Speeding are we stupid?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
nick0
nick0
NSW
510 posts
NSW, 510 posts
3 Apr 2010 9:25pm
i only got my red P just 1 month ago so i have little to no experience ..id say as part or going from a lerners licence to a provisional licence should be ..defencive drivers cources and all the **** ... one thing i noticed as i drove home from a long day of windsurfing i was cruising at 60kph in a 70zone while i was drinking my thinkshake from macccas ... NO ONE OVER TOOK ME IN A 2LANE ROAD.... after i was done my drink and drifted baack up to 70 pl started to over take me ..only takes one person to influence the half dozen others around.
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
3 Apr 2010 11:44pm
Speed limits in Christchurch are 50KMH ... everywhere, even six lane roads. You feel like you could get out and run faster. Maybe you could.

Somebody pointed out to me the other night that when we received our licences we agreed to abide by all the rules. What happened?

Statistics and reactions to them are funny things - if as many people died from a new designer drug as road accidents there'd be a war on it. But we need cars, just like we need alcohol. We're addicted and defend our addictions accordingly.
ginger pom
ginger pom
VIC
1746 posts
VIC, 1746 posts
3 Apr 2010 11:57pm
evlPanda said...

if as many people died from a new designer drug as road accidents there'd be a war on it.


if as many people took designer drugs as drove, there wouldn't be war on anything. We'd all be cuddling and telling each other how much we loved them....
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
3 Apr 2010 9:34pm
rod_bunny said...
[The drivers licence test is the LOWEST 'acceptable' point of which people can drive a vehicle on a public road - what motivation is there to be a better driver? None - just fines for stepping outside the line determined by and for... the people who should'nt be there in the first place!

The driver test is essentially 'can you pilot this thing without hitting anything else for the next 10 minutes' - no training in defensive driving - no training in collision avoidance - no training in handling a slide etc. Why? because these things are much harder to implement and cost money rather than putting a cash generating hidden radar on the side of the road.


when I recently took my daughter for her test I would have been quite happy for her to drive home on her own. shes a geat little driver. But they tell me she now has to do25 more hours of supervised driving before sitting a computer test( that he passes every time at home) before qualifying for here P pates. Certainly not the Dumb test you are suggesting,
I now have to sit in the car whilst she does 100km return , trips to the next town, after the 3rd trip , I started sleeping through the whole trip
.Only 11 to go, 1100kms, 11hrs.
I can see why so many people are not bothering to get a drivers licence.
it would cost more than your first car just to get the licence
rod_bunny
rod_bunny
WA
1089 posts
WA, 1089 posts
3 Apr 2010 9:53pm
landyacht said...
when I recently took my daughter for her test I would have been quite happy for her to drive home on her own. shes a geat little driver. But they tell me she now has to do25 more hours of supervised driving before sitting a computer test( that he passes every time at home) before qualifying for here P pates. Certainly not the Dumb test you are suggesting,
I now have to sit in the car whilst she does 100km return , trips to the next town, after the 3rd trip , I started sleeping through the whole trip
.Only 11 to go, 1100kms, 11hrs.
I can see why so many people are not bothering to get a drivers licence.
it would cost more than your first car just to get the licence



So what does driving 100km (in mostly the same gear) teach her about accident avoidance, skid control etc - it creates a comfort zone of 'normal' driving - what happens when something out of the normal happen?

Dont get me wrong, I think the new tests are better than when I got my licence but still not teaching anything they wouldn't pick up driving normally.
j murray
j murray
SA
947 posts
SA, 947 posts
4 Apr 2010 8:36am

So Landyacht......have you ever seen an aboriginal car with "L" plates on it

or any of their kids doing log book hours. It dosent happen over this side

of the continent. Matter of observation, I dont think i have ever seen an

indigenous vehicle with red or green "P"s. one law for some , another

for others. Would their cars pass roadworthy?
rod_bunny
rod_bunny
WA
1089 posts
WA, 1089 posts
4 Apr 2010 10:49am
j murray said...


have you ever seen an aboriginal car


Are they the cars that were here before the holdens and fords turned up
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
4 Apr 2010 8:27pm
rod_bunny said...




So what does driving 100km (in mostly the same gear) teach her about accident avoidance, skid control etc - it creates a comfort zone of 'normal' driving - what happens when something out of the normal happen?

Dont get me wrong, I think the new tests are better than when I got my licence but still not teaching anything they wouldn't pick up driving normally.


I chose this particular regular route because of the direction and time of day.
she drives into a sunset on a major road with triple roadtrains going both ways on their last load of the day. mine workers are coming home after 12 hr shifts , half asleep and in a hurry
At the coolgardie end the Kangaroos are just coming out to feed and if it was a hot day the shire workers wont have picked up the pieces of exploded truck tyres till the next morning. If we get a thunderstorm or dust storm thats a bonus.
in a few more hours I will let her drive a return route on the Kambalda road.
that road has all of the above but the drivers are alot worse. that 55km road has one of the highest death tolls in the state, almost all of them tired workers doing something stupid


landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
4 Apr 2010 8:32pm
j murray said...


So Landyacht......have you ever seen an aboriginal car with "L" plates on it

or any of their kids doing log book hours. It dosent happen over this side

of the continent. Matter of observation, I dont think i have ever seen an

indigenous vehicle with red or green "P"s. one law for some , another

for others. Would their cars pass roadworthy?

i havent ever really noticed the racial or skin group of any Lor P platers. I have noticed how few of my kids mates have got thier licences tho. when we were young you did your test within days of our 17th birthday
rod_bunny
rod_bunny
WA
1089 posts
WA, 1089 posts
5 Apr 2010 9:28am
landyacht said...


I chose this particular regular route because of the direction and time of day.
she drives into a sunset on a major road with triple roadtrains going both ways on their last load of the day. mine workers are coming home after 12 hr shifts , half asleep and in a hurry
At the coolgardie end the Kangaroos are just coming out to feed and if it was a hot day the shire workers wont have picked up the pieces of exploded truck tyres till the next morning. If we get a thunderstorm or dust storm thats a bonus.
in a few more hours I will let her drive a return route on the Kambalda road.
that road has all of the above but the drivers are alot worse. that 55km road has one of the highest death tolls in the state, almost all of them tired workers doing something stupid


Sounds like you taking a thorough approach (wish all parents did the same) and yes that is a crap road.

You have the room out there... get her out on the lakes or in the gravel - show her what the car feels like out of the normal driving.

I gave my wife (then 18yr old girlfriend) a birthday present of a safe driving course (Boy was she pissed at me at the time [}:)] ) she spent a day on a skid pan doing crash avoidance and emergency turns and stops etc - the number of times that she has thanked me for that since then... snow and ice in the UK, diesel spill on roundabout, guy falling asleep and crashing right in front of her...

Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5124 posts
VIC, 5124 posts
6 Apr 2010 2:31pm
rod_bunny said...... accident avoidance...


The only accident avoidance techniques that work reliably are seeing hazards ahead and slowing down to to avoid them, and creating a buffer of space around you (ie. not tailgating and slowing or changing lanes to get away from other drivers).

rod_bunny said...... skid control etc ...


There's no such thing. Driving under the illusion that you can control a skid creates the potentially fatal situations of driving too fast and over correcting when a true skid occurs.

The only way you can maintain high performance driving skills is to practice them frequently. There's no way anybody could reliably put in several hours at a skid pan every month to hone the skills necessary to actively control a skidding car without making things worse.

Believing you are a high performance driver is exactly the reason 18-25 year old males are over represented in accident statistics.

Far better is to drive defensively by slowing down and maintaining a safety buffer around you and drive a modern car with all the safety bells and whistles (ABS and ESC) and drive it well within the capabilities of the systems and your skills.

Good driving has vey little to do with driving skill and everything to do with good judgement.

(BTW I just drove home after an Easter trip. The only hassle I had was a dickhead with high beams on approaching from behind. I briefly considered having a headlight war with him. Instead I immediately pulled over and let him get a long way ahead. Problem solved. Uneventful trip home.)
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
6 Apr 2010 12:50pm
Gorgo said...

rod_bunny said...... accident avoidance...








The only way you can maintain high performance driving skills is to practice them frequently. There's no way anybody could reliably put in several hours at a skid pan every month to hone the skills necessary to actively control a skidding car without making things worse.

Believing you are a high performance driver is exactly the reason 18-25 year old males are over represented in accident statistics.

Far better is to drive defensively by slowing down and maintaining a safety buffer around you and drive a modern car with all the safety bells and whistles (ABS and ESC) and drive it well within the capabilities of the systems and your skills.

Good driving has vey little to do with driving skill and everything to do with good judgement.



I wish I could get a few hours on a skid pan every month, I agree with what you have said in the rest of your post.
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
8 Apr 2010 12:14am
Gorgo said...

Good driving has vey little to do with driving skill and everything to do with good judgement.



Isn't that the truth.
FlySurfer
FlySurfer
NSW
4460 posts
NSW, 4460 posts
9 Apr 2010 4:47pm
A perspective from the USA:

Broke Cities Ravage Motorists
With Speeding Tickets
By Scott Teeters
4-9-10

GOCHA!!! That'll be $500, sir. Have a nice day and drive safely.

Recently, I was listening to Gerald Celente on The Jeff Rense Program on the internet, and Gerald mentioned that the previous weekend in the State of Virginia, almost 7,000 traffic tickets were issued in ONE WEEKEND!

Townships and states all across the Union are feeling the pressure of this Depression, so they are turning to police to help raise money through vehicle or traffic citations. Towns are installing surveillance cameras at intersections to catch drivers cutting a fast yellow light, running a red, not coming to a full stop, not stopping behind the line, etc. A camera catches license plate numbers and a computer sends the ticket in the mail. Pretty soon they'll just debit your checking account.

BEARS ARE MANNING THE SPEED TRAPS

Some townships, such as Medford Township, where I live in Southern
New Jersey, have lowered the speed limit on certain stretches of road, turning those roads into cash cows. I live very near one such road. Taunton Blvd in Medford, NJ has a 2-mile stretch that used to have 35-MPH posted. Now the speed limit is a crawl at 30-MPH. One morning around 9:15, I was sitting at the corner gas station at the intersection of Taunton Blvd and Tuckerton Rd and saw that the other three corners of the intersection had police cars with lights flashing like crazy while drivers were getting ticketed. The gas station owner said, "This has been going on since 7AM when I got here. One, right after another"

It is very obvious that, the local law is using traffic tickets to make up for loss of state and federal revenues. Last week I saw that my town will be raising school taxes because of a huge shortage of money from the State and Federal government. To make it up, the average local taxes will go up $300 per year ? about $25 a month.

The very same day that I read about my real estate taxes going up, I saw this headline in USA Today

"Speeding 'cushion' may dwindle due to recession"

Here's the USA Today link

usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-03-30-speeding-cushion_N.htm

The story has a lot of interesting statistics, but here's the bottom line. When you see a sign that says, "SPEED LIMIT" the word "LIMIT" means just that, "LIMIT" It doesn't mean 3-MPH, or 7, or 8-MPH over the limit. The "LIMIT" is THE LIMIT! The ticket book is coming out
and being used!

END OF ARGUMENT.

Where I live in New Jersey, a 45-minute drive could easily take me through 10 townships, each one with its police task force looking for the SLIGHTEST infraction of the law. ANY infraction of the law by the passing motorist!

FIRST TICKET IN 65 YEARS!

Here's a good one for you. My Mom and Dad live in a retirement community in rural Florida. It's quite common for the main road to have very little traffic. Dad's 81 years old, sharper than a tack, with excellent motor skills. He still thinks he's 41. They went to the grocery store one day and on the way out of the parking lot (with NO traffic in sight, BOTH ways), Dad didn't come to a FULL and COMPLETE STOP. Less that 1/4-mile down the road as they were turning into their community, all the sirens and lights were in his rear-view mirror. "What's the problem officer?" he asked. "You failed to come to a full stop sir. Here's your citation." This was his SECOND ticket in 65 years of driving. I said, "Well Dad, you were just overdue."

So, between the fine, court costs and a class he had to take to keep from getting points on his record, (if you get points, the insurance company wants to punish you too, even at 81-years of age) Dad made a $200 donation to his town. I said, "Gee Dad, that was VERY nice of you." He replied, "Yea, I'm SO nice."

"WELL, MAYBE THAT'S WHAT WE HAVE TO DO TO BE SAFE..."

Now if you're thinking, "Well, if that's what it takes to make things safer on the roads for everybody, maybe it's a good thing." Look, I know that car crashes can be devastating. But nailing drivers for minor infractions is nothing more than a regressive TAX. This is the same "logic" I hear concerning everything we have to do today to get on an airplane. Where does it end? REAL strip searches? Maybe we should be shackled to our seats? There was one plan I read about a few years ago that would have required passengers to wear RFID bracelets with a built in Taser device. "Well, if it keeps us safe" Over ten years ago I read that cars would one day be equipped with a camera that aimed at your eyes that would report to the authorities if your eyes weren't looking straight ahead and listening devices that will make sure your not arguing with someone. Can't have distractions, you know. For those with GM's OnStar systems, police can shut off your car if they choose. So where does it end?

And unfortunately the lower your income, the larger the impact will be for simply not coming to a full stop or being 3 MPH over the limit. A $200 fine for someone with an average income is a minor nuisance. The same fine for someone just eking by could mean not being able to buy groceries or medication. And you BETTER pay the fine or they'll put a warrant out for your arrest.

Having a Tough Time Financially? TOO BAD!

As this Depression continues on, and more and more townships struggle with their budgets, they WILL turn to this kind of regressive tax into income generation. And have you ever noticed that when government gets bigger, or new rules or fines are imposed, they never go away? They're permanent. So, if and when we ever get out of this Depression, don't expect townships to lower those fines. No way! They're going to start liking that extra money and they ain't about to stop that gravy train.

BE CAREFUL and PAY ATTENTION!

Look, times are tough and they are probably going to get tougher. Unless you are housebound or live in the city and only ever use public transportation, you have to use a car to get around. So when you're out going here and there, BE CAREFUL. PAY ATTENTION because your local police officers are no longer just "Keeping the Peace." Their Commanders have instructed them, "WRITE MORE TICKETS!" That means they're looking FOR YOU AND ME.





Who knew the "To Serve & protect" would
one day mean, "To Serve & Collect"?

To Serve & Protect

There's a common saying that's painted on many police cars that says, "To Serve and Protect." Perhaps it should be changed to, "To Serve and Collect." Police now have a new duty, to participate in tax collection. They start the process with a little piece of paper.

And one last thing. If you do get pulled over, you're GETTING A TICKET. Don't talk, don't try to explain or argue, unless you'd like a Taser experience. So, MOTORIST BEWARE! This is the only warning you're going to get!

Be careful out there,

K. Scott Teeters
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
25 Apr 2010 3:13pm
busterwa said...

late for work ?????????????!!



Somewhat akin to base jumping with the adrenal buzz prolonged by mechanical assistance. Like the intro said a total disregard for any kind of law, legal, moral or ethical.

choco
choco
SA
4181 posts
SA, 4181 posts
25 Apr 2010 3:58pm
It's interesting that they keep a road toll but more die from committing suicide but they don't run a tally on that on a daily basis as road accidents.
Anyway pic of a driver in Adelaide:
This is an actual photo taken by Transport SA last month at the corner of Trimmer Pde and Frederick Rd Seaton.

The wood was about 2 mtrs out of the left hand side and about three out of the right. The beams in the front window went across his chest and he could only get one hand on the wheel.

j murray
j murray
SA
947 posts
SA, 947 posts
26 Apr 2010 10:49am
Choco...... any info on nationality of driver, that should be released too.

All motorists are paying for unsuitable drivers now on Australia's roads.

Scenes are now common as one would unfortunately see in third world

the bar has been lowered, smashed, to allow people who in their country of

origin would never ever drive. It is madness, the lowest common denotational.
Buell
Buell
SA
89 posts
SA, 89 posts
26 Apr 2010 9:01pm
I like this, no, I really like this.




limiting heavy vehicles to 80k's would have enormous benefits with only the one obvious drawback of long haul trips taking about 20% longer.
It would -
Reduce the number of heavy vehicle accidents
Reduce the severity of the accidents
Reduce the amount of fuel consumed
Allow other motorists to pass them without breaking the law
Reduce the maintenance costs of trucking companies, tyres, brakes etc
Reduce the damage to our roads

I'm sure I'm going to get caned by any truck drivers on this forum but after 35 years of driving on our highways I've had a few positive interactions with heavy vehicles but most have been dangerously negative.
Anything the weight of a road train doing 100kph is simply not safe for all the other road users


rod_bunny
rod_bunny
WA
1089 posts
WA, 1089 posts
27 Apr 2010 9:32am
Buell said...

I like this, no, I really like this.





Hmmmm very simple isnt it.
Notice how there is no reference to multiple changes of speeds in varying zones...
If your in town 50
If your not in town and on a dual carriage way 110, a motorway 130

How is it that Poland with a more densely populated, shorter travel distances country can have such an elegant solution... and Australia with longer distances and lower pop. density need to have some massively complex, constantly changing, 'make your own mind up about what speed you should be doing cause the signage is so poor' system FOR EACH STATE!?

FlySurfer
FlySurfer
NSW
4460 posts
NSW, 4460 posts
27 Apr 2010 12:51pm
You want simple?




*We get












Police warned of speed sign loophole (I'm sure they've plugged it now)
www.theage.com.au/national/police-warned-of-speed-sign-loophole-20050627-ge0exo.html

Buell
Buell
SA
89 posts
SA, 89 posts
27 Apr 2010 6:10pm



How is it that Poland with a more densely populated, shorter travel distances country can have such an elegant solution... and Australia with longer distances and lower pop. density need to have some massively complex, constantly changing, 'make your own mind up about what speed you should be doing cause the signage is so poor' system FOR EACH STATE!?




Simple answer, too many politicians
stamp
stamp
QLD
2797 posts
QLD, 2797 posts
27 Apr 2010 7:09pm
buell- truckies are the best and most careful drivers on the road. they have to be.

limiting trucks to 80 won't solve anything, as you mentioned transport times will rise which in turn will cause prices associated with tranport to rise significantly, turnaround times to be longer, and drivers spending even longer out on the road.

motorists do stupid things to get past trucks as it is, imagine if trucks were even slower how many more idiots would try to overtake dangerously.

road congestion will also increase, especially on freeways.

Buell
Buell
SA
89 posts
SA, 89 posts
27 Apr 2010 9:00pm
Appreciate the response stamp, as you’ve read my post and know what my views are, you won’t be surprised when I say that I can’t agree with you.
If slowing down heavy vehicles is not going to have any effect on the crazy things that happen on our highways then another solution is to remove them altogether.
Rail is a vastly more economic method of moving freight from state to state. It’s a shame that consecutive governments over the last 30 years have let our rail system degenerate into something that most third world countries would be embarrassed to own.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
28 Apr 2010 2:57am
You've got that one right Buell. Freight by rail is the most economical tonne/klm form of goods transport.

This country desperately needs the high speed Darwin to Melbourne rail freight line via the heart lands. The government won't build it and expects private enterprise to do it.

I believe there should be little or no interstate heavy truck haulage of anything that can be handled by rail.

At night I see trucks get into a convoy of up to 6 trucks and fly up or down the highway at 130 kmh. Totally irresponsible and sheer madness.
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
28 Apr 2010 5:15pm
cisco said...

You've got that one right Buell. Freight by rail is the most economical tonne/klm form of goods transport.

This country desperately needs the high speed Darwin to Melbourne rail freight line via the heart lands. The government won't build it and expects private enterprise to do it.

I believe there should be little or no interstate heavy truck haulage of anything that can be handled by rail.

At night I see trucks get into a convoy of up to 6 trucks and fly up or down the highway at 130 kmh. Totally irresponsible and sheer madness.


I thought convoys were illegal?
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
29 Apr 2010 12:03am
doggie said...
I thought convoys were illegal?


Well I believe they are but how does the law define a convoy. It can only be by setting a minimum distance between trucks.

When I have seen them they have been very equally placed apart at about 30-50 metres. It is still a convoy in my books.

FlickySpinny
FlickySpinny
WA
657 posts
WA, 657 posts
29 Apr 2010 5:02pm
OK, this claim about the 70 mph limit in the UK....

Yeah, that's the official limit. Cops won't even look at you on a motorway unless you're doing over 85 mph if the conditions are good. Over take them at 85 and they won't touch you if you're driving sensibly.

If you're driving like an idiot they'll do you immediately.

Same as in France. In good conditions the limit is 130 kph - you can cruise straight past a copper at 147 and he won't bat an eyelid. I know, I've done it for years.

The problem in Australia isn't so much the speed limits (110kph on the Hume is FAR too slow in my opinion) but the extraordinary lack of freeway driving talent. The UK isn't brilliant, France is better, the Germans are the best, but they're all far better than here.

They keep left unless they're overtaking.

...and they don't tailgate.

It's taken a long time to get used to people deliberately undertaking in this country... cruise past a freeway exit in the 2nd left lane... don't pull in, because cars are going to be merging into that lane in a hundred meters... car comes up behind, and instead of using the empty outside lane, deliberately pulls into the left lane and undertakes right through my blind spot (BIG blind spot in a panel van) into a lane that's about to be filled with cars.

Never seen this anywhere else, and I see it on every journey I make on the Tulla.

Everyone should be given lessons on how to drive on freeways safely and responsibly... and then the speed limits should be lifted on roads such as the Hume.

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅