weather forcasters

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
HAIL
HAIL
SA
1160 posts
SA, 1160 posts
3 Aug 2011 8:13pm
Can we believe them any more? 20-25 knots my ass!! they owe us a apology for wasting our precious sick, rdo, spare days! GGGGGGRRRRRRRRRRR thats all i have to say... HOWEVER saying that is was still bloody nice to be in the water and some good rides to be had.
SHEETIN
SHEETIN
291 posts
291 posts
3 Aug 2011 7:31pm
IN GOOD...........

BLOCK BAD.........

CIRCLE THE ENERGY.........

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

BETTER NOW

ahhhhh
Darkplague
Darkplague
SA
197 posts
SA, 197 posts
3 Aug 2011 9:04pm
So does this mean the weekend will actually be windy then?
russh
russh
SA
3027 posts
SA, 3027 posts
3 Aug 2011 9:06pm
Whatever ya drinkin Cain - I want some!!!
SHEETIN
SHEETIN
291 posts
291 posts
3 Aug 2011 7:36pm
by the way who can help with ' FACTORIZING' and FACTORIZING WITH BINOMIALS??
SHEETIN
SHEETIN
291 posts
291 posts
3 Aug 2011 7:39pm
'GOOSE ISLAND' 2006 SHIRAZ
choco
choco
SA
4181 posts
SA, 4181 posts
3 Aug 2011 10:25pm
HAIL said...

Can we believe them any more? 20-25 knots my ass!! they owe us a apology for wasting our precious sick, rdo, spare days! GGGGGGRRRRRRRRRRR thats all i have to say... HOWEVER saying that is was still bloody nice to be in the water and some good rides to be had.


they got it spot on up here at lake Bonney
Kym Roberts
Kym Roberts
SA
260 posts
SA, 260 posts
3 Aug 2011 11:28pm
have to admit the recent forcasts have gone to ** ..... LOL
SWS
SWS
SA
196 posts
SWS SWS
SA, 196 posts
4 Aug 2011 8:17am
Maybe we will get some wind on Sunday from the south east!
Zubby
Zubby
SA
896 posts
SA, 896 posts
4 Aug 2011 8:28am
HAIL said...

Can we believe them any more? 20-25 knots my ass!! they owe us a apology for wasting our precious sick, rdo, spare days! GGGGGGRRRRRRRRRRR thats all i have to say... HOWEVER saying that is was still bloody nice to be in the water and some good rides to be had.


I feel your pain Chris. I have had a couple of useless conversations with the weather forecasters over the years. I think they over forecast the wind range to meet the OHS requirements. Maybe I just need to get a life, a day at the beach is better than a day at work.

Will they get it right today, we will wait and see.

Check this out, very cool.
http://www.wimp.com/boardsports/


maris
maris
SA
179 posts
SA, 179 posts
4 Aug 2011 10:15am
hey? i must've missed something
Far yesterday x off half mast, silky smooth and FUN.
Far tuesday xoff gusting 25 head hi cleaaaan and faaast.
pretty short windows(100L quad helps too).
if mid works, far will be better a bit later on.
August and sept best months down far; around 10-15 days last couple septembers.
so , talk to the oracle (Harry), watch bom (15+at HI NNW), work smart (where u been Paul?), stop whingeing and fire up for smokin september!
dralyagmas
dralyagmas
SA
380 posts
SA, 380 posts
4 Aug 2011 10:30am
BOM are up front about over forecasting and yes they do it to be conservative. Through my work i go to the BOM Marine weather forecasting consultative committee which talk about the new forecasting web sites (look at the Vic pages and SA is doing the same soon).

Each meeting there is a discussion about the validation of the forecasts against black pole for the previous quarter. Each time they get about 95% reliability with the strength (with a 4.1 knot over estimation) and a little bit higher for direction (If i remember correctly). The times that they are not accurate they are way out, which means for the most part they are spot on but they lose accuracy when a seabreeze kicks in when it wasnt expected or vice versa or a series of cold front slip below a very stubborn high pressure system. Some of the reliability inaccuracy is also to do with local wind effects which may be too fine a resolution for their models & interpretation

I think they do a bloody good job (as long as you subject about 4 knots from each forecast)
SHEETIN
SHEETIN
291 posts
291 posts
4 Aug 2011 12:15pm
BOM and forecasting good reliable wind models.................. you and they have to be kidding..

95% reliability over what time period?

Anyone who can write a disclaimer like this still don't have a handle on how to accurately predict the wind.

Please Be Aware
Wind gusts can be a further 40 percent stronger than the averages given here, and maximum waves may be up to twice the height.


Image if they did that with the temp forecasts.

If the BoM placed more than 1 weather stations along coastlines they could maybe predict weather/wind speeds better, by tightening up the models they use with more reliable data.

and by the way was there meant to be a 1 or 2 in front of that 4 knots.
Bondage
Bondage
SA
637 posts
SA, 637 posts
4 Aug 2011 4:53pm
After over 25 years of windsurfing ive come to realise that if i based my hopes of getting a sail purely around BOM well i probably would have slit my wrists. There are too many variables including local conditions that can change things and BOM have to be careful to not underpredict for the boating fraternity to whom it is much more critical that they dont get caught out in foul weather. Much unlike us windsurfers who usually want it to blow as hard as it can.

To get excited about a sail 5 to 7 days in advance and make plans about the great sail you are gonna have based on BOM is usually unrealistic except in instances where you can see the front coming is huge or the weather pattern is easy to read (ie summer seabreeze patterns).

Best thing to do is use the info from sites like BOM as a guide but have other hobbies as a back up plan ie surfing, paddleboarding or whatever gives you stoke!!

Anyway, thats my 5cents worth.
HAIL
HAIL
SA
1160 posts
SA, 1160 posts
4 Aug 2011 6:05pm
I would have thought that these days within 24 hours of the day they should be able to get it very close to perfect forcast! all the gps/satelite ****e! around the world! maybe they need a bigger budget from the government to build new stations dotted along the coast. but all i do know is that they have been extremely wrong latley!
nusbreath
nusbreath
SA
101 posts
SA, 101 posts
4 Aug 2011 6:46pm
maris said...

talk to the oracle (Harry), watch bom (15+at HI NNW), work smart (where u been Paul?)



Bugger! Looked at the surf report (1 foot) and didnt bother.

Next time I will seek the wisdom of the Oracle..............or if you get a chance Maris text me and I'll be there to keep you and Harry company.
gmitton
gmitton
SA
1461 posts
SA, 1461 posts
4 Aug 2011 8:14pm
We need a weather system hooked up to a computer at each spot, hooked up to the internet. Or enough money to live on Maui and not work, or something.....
pilchard
pilchard
SA
626 posts
SA, 626 posts
4 Aug 2011 9:03pm
AUGUSTIS****EDUP bring on september, spring, the equinox, non westerly swells and bring my beach back at nene
SHEETIN
SHEETIN
291 posts
291 posts
5 Aug 2011 6:51am
Why is it that the Bom has only 1 weather station close to the beach?????

Other States can manage more stations along the coastline.

The Victor station has been broken for ages.

Come on Bom lift ya game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
russh
russh
SA
3027 posts
SA, 3027 posts
5 Aug 2011 9:55am
maris said...

hey? i must've missed something
Far yesterday x off half mast, silky smooth and FUN.



By the time I arrived at Dribs it was glassy and Gareth was getting washed in - Still managed to have some fun waves in some small high tide sucky SUP waves though.


russh
russh
SA
3027 posts
SA, 3027 posts
5 Aug 2011 10:40am
SHEETIN said...


The Victor station has been broken for ages.

Come on Bom lift ya game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Coreect me if Im wrong but the victor weather station only reports 3 or 4 times a day, 0300 0900 1500 2100 are the two day time reports - they're like elliston on the West coast and a few others - probably recorded by an old man with a stick with streamers attached who estimates how many streamers lift up over two minutes!!

I think it says When the recordings are in highlighted and in italics it suggests they are updated 4 times a day. EDIT _ havent been updated for 75mins.

There was something on the news about an improved weather system across SA a few months ago with new weather recording stations to improve forecasting - not sure where they are at.






HAIL
HAIL
SA
1160 posts
SA, 1160 posts
5 Aug 2011 6:36pm
today hindmarsh island gusting to 19 knots......... dribbleton was a dribbling 4 knots. wat the hell! was dying for a decent sail with waves!! was extremely fustrating!
Scotty Mac
Scotty Mac
SA
2060 posts
SA, 2060 posts
5 Aug 2011 7:55pm
Hail, I used to be like you. Honestly you have two choices:

1/ move somewhere windy like WA

2/ find a non windy sport like surfing or sup to do and windsufing

Otherwise this place will drive you up the benz.....
maris
maris
SA
179 posts
SA, 179 posts
5 Aug 2011 8:00pm
did u consult the oracle?
stormsurf
magicseaweed
capeducouedic
jabbajarjarbinks
bomobs
theoracle
put these words into the worldwide web and may the force be with you
this system will get you more wsurf action than deuce (watch for tricks).
GUNFIREIMGS
GUNFIREIMGS
WA
82 posts
WA, 82 posts
5 Aug 2011 6:39pm
Scotty Mac said...

Hail, I used to be like you. Honestly you have two choices:

1/ move somewhere windy like WA

2/ find a non windy sport like surfing or sup to do and windsufing

Otherwise this place will drive you up the benz.....


Mac is right Hail. Period.

SWS
SWS
SA
196 posts
SWS SWS
SA, 196 posts
6 Aug 2011 7:34am
Looks like bugger all wind this weekend!
russh
russh
SA
3027 posts
SA, 3027 posts
6 Aug 2011 10:33am
All most enough to sail the mid right now - still a few waves - tides a bit high - mmm probably SUP and 5m
pilchard
pilchard
SA
626 posts
SA, 626 posts
8 Aug 2011 12:17pm
hey haily i moved down here 5 yrs back due to many reasons, one being more wind in summer and more waves than the mid but theres much frustration when the wind racks off. if you move to wa have fun with the euro's and crowds. the most out sailing here at one time in my brief stint down the far se is 4 and that was with one of your local rippers mr pink bum.
nearly every standupper down here wishes they knew how to sail such is the nature of this joint
if you like sellicks wind, esperance water and middleton+ swell with the mid style reefs migrate south
if wednesdays forcast rings true i will be getting a very early season sou' easter on a couple of meters of swell over a reefy nene
HAIL
HAIL
SA
1160 posts
SA, 1160 posts
8 Aug 2011 12:33pm
Adelaide is good to live and work. i think you just have to be prepared to travel a bit! im keen on a big WA road trip in jan. also really eager to get over to lincon more in summer. adelaide metro can be really good for windsurfing but it only happens a few times a year!
viksta
viksta
69 posts
69 posts
8 Aug 2011 2:02pm
HAIL said...

im keen on a big WA road trip in jan.



Make sure you come say hi to me!!
I am always keen for a beer and won't know anyone so familiar faces are always welcome!!
russh
russh
SA
3027 posts
SA, 3027 posts
8 Aug 2011 3:53pm
pilchard said...

hey haily i moved down here 5 yrs back due to many reasons, one being more wind in summer and more waves than the mid but theres much frustration when the wind racks off. if you move to wa have fun with the euro's and crowds. the most out sailing here at one time in my brief stint down the far se is 4 and that was with one of your local rippers mr pink bum.
nearly every standupper down here wishes they knew how to sail such is the nature of this joint
if you like sellicks wind, esperance water and middleton+ swell with the mid style reefs migrate south
if wednesdays forcast rings true i will be getting a very early season sou' easter on a couple of meters of swell over a reefy nene


I reckon it Wouldn't matter where I lived it would always be windy on work days, birthdays mothers day football mornings or on the opposite coast to where I'm looking :-(


Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅