quick release the good the bad the down right sh!#

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Craig66
Craig66
NSW
2466 posts
NSW, 2466 posts
4 Jul 2010 10:59am
Am I alone in thinking that the preferred direction of movement to operate a quick release would be towards the body ????

I have always found it easier to pull on a rope over pushing on a rope

As for the 200kg loading, I recency was smacked by a large wave, fell in front of it and was sucked back up and over the falls.
At some stage I managed to PULL the quick release.
I'm about 100kg, so if there was a way to measure and add my weight + the water over me + the pull of the kite I have no dough 200kg would be achieved.
terminal
terminal
1421 posts
1421 posts
4 Jul 2010 9:03am
Craig66 said...

Am I alone in thinking that the preferred direction of movement to operate a quick release would be towards the body ????

I have always found it easier to pull on a rope over pushing on a rope



If the kite was dropping back into the powerzone in a sudden lull and was about to power up in a gust, its hard to pull against a slack powerline.

Craig66
Craig66
NSW
2466 posts
NSW, 2466 posts
4 Jul 2010 11:13am
terminal said...

Craig66 said...

Am I alone in thinking that the preferred direction of movement to operate a quick release would be towards the body ????

I have always found it easier to pull on a rope over pushing on a rope



If the kite was dropping back into the powerzone in a sudden lull and was about to power up in a gust, its hard to pull against a slack powerline.




Yes can see your point.

dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
4 Jul 2010 10:14am
Look at the test closely. The way the cabrinha knob is tied does not provide an even pull. The pressure is applied to the top part pushing down a relatively inflexible line that it then has to slide along. This part of the test has not been set up right and is the reason why the load shown is very high...

Andy76
Andy76
WA
13 posts
WA, 13 posts
4 Jul 2010 10:51am
orynoco said...

Adrenalin has fugg all to do with lab testing!!!!! Ask the Hulk if you dare!


Orynoco I am not referring to adrenalin... Its the thought process of getting to releasing the QR... How many times have you see a newbie been dragged wildy trying to save his kite and not thinking about his life... Once he realises how stupid he is being, he then has to find the QR and tries to release....

If the french are already testing QR's, what lab test do they undertake? does anybody know...?

This is the problem with a lot of hobby sports. An idea is put into construction, tested 10 times in the field, if it does not fail its put to the market.. We dont do that with planes, cars, houses, bridges etc, because of the life costs, so why here?. Its odd we use rated lines, but we put no thought to where the hole load is at its greatest?

Given the number of kites sold each year, to undertake proper R&D engineering and testing would equate to a couple of dollars to each kite..

Again my 2 cents....
PsYLoR
PsYLoR
QLD
927 posts
QLD, 927 posts
4 Jul 2010 1:57pm
sir ROWDY said...

You know what the best tried and tested quick release is for almost every situation?.... yep, you guessed it, UNHOOKING! Try it fools.


that and pulling down on the 5th line helps to.

Next they'll want airbags to pop out of the bar with auto release & ESP with built in sat nav!





Lovely
Lovely
QLD
248 posts
QLD, 248 posts
4 Jul 2010 2:25pm
This is a big issue!!
After watching how safety releases explode after load testing!!
Work Health and Safety must get involved and insist all kiteboarders wear an approved AS/NZS 1337 face shield to be able to safely activate their safety releases in high loaded situations.

I also believe we need effective safety leashes attached to the beach so if there is any problem (for example the rider isn't a good swimmer) one can climb up the safety leash back to the beach. I have thought about it and extra long ones are needed for down winders.
shannon8888
shannon8888
NSW
517 posts
NSW, 517 posts
4 Jul 2010 4:46pm
sir ROWDY said...

You know what the best tried and tested quick release is for almost every situation?.... yep, you guessed it, UNHOOKING! Try it fools.


agreed
Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
4 Jul 2010 5:49pm
May I add that perhaps a salted up used QR may not work as well as your brand new WD-40 sprayed shop tested QR. Also with basic physics that 25kg is 25 kg of force applied in the correct vector, most people in a panic situation will not pull in a completely straight direction and thus require more force to operate.
jas73
jas73
QLD
796 posts
QLD, 796 posts
4 Jul 2010 7:47pm
No matter what you think of the test (My thought that ist a load of bull ****) You are participating in a sport that has multiple risks and should learn to work with your gear or you just dont do it. I am sure every one that kites has a story of a near disaster or worse but thats the risk. We kite because its a thrill and something different to your average sports. But if you are going to whine about wether the makers of kites are making it SAFE enough then you should take up tennis or the like.
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
4 Jul 2010 6:17pm
There are so many things that can go wrong just getting out of bed..........look at the poor fellow who recently went kiting at Woodies. There is almost no kiter I know that hasn't had some scary thing happen. I've had 3 bars snap, chicken loop break, line break, canopy blow out, not to mention heaps of inversions.............. and I do try to ride "safe" gear.

Kite gear will progress further just like all things. I do trust that people who make kite equipment want safe stuff, and they will be the survivors. Late market entrants risk losing any chance if they compromise on safety.............but surprisingly some do...go figure.
dafunk
dafunk
QLD
561 posts
QLD, 561 posts
4 Jul 2010 10:08pm
25kg anit too much? take up something easier if its too hard for ya .
as long as the operator can use it .
and in a emergency everyone gets adrenalin power up
Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
4 Jul 2010 11:13pm
dafunk said...

25kg anit too much? take up something easier if its too hard for ya .
as long as the operator can use it .
and in a emergency everyone gets adrenalin power up


25 kg is WAAAAAAAAY to much... this isn't a bench pressing competiton. This is one hand quickly scrambling for the QR- you only get one shot.
Charl dv
Charl dv
WA
2485 posts
WA, 2485 posts
5 Jul 2010 1:59am
why is everyone using mass as a force unit?

accepted unit for force is newtons just in case anyone cared...

and yes you have to agree that the last QR looks older and more worn out than the fresh brand new 2010 releases used in first 2 trials.
mattyjee
mattyjee
WA
575 posts
WA, 575 posts
5 Jul 2010 7:36am
200 kg is a bit over the top. Yes its possible to build up this kind of force as you are accellerating upwards, etc... but the whole 200kg force would be very short lived, and the most you would be likely to have when pulling a quick release is your own body weight or less.

By definition, to have a force of 200kg means you are accellerating at 2g's horizontal or 1g vertical (for a 100kg person).

Do the test again at 80-100kg force. Also, pull the release using another block, not by hand. You can skew the results by jerking.
prea
prea
QLD
184 posts
QLD, 184 posts
5 Jul 2010 10:06am
jas73 said...

No matter what you think of the test (My thought that ist a load of bull ****) You are participating in a sport that has multiple risks and should learn to work with your gear or you just dont do it. I am sure every one that kites has a story of a near disaster or worse but thats the risk. We kite because its a thrill and something different to your average sports. But if you are going to whine about wether the makers of kites are making it SAFE enough then you should take up tennis or the like.


I have more injuries playing tennis
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅