Ive only been posting for a short time, but have been reading most posts on this forum over the last 7 months.
It is very frustrating when someone new asks a simple question, and other posters get so wound up around their own personal opinions that they
- either dont actually answer the question,
- veer off on weird tangents,
- or do answer with such overt and strongly worded know it all opinion that it may cause people to be reluctant to openly share in the future to avoid being smacked down. I certainly felt this way when I first started reading this forum and is why people generally read a long time before actually posting.
1. No where did anyone state that instructors should advocate the use of a leash.
2. No one has stated that a leash should replace lessons and lots of practice body dragging upwind.
3. No one is arguing that "once you get "better" you can suddenly do without a leash".
People have just been acknowledging that once one becomes more proficient and they start jumping and attempting other tricks - it therefore increase the chances of being hit by a board if you wear a leash, compared to someone who just rides out and back doing slide turns all day. It may therefore not be wise to wear one then.
The original question was "Do people use legrope or leash on their boards, to stop them wandering away after a stack? If not, why not? " He also indicated he has been taught to body drag up wind.
Making a statement like "
"Using a leash is a dead giveaway that you're a noob with no skills and most likely a noob that has been told by their instructor (assuming they have had lessons) to not use a leash, which makes you obstinate and inexperienced. A scary combination!"
This response really doesn't answer the guys question. It is rather insulting actually - especially to some experienced kiters all round the world who do use leashes. We all start off he same - inexperienced. If the guy wants to hook on a leash while he gets his kite sorted, and to maximise his time on the board each session - its his choice.
I would have thought what the 'experienced' kiters should be saying is to:
Learn to body drag upwind to reduce your chances of losing your board. Using a leash is not recommended as you increase the chance of hurting yourself - it is also not recommended by the IKO. If you do wear leash, make sure you use a reel leash and wear the correct safety gear. People have copped nasty injuries (& even been killed) by sling shotted boards. Even wearing the safety gear and using a reel leash still doesn't eliminate all the risk.
Clear statements - Its that simple.
At the end of the day - it is each individuals personal choice if they do or dont wear one. Let them know the risks - but leave the choice to be theirs rather than so arrogantly smacking others down after stating their views.
Statements like "If you start with a leash as a beginner you are obviously not good at upwind body dragging, hence the need for a leash." are also ultra opinionated.
I know several guys that arnt blessed with living on the beach, and have to drive an hour 25min each way. When you allow the time for pump up and pack up, it only leaves a few hours of kiting for a half a days effort, and they wear leashes to maximise their riding time in the half day a weekend they get due to their families commitments. They have obviously accepted the increased risks and would rather get up and going faster to maximise their time - especially in the surf when their boards would often get washed up. And yes - they have both had lessons and know how to body drag too

By the way, for the record - I dont wear a leash and I lost my board several weeks ago. I took 8hrs of lessons when I started, can body drag upwind (recovered my board on many occaisions on that day I lost it). But there is little you can do when a very strong current and lulling wind conspire against you not long before dark - you get separated from your board, the wind lulls but there is enough wind to keep you and your downed kite moving slowly towads hazards (rock groin, nav beacon and a jetty) - while the river current takes your board sailing away in a different direction with not enough wind to relaunch the kite. I chose to save the kite and try swim for the board once ashore, but once in the water in chop with glare from a low sun in the sky - I could not find it. Even some watchers on the shore said they lost site of it in the glare. A leash would have been handy for me in this instance.
It would be so nice if one could state a view without the smackdowns by obviously experienced guys - many of whom seem to suffer from a little tunnel vision, lack of open mindness yet have the "we'll do this as a team and do it my way" kind of approach. They seem to have forgotten what it was like when they were new.
Just give me a minute to put my Flame suit on



And like the crusty old shellbacks with 1000+ posts say :-
Goodwinds......