mistake right there guys!!!!!
When I just checked them, all my bearings are just as Landyacht has described above. They are 6004 2RS.

Doesn't pay to trust your memory when you are an old fart like me.
Sorry bout that.

Great info Hiko!!!
Test pilot 1
Test pilot 1
WA
1430 posts
WA, 1430 posts
29 Dec 2015 8:00pm
Ive found that removing the inner seals on the bearings makes it easier to clean and wash after sailing on salt, no need to replace as any salty, gritty liquid will drain out during use!
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
30 Dec 2015 9:45am
No such thing as a dumb question if something is learned from it
No such thing as a dumb mistake either if it serves as a bad example !
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
30 Dec 2015 3:06pm
i haven't been landsailing long enough to make any dumb mistakes related to it. at least nothing big, dangerous, or memorable. and my sailboat hasn't been struck by lightning yet which must count for something
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
31 Dec 2015 9:50pm
Chook2 said..

landyacht said..






JAronstein said..
thanks hiko for all the great info. hope that wasn't a dumb question.








no such thing. only dumb mistakes.
thats exactly the kind of reason we come here.
if however you make a dumb mistake please tell us about it. even better a video .
with all the wheels ive built ive settled on 6004 bearings . still a 20mm centre ,but narrower OD. seem to get a better life out of them







Well I made a dumb mistake right there guys!!!!!
When I just checked them, all my bearings are just as Landyacht has described above. They are 6004 2RS.

Doesn't pay to trust your memory when you are an old fart like me.
Sorry bout that.

Great info Hiko!!!


we changed to a 6004 in the fallshaws because the nylon bush ws thicker and didnt distort as much also didnt tend to pop out of the placcy wheel as it aged . the i found they were longer lasting
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
8 Jan 2016 4:20am
will a 5/8 inch(about15mm) axle be strong enough or should I plan on 3/4 inch?
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
8 Jan 2016 3:14pm
5/8 will be fine for light duty yacht. blokarts started with 15mm then moved up to 17, .
on lefroy we simply snapped 15's(5/8)
we use 20mm simply because they are the narrowest thats readily available in a range of typesand tempers, cheap to buy, range of sizes,bearings readily available.
next metric size down thats off the shelf is 16mm and everything gets complicated
GeoffSobering
GeoffSobering
59 posts
59 posts
9 Jan 2016 12:35am
Just a data-point: I've been sailing 15mm axles/bearings on my blokart for years without bending an axle or other problem.
I sail hard and weigh 115kg (255 lbs).

I don't know what the blokart axles are made out of. I would guess some kind of stainless steel.

Having said that, I'm switching to 17mm axles/bearings when I wear out my current set of bearings (which is taking longer than I anticipated...).

Cheers,

Geoff S.
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
9 Jan 2016 6:28pm
never seen a bent blokart axle, but they must have changed for a reason. the lovely fibreglass axles on the blowie probable save the axles.
at 115 kg you are in the lighter range of blokart pilots that ive met
keep in mind that us homebuilders are using hardware store HT bolts
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
9 Jan 2016 6:34pm
landyacht said..
never seen a bent blokart axle, but they must have changed for a reason. the lovely fibreglass axles on the blowie probable save the axles.
at 115 kg you are in the lighter range of blokart pilots that ive met
keep in mind that us homebuilders are using hardware store HT bolts


actually just realized seen 1 bender, drunked idiot sailed into bog on pink lake. own fault,but replaced on warranty
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
10 Jan 2016 5:56am
There have been a few bent 17mm class 5 axles here I have been told
20mm has become the standard for them
Spacers between the bearings with the end nut done up tight effectively increases the axle diameter in the wheel area
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
10 Jan 2016 7:43pm
Hiko said..
There have been a few bent 17mm class 5 axles here I have been told
20mm has become the standard for them
Spacers between the bearings with the end nut done up tight effectively increases the axle diameter in the wheel area


never thought of those spacers like that. I rely on them yo prevent the bearings getting sloppy
JAronstein
JAronstein
32 posts
32 posts
11 Jan 2016 12:51am
thanks everybody! I was planning on 20 mm just to be safe but I cant find 20mm ID bearings to fit my new wheelbarrow wheels. I guess I'm stuck with something smaller. When I make new axle mounts on the yacht frame i'll plan for possibly increasing the diameter in the future. I'm just going to use a bolt for the axle. Also I broke one of my plastic wheels yesterday so I can't go sailing until I get this wheelbarrow conversion done.
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
11 Jan 2016 5:03pm
Surprising you cannot find 20mm bearings they are plain vanilla world wide Even the USA I would have thought
If you must 3/4 inch is very close maybe you can get those to match wheelbarrow wheels in your area
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
11 Jan 2016 5:07pm
landyacht said..

Hiko said..
There have been a few bent 17mm class 5 axles here I have been told
20mm has become the standard for them
Spacers between the bearings with the end nut done up tight effectively increases the axle diameter in the wheel area



never thought of those spacers like that. I rely on them yo prevent the bearings getting sloppy


Spacers done up tight have saved a few skinny axles in this neck of the woods
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
11 Jan 2016 8:36pm
Hiko said..
Surprising you cannot find 20mm bearings they are plain vanilla world wide Even the USA I would have thought
If you must 3/4 inch is very close maybe you can get those to match wheelbarrow wheels in your area


im guessing it would be 1",3/4"9/16"5/8"
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅