Poll: What's The Best War Movie Ever!!!

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
13 Mar 2013 4:16pm
I have a suspicion that a lot of seabreezers would dig war films. I find them fascinating. So here's a chance to share your favourites with others. I'll go first with a tie for the two I think are the best ever :

- Zulu (1964)

- The Thin Red Line (1998)


doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
13 Mar 2013 2:32pm
Guns of Naverone.
mocha1
mocha1
WA
934 posts
WA, 934 posts
13 Mar 2013 2:42pm
there's war movies and then there's war movies - some where (usually) Allied machine guns never miss and the Germans/Vietcong etc are the worst shots in the world - and no blood from gunshot wounds, wrong vehicles/planes for the era etc!!!!!!!!!!!! ie Chuck Norris and John Wayne films

then there's

Saving Private Ryan - best by far
longwinded
longwinded
WA
347 posts
WA, 347 posts
13 Mar 2013 3:21pm
Das Boot.
gibberjoe
gibberjoe
SA
956 posts
SA, 956 posts
13 Mar 2013 6:09pm

" The End "
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
13 Mar 2013 3:40pm
Obviously not as old as you blokes

Tears of the Sun. Awesome.

For other modern stuff - Blackhawk Down, Behind Enemy Lines, Crimson Tide (not really war but....)

Worst - Hurt Locker (yeah bomb techs that are unstable really last a long time), Jarhead. Both were raved about before release also
Rex
Rex
WA
949 posts
Rex Rex
WA, 949 posts
13 Mar 2013 3:40pm
mocha1 said...


Saving Private Ryan - best by far


I feel Saving Private Ryan rates fairly high, also Flags of our fathers and letters from Iwo jima for contrast.
hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
13 Mar 2013 3:45pm
Apocalypse Now
d1
d1
WA
304 posts
d1 d1
WA, 304 posts
13 Mar 2013 3:48pm
I like the attention to detail and apparent historical accuracy of

Downfall (Der Untergang) - 2004
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
13 Mar 2013 5:57pm
d1 said...
I like the attention to detail and apparent historical accuracy of

Downfall (Der Untergang) - 2004


Awesome film.
Bondalucci
Bondalucci
VIC
1580 posts
VIC, 1580 posts
13 Mar 2013 6:58pm
"Where Eagles Dare"
John Mills and Clint Eastwood
saw it at the drive-in when I was just a little kid and it left a big impression on me.
-life, death, suspense, double cross/twists etc

It seemed larger than life at the time.
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
13 Mar 2013 6:01pm
Saving Private Ryan was a turning point that brought new technical standards to war films and allowed subsequent film makers to make films that were more truthful about the experience of combat, but the narrative and script were too formulaic for me.
Stubbies
Stubbies
WA
1126 posts
WA, 1126 posts
13 Mar 2013 4:11pm
The Sea Hawk (1940), with Errol Flynn... a real blud and gutser without blood and guts.
sn
sn
WA
2775 posts
sn sn
WA, 2775 posts
13 Mar 2013 4:24pm
I like the old ZULU DAWN, and Saving Private Ryan is pretty good- but a lot of little technical fubars kept popping up.
Dark Blue Sky is worth chasing up.
Really impressed with Das Boot, and Letters from IWO JIMA was very well put together.
There is a lot of good movies coming out of the old Iron Curtain countries (but dont ask me to pronounce them correctly- or spell them

I really prefer movies that closely follow what actually happened- and not just a directors money maker version.

Having said all that .....Kellys Heroes is responsible for a high rate of popcorn consumption around here!
mocha1
mocha1
WA
934 posts
WA, 934 posts
13 Mar 2013 4:59pm
Channels 7, 9, 10 love Merryls Marauders going on the number of times it's been on the midday movie Closley followed by Von Ryan's Express

Battle of Britain was my favourite as a pup, I loved WWII air warfare.

Does the EXPENDABLES 1 & 2 count
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
13 Mar 2013 5:02pm
mocha1 said...
Does the EXPENDABLES 1 & 2 count


Expendables 1 yes, but number 2 I have watched half and given up, what a load of written to a formula ****
ka43
ka43
NSW
3101 posts
NSW, 3101 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:25pm
Dirty Dozen
Clarky
Clarky
QLD
295 posts
QLD, 295 posts
13 Mar 2013 7:29pm
1. Saving private Ryan
2. Platoon
3. We were soldiers, i think ( the one with Mel Gibson )
stuk
stuk
NSW
894 posts
NSW, 894 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:42pm
Apocalypse Now...many many film critics rate this as the best ever. I remember it had a R rating at the box office and my dad snuck me in.
Salatiela
Salatiela
NSW
378 posts
NSW, 378 posts
13 Mar 2013 9:16pm
I vote for "Full Metal Jacket" twisted sh#t!
adolf
adolf
1862 posts
1862 posts
13 Mar 2013 6:27pm
Each time I watch Apocalypse Now I get something else from it, great soundtrack too.
stamp
stamp
QLD
2797 posts
QLD, 2797 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:53pm
'top secret' with val kilmer
divaldo
divaldo
SA
2879 posts
SA, 2879 posts
13 Mar 2013 9:25pm
Heart break ridge / clint eastwood = legend
sameh
sameh
WA
310 posts
WA, 310 posts
13 Mar 2013 7:15pm
ememy at the gates 2001
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
13 Mar 2013 7:57pm
^^^ yes Sameh
was trying to think of the name of it

very good
Chris6791
Chris6791
WA
3271 posts
WA, 3271 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:12pm
Full Metal Jacket or The Great Escape.
sn
sn
WA
2775 posts
sn sn
WA, 2775 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:18pm
sameh said...ememy at the gates 2001


oops, I should have thought of this one too

I kinda have a soft spot for old Russian schutzenboomers

gs12
gs12
WA
426 posts
WA, 426 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:23pm
speaking of Russians - letme put something different out there if you feel like expanding your horizons a little... I saw it many years ago and it still gives me the chills...

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Come_and_See
mocha1
mocha1
WA
934 posts
WA, 934 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:46pm
HEARTBREAK RIDGE
That ayotallah of Rock n rollaha!!
You've got an expression on your face like you've just popped the neighbours cat!!
Just because we're sharin dirt don't mean we gonna be swapping spit an lookin longingly into each others eyes!

Ahhhh Clint at his best- saving Panama with extremely accurate gunfire, steeliest of steely squints, combat camo face paint, cigars and one liners
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
13 Mar 2013 8:48pm
sn said...
sameh said...ememy at the gates 2001


oops, I should have thought of this one too

I kinda have a soft spot for old Russian schutzenboomers




Yes u love your Moist Nuggets don't ya.

Nice M98 in 7x57 craps all over them
sn
sn
WA
2775 posts
sn sn
WA, 2775 posts
13 Mar 2013 9:17pm
Mark _australia said...Nice M98 in 7x57 craps all over them


who wants nice!
7.62 x 54R, adopted in the 1880's- and still a current military issue cartridge that scares our blokes silly

heres a decent unbiased review

7.62x54r.net/MosinID/MosinHumor.htm

(we need a flipping the bird smiley)

stephen
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅