OFFICIAL LAKE LEFROY LANDSAILING CLUB MINI SPECS

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Robi
Robi
9 posts
9 posts
2 Jan 2008 3:40am
landyacht said...
thats a lot of sail bling your adding. . Make your yacht bigger,and your sailing area clearer,bigger to allow you time to didle around. also let other landsailors get out of the way because your going to be rather busy sorting your tanged lines.
I'd say yiu have this all pretty well sorted so the next thing to do is go try it. I did ,and i learned all those lessons . Gosh that was almost 30 years ago!
I hear ya, more stuff added to anything just complicates it even more.

Maybe the whole downhaul/mast brebend thing only works on taller more sail area rigs.

But in all honesty ive been doing all that already sailing my singlehanded spinaker boat. You want to talk about a spaghetti of lines, I know what its all about. Plus sailing the cat in a crowded fleet you must be on top of your game at all times.

I dont see how much more different it will be on a landyacht. Maybe im trying to reinvent the circle, but seeing how there is NO landyachting here in my area I am willing to try anything.

hills
hills
SA
1622 posts
SA, 1622 posts
2 Jan 2008 11:04am
bazl said...

hills said...

I really like the way Pauls PM seat sits down over the tubes.




Can't say I am familiar with this concept, hopefully all will become clear when Susan posts up the pics she promised..


Here's a pic of Promo-girl's promo from underneath. Really nice looking landyacht, no doubt about it, but see how the seat just sits on top of the chassis, whereas my seat below (designed by Paul BTW ) you can see from the top where the seat is moulded around the chassis and therefore sits a little lower (sorry, you'll have to open it)





Don't get me wrong, I'm not against limiting the build to make it fairer, but I just thought some of these rules are just cosmetic. I agree with not being able to put on $2k wheels and sails as I can see that would make a huge difference, but why take off the braces between the "y" for example. That just makes it a little stronger.

Anyway, I'm not planning on racing internationally anytime soon so I should probably just but out and leave it to the professionals

So Paul, when are you releasing the Pacific Magic - Promo upgrade kit



landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
2 Jan 2008 7:30pm
bazl said...

The way I see it you can still tinker as much as you like within the confines of the Promo rules. Just means you dont need to mortgage the house to make simple changes.

You have seen the light my friend. same running gear in sails,wheels ,mast etc same speed and sensations,without the price. '
In reality there are no Australian class 5 yachts that would even begin to give the European yachts a run on any surface


heccles
heccles
WA
30 posts
WA, 30 posts
2 Jan 2008 8:17pm
landyacht said...

bazl said...

The way I see it you can still tinker as much as you like within the confines of the Promo rules. Just means you dont need to mortgage the house to make simple changes.

You have seen the light my friend. same running gear in sails,wheels ,mast etc same speed and sensations,without the price. '
In reality there are no Australian class 5 yachts that would even begin to give the European yachts a run on any surface



who cares how good the europeans yacht are ,how many clubs are there in the european area and how many do we have in aussie , compare us to nz if you have to, but still they also have more clubs according to web sites than her.so what is the go with the promo,from the photos i have see on web sitesit is not that much different to the ausie class5,and i cant see that any aussie would cost the dollars you are quoting

heccles
heccles
WA
30 posts
WA, 30 posts
2 Jan 2008 8:19pm
landyacht said...

bazl said...

The way I see it you can still tinker as much as you like within the confines of the Promo rules. Just means you dont need to mortgage the house to make simple changes.

You have seen the light my friend. same running gear in sails,wheels ,mast etc same speed and sensations,without the price. '
In reality there are no Australian class 5 yachts that would even begin to give the European yachts a run on any surface





landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
2 Jan 2008 9:54pm
The only problem with the pm seat is that it really only fits the PM or a mongrelized fed 5. promogirls new PROMO seat is a lot more universal,and drier. mind you after sailing with ner new helmet she is now insisting on a neck cushion, so why did I design a new seat?
heccles
heccles
WA
30 posts
WA, 30 posts
3 Jan 2008 9:48pm
Promo girl said...

Hi Hills, there is a number of differences between international cl5 and promo class 5. Promo's are class 5's but not all class 5's are Promos.

Class 5 for quite a number of years was very big internationally and developments in the class were fast and furious. FISLY often had to interpret or allow/disallow various new ideas that people came up with. However internationally over the last 5-7 years to be competetive on a international racing stage you needed an ever increasing pocket as advancements became more and more costly. Here in Australia we tend to hang on to our yachts for several seasons and can still race locally at a good level. This is not the case elsewhere. Last years yacht design in class 5 was old and slow.

There have been several attempts to regulate class 5 to a more *one design* or cheaper version - both here in Aus and internationally. The Club 88, FEd 5's and Pacific Magics are all examples of this. Aussies started modifying Pacific Magics at about chassis no 7.

One design classes can and do work as Standart as shown.

The Promo class 5 is another attempt to regulate class 5 as a cheaper and simpler land yacht that can be built and raced internationally on a reasonably level playing field rather than just on who has the most money. The big advantage that Promo has over other attempts to regulate class 5 is that it has been ratified by FISLY, none of the others had.

It is currently being raced in Europe (mainly France at the moment), several Sth American countries and here in Aus.

Interestingly enough with the exception of your Pacific Magic mast step your class 5 would be close to fitting into Promo rules.

I like racing class 5, it is fast and fun. However my posket is not deep. Internationally my yachts have not been competetive for some time. However my new Promo is now up there with the best and cost just over $2000 to build.

Promo class still allows quite a latitude for personal design and expression however you need to use a relatively simple chassis, wheel barrow wheels and a dacron sail.

I won't bore you with any further differences between Promo's and Class 5's best way to see the difference is look in the FISLY specs. (Aussie class 5 rules are donkeys years behind the rest of the world)

I'll find some photos of my yacht and post.
cheers
Promo Girl
i have just gone thru the fisly rules all 83 pages by the way and see that the only differences between the fisly cl5 and aussie ci 5 are rules b2@s1 on page 24 ,am i missing something as in the way i see it that does not put the adelaide rule book donkey years behind the rest of world

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
4 Jan 2008 12:13am
The important equalizers. in the promos are the wheels, and the simplified sail designs. these are yachts WE can build.
It is important to realize that on a world scale Australian land yachts are comparable to europe circa .1988. the top NZ cl 5 ( those which raced at the Pacrimin 2006) would be comparable to a competative yacht in about 1998. . the spending and development in Europe and NZ that led to these yachts has killed the class as people moved to other things. In NZ it led to the development of the BlOKART. the designer of this yacht should be given a medal for saving landyachting in NZ and australia by reinventing it and putting it out into the electronic universe. . It was suggested in a post somewhere around here that the blokart is nothing new , but I would suggest that is a well thought out machine that accomadates a huge range of requirements for sailors ,transport,diversity of saliing venues . types of pilots, etc.
you can bet that there will be many more blatant copies to come , but it will be interesting to see if they can match the professional marketing skills that BLOKART have added to the package.
Why dont I have a BLOKART? because I love to build,experiment etc and typically of Austalians and kiwis , I'ma tightarse when t comes to the money
In Europe the attempt to save landyachting has come in the form of the promo. it has just had its first international outing and is growing well , so time will tell how it grows.
Id be putting my money on private enterprise .
aus230
aus230
WA
1660 posts
WA, 1660 posts
4 Jan 2008 1:02am
I have been reading this discussion with interest, I keep hearing about the high cost of a class 5. I built aus 230 for $1800 I know it will never be competive overseas but has been a lot of fun to build and tinker with. Some of us find a need to experiment and not fit into a square box (one size fits all) I like the promos but nothing changes without experimetation .
Cheers
Vic

stevo bbb
stevo bbb
QLD
56 posts
QLD, 56 posts
4 Jan 2008 2:12am
FIRSTLY ROBI ,WITH A BLOKART YOU HAVE SEPERATE DOWNHAUL(FULLY ADJUSTABLE) AND MAINSHEET AND AS FAR AS ALL THIS DISCUSSION ABOUT DESIGNS OF KARTS AND THE CONFUSSION ,THIS IS WHERE BLOKARTS REALLY STAND OUT,ONE DESIGN WORLD WIDE!!!TAKE YOUR BLOKART TO JAPAN ,BELGIUM,AMERICA OR N.Z AND YOU CAN WALK ON TRACK KNOWING YOU CAN COMPETE ON A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD WITH SAILING SKILL BEING THE DETERMINING FACTOR .THE IDEA OF YOUR KART BECOMING OBSOLETE IS NOT A PROBLEM,WE HAVE GUYS RACING COMPETIVELY TOGETHER IN THE OLDEST AND NEWEST KARTS,NO PROBLEM!THERE HAS BEEN DEVELOPMENT WITH SAILS ETC. BUT AN OLD SAIL IS STILL O.K. AND THE BASIC FRAME DESIGN AND SPECS HAVE HARDLY ALTERED DUE TO THE PERFECTION OF PAUL BECKETTS ORIGINAL DESIGN AND RESEARCH,IT IS A REAL CREDIT TO HIM! STEVO
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
4 Jan 2008 7:08pm
hear,hear ,stevo
Promo girl
Promo girl
259 posts
259 posts
4 Jan 2008 7:58pm
heccles said <i have just gone thru the fisly rules all 83 pages by the way and see that the only differences between the fisly cl5 and aussie ci 5 are rules b2@s1 on page 24 ,am i missing something as in the way i see it that does not put the adelaide rule book donkey years behind the rest of world>

I said Aust cl 5 rules not Adelaide.

Despite the fact I have seen a couple of *drafts* for updates both for class Aust cl5 rules and ALSA sailing rules (least one in marked Jan 2006 draft). These drafts have not been accepted as we have not had a National Championships and AGM in many many years. I think you will find the last ratified ALSA sailing rules dates at 1991.

perhaps we better agree to diagree Heccles on the above points.

promo girl



heccles
heccles
WA
30 posts
WA, 30 posts
4 Jan 2008 9:11pm
Promo girl said...

heccles said <i have just gone thru the fisly rules all 83 pages by the way and see that the only differences between the fisly cl5 and aussie ci 5 are rules b2@s1 on page 24 ,am i missing something as in the way i see it that does not put the adelaide rule book donkey years behind the rest of world>

I said Aust cl 5 rules not Adelaide.

Despite the fact I have seen a couple of *drafts* for updates both for class Aust cl5 rules and ALSA sailing rules (least one in marked Jan 2006 draft). These drafts have not been accepted as we have not had a National Championships and AGM in many many years. I think you will find the last ratified ALSA sailing rules dates at 1991.

perhaps we better agree to diagree Heccles on the above points.

promo girl




well enlighten us what are the differences in rules ,you state that the rules are donkey years behind,where do you get your info from???

Promo girl
Promo girl
259 posts
259 posts
5 Jan 2008 5:26pm
<perhaps we better agree to diagree Heccles on the above points.

promo girl>

Heccles said <well enlighten us what are the differences in rules ,you state that the rules are donkey years behind,where do you get your info >

I have typed up a table that clearly shows the big differences and the small subtle differences between Aus Cl5 rules, FISlY Cl5 rules and Pacrim Cl5 rules. It is only when they are broken down like this and put against each other you can really see the differences. This table is in a word document. I need to find out how I can upload it without losing the table format. I may need to speak to Laurie 1st. But basically Heccles it will answer your question quite clearly.

Promo Girl

PS this is hardly a mini spec topic probably should be its own discussion - perhaps why has Australia not reviewed in class 5 specs for sooooo long???
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅