goog64 said...
Here's a selection from the replies to my original question. Anyone notice a problem....
1. I think you can forget about 12-14 knots in the surf if you weigh 90kg
2. Can kite easy in 10 to 12 knts and 2to 3 foot surf with 10mtr rebel and 6'4 nsp fish lots of fun
3. use a kite no bigger than a 10m
4. Size does matter, end of story....the bigger kite will always be more powerful
Goog64
Opinions are like a***holes, we all have one. We are all full of it, like Schmik said.

On point 1
Well I've seen guys going it and enjoying themselves. Rich Stenning former double Aust Nat champ (80-85kgs') is often at Wanda in waves on a skimboard or Underground Freewave with no fins, in marginal conditions of 12-14 knots. Richies biggest kite is an 11M Cabrinha CB IDS. I see others there too on kites up to 14M in size, but I rarely see any kites in the surf bigger than that, that are seriously trying to ride waves. Anything over 14M just moves too slowly and will end up either not fun or in the water and getting pounded by waves and also not fun.
On point 2
No way, not riding upwind, downwinder maybe. I'm sure the rider does kite in waves with that board, but not in 10 knots, not upwind and not in fast breaking waves. The real wind will be more like 12-14 knots, he just does not realise it.
10 knots means that the wind is peaking at 10 knots and there will be lulls below, I cannot get going in flat water, upwind, on an Ozone Light XC 14M on an huge 1.44x46 TT in less that 12 knots. On a bigger inflatable on the same board I can go as low as 8-10 knots, I've used many different brands of big inflatables and foils.
On point 3
Use a faster flying and quicker turning modern kite, like the 13M Rev2 and Rev1, Ozone Light XC 12M or 14M, Best Waroo 09 13M, 08 is ok too, SS RPM 14M or 12M, etc, etc.
On point 4
True, but only up to a point as I've said above, bigger than 14M and I've never seen or flown a kite that moves quick enough to be regarded as a serious wave kite, although a bigger kite can still get you out in the ocean in light winds, you just might not be able to get in amongst the waves with it.
The bigger the kite, the better the board and kite skills need to be to ride in waves, or better put, the more experienced a rider is with that sort of gear in those lighter conditions the better they will do.
90kg does not mean you cannot surf in 12-14 knots, but that wind is really the lower end of the spectrum and you will have a lot more fun in just couple of knots more, like 14-16 knots (still on a 11-14M kite/and larger board combo).
Cya and
Goodwinds
Steve