From my armchair

:
I can only assume Kauli's on a twin, right? I don't like the lines they draw. They can sit up higher, but they (or Kauli) don't seem "powerful". Feels like I'm watching Mark Richards. It's more slashing than carving. Bring on the thrusters I say.
Kauli is very fluid, no doubt and really works the entire wave. His transitions are fast. But... I don't know. Kauli doesn't come across as, say, a big wave surfer.
Josh is more ragged, but it's a style. Since when has getting air been a negative? From the few snippets on that vid Josh has better wave selection, again.
I thought the action earlier in the vid was better than the finals.