a doctor question

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
31 Jan 2012 3:44pm
been thinking about the race and conditions.

now i know jack about the area, but seeing as rotto is an island couldn't the race finish be altered to suit the conditions on the day

cheers
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
31 Jan 2012 1:47pm
Where are they doing it on Rotto?
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
31 Jan 2012 1:48pm
not in a n/w'er, there is no good line. If it was run into Freo or south you would still have to contend with a sw swell. So you either go with the swell and against the wind or vice versa.

Two years ago it was run from Port Beach (just on the north side of Freo) to Rotto as it was a howling easterly (offshore on this side of the country). That wasn't a bad run. A bit washy towards the end but not as bad as last weekends conditions.
angie pangi
angie pangi
QLD
1782 posts
QLD, 1782 posts
31 Jan 2012 3:49pm
Nope, side wind either way that day.

The following day on sunday would've been a treat, not that it would've made a difference for me. Nevermind fingers crossed for good conditions next year.

XX angie
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
31 Jan 2012 2:55pm
Four years running of below average conditions so next year we should be due for a "true" Dr.
husq2100
husq2100
QLD
2031 posts
QLD, 2031 posts
31 Jan 2012 5:55pm
this wasnt some wannabe's running this event....im sure they didnt wish for those conditions and had the best coarse for the day.

STOP LOOKING FOR EXCUSES
Fergus
Fergus
WA
136 posts
WA, 136 posts
31 Jan 2012 4:40pm
In regard to flexibility of finish lines and even the race day these remain somewhat inflexible as the race is run basically as a ski race and that is the orgaisers top priority. Ski's as we know are less effected by wind than SUPs. When it went in reverse with the eastly they were very reluctant to change and only did so at the last minute even if it is was a no brainer. Factors involved are shipping movements which means race organisers need permission re time slots from harbour authorities, certainy for sponsors in where to display there advertising, attract the public as well as providing the spectacle of an "exciting" finish.

There are advantages to being tacked onto a ski race as they do most of the hard hards in advertising, entries, timing, permission from relative authorities, logistical matters and insurance. I raced in the "easterly" race and found on the whole it was a well run, enjoyable and cheap event to be involved in.

However, I do believe the event could be done really well as a stand alone SUP event and if we got the conditions that are in actual fact common here i.e. a real Freo Doctor at 25+ knts with swell then the event could be a truly spectacular SUP event and a real highlight on the SUP racing calender.

There are pros and cons like most things and probably as a sport in W.A. are not quite big enough to go stand alone yet but I think it's a goal worth striving for.

Best wishes from W.A. (which some believe means Wait Awhile).
hb
hb
QLD
12 posts
hb hb
QLD, 12 posts
31 Jan 2012 6:47pm
so would there be a better time of the year to snare epic conditions for a stand alone sup race ???
Ali Cat
Ali Cat
QLD
1205 posts
QLD, 1205 posts
31 Jan 2012 7:00pm
As most people have said, I don't think there was any way to change the course to utilise better conditions on the day... especially when right up to the race start the forecast was still calling for the wind to swing W/WSW albeit very light.

It was a tough race and conditions weren't great, but that's what you get when you choose to race in Oz!

Most of the 'downwind' races I've done this season (Coffs, Sydney and Perth) have been in less than ideal conditions, some a bit worse than others - our weather is highly variable and not always predictable (unlike Maliko for example) and that adds an extra challenge to each race. Regardless - the better paddlers usually come out on top!

Only feedback I would have for The Doctor organisers is that if you advertise a race as having a two-day window to utilise the best downwind conditions possible, then use the window, otherwise don't advertise it in the first place - just set the date and run with it.
rambooc1
rambooc1
QLD
326 posts
QLD, 326 posts
31 Jan 2012 7:06pm
Past Wind record for all Months past 10years. It don't get any better, January is the Perfect time.

Rottnest Island/Perth (ROTTNEST)
Statistics based on observations taken between 7/2002 - 12/2011 daily from 7am to 7pm local time.



Predominant wind direction and strength

wodgina6722
wodgina6722
229 posts
229 posts
31 Jan 2012 5:11pm
I'll be entering no matter
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
31 Jan 2012 8:27pm
husq2100 said...

this wasnt some wannabe's running this event....im sure they didnt wish for those conditions and had the best coarse for the day.

STOP LOOKING FOR EXCUSES


YOU STOP BUTTING INTO THINGS YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT.
it's a question dickhead
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
31 Jan 2012 8:32pm
i not trying to make a noise or sups go it alone or anything sinister.

its a legit question for my interest in the race
husq2100
husq2100
QLD
2031 posts
QLD, 2031 posts
31 Jan 2012 9:22pm
Lighten up dickhead

But your question kinda undermines the organisers.

And re knowing nothing about it....its it required to have done multiple dw paddles to have an understanding of the weather....
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
31 Jan 2012 9:50pm
husq2100 said...

Lighten up dickhead

But your question kinda undermines the organisers.

And re knowing nothing about it....its it required to have done multiple dw paddles to have an understanding of the weather....


no, it doesn't undermine the organisers, there is a reason most likely, i'm asking what it is.

the paddlers i've talked to said it was the hardest race they've done. why- side chop , they said.

so that got me thinking, if the side chop was dominate , why not paddle with it if the wind wasn't right.

is that thumbing down the organisers- hardly.

people who know the area, are involved with dw ing in its many forms might clue me in and some, maybe some others who might be interested.


hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
31 Jan 2012 7:55pm
SSW is the go to wind.

The powers that be want a two day window and 3 races in 10 days to attract more quality racers both ski and sup. this would be the ideal situation and Dean is is on to it. I hope he succeeds.

To make it the race people talk about after the Molokai that is what is needed. Oh and a bucket full of cash.

Was a buzz to see Conner, Travis, et al here this year I hope it gets bigger.
BulldogPup
BulldogPup
6657 posts
6657 posts
31 Jan 2012 8:04pm
hilly said...

SSW is the go to wind.

The powers that be want a two day window and 3 races in 10 days to attract more quality racers both ski and sup. this would be the ideal situation and Dean is is on to it. I hope he succeeds.

To make it the race people talk about after the Molokai that is what is needed. Oh and a bucket full of cash.

Was a buzz to see Conner, Travis, et al here this year I hope it gets bigger.


SSW? ... Geez that would be interesting half way across where we get those bigger swells rolling through , where it shallows off bit , nice sized "Surf-runners" eh Hilly
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
31 Jan 2012 11:04pm
One thing the Doctor race makes clear and that is only a fool would promote a race as a downwind race if the wind direction and strength is not pretty well guaranteed. The Doctor organisers don't promote it as downwind. They're not fools.
camo hosk
camo hosk
VIC
613 posts
VIC, 613 posts
31 Jan 2012 11:20pm
hilly said...

SSW is the go to wind.

The powers that be want a two day window and 3 races in 10 days to attract more quality racers both ski and sup. this would be the ideal situation and Dean is is on to it. I hope he succeeds.

To make it the race people talk about after the Molokai that is what is needed. Oh and a bucket full of cash.

Was a buzz to see Conner, Travis, et al here this year I hope it gets bigger.


Reckon they already have 'a bucket full of cash on offer',
but with 30+ entrants this year would be good to see the numbers increase in the future races with the generous offerings by the sponsors,
so it sounds like the organizers are prepared to change things around a bit which is good, maybe teams of two people to get the not so elite across the 27 kays?
akhawk
akhawk
WA
1085 posts
WA, 1085 posts
31 Jan 2012 8:36pm
camo hosk said...

hilly said...

SSW is the go to wind.

The powers that be want a two day window and 3 races in 10 days to attract more quality racers both ski and sup. this would be the ideal situation and Dean is is on to it. I hope he succeeds.

To make it the race people talk about after the Molokai that is what is needed. Oh and a bucket full of cash.

Was a buzz to see Conner, Travis, et al here this year I hope it gets bigger.


Reckon they already have 'a bucket full of cash on offer',
but with 30+ entrants this year would be good to see the numbers increase in the future races with the generous offerings by the sponsors,
so it sounds like the organizers are prepared to change things around a bit which is good, maybe teams of two people to get the not so elite across the 27 kays?


I think teams was an option this year however it means each team having their own support boat which is not an option for most.
hilly
hilly
WA
8120 posts
WA, 8120 posts
31 Jan 2012 8:37pm
27 k dw in 20+ knots is a piece of piss but side shore is hard work 2 day window might solve that. Remember it is a ski race so side shore not as much of an issue.
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
31 Jan 2012 11:31pm
If they want it to be next in line to Molokai then it shouldn't necessarily be open to all and sundry, it should be something you have to train for and not just show up and paddle. Have to agree with Hilly 27kms with a 20+knt wind is pretty easy.

Until it becomes a stand alone SUP event the numbers won't explode as the ski's will always be the first to enter as they aren't as dependant on the weather so will take the majority of spots in regards to transport. Logistically there are only so many people organisers can cater for and be accountable for once on the water.
SimonDodd
SimonDodd
NSW
80 posts
NSW, 80 posts
1 Feb 2012 8:38pm
laceys lane said...

been thinking about the race and conditions.

now i know jack about the area, but seeing as rotto is an island couldn't the race finish be altered to suit the conditions on the day

cheers


Hi Lacey, I know that deano did try to start us from the northern side but the rangers wouldnt let him do it, a freo finish was thought about as well but the maritime authorities put that one to bed pretty quick due to shipping movements. That stetch of water is pretty well policed you are not even allowed to drive a jetski across without permission. They did all the best to help us out including a wide start and cutting out the middle marker. It was a tough paddle but was cool to see all the outer reefs around that area and some looked quite surfable on a sup.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
1 Feb 2012 10:02pm
SimonDodd said...

laceys lane said...

been thinking about the race and conditions.

now i know jack about the area, but seeing as rotto is an island couldn't the race finish be altered to suit the conditions on the day

cheers


Hi Lacey, I know that deano did try to start us from the northern side but the rangers wouldnt let him do it, a freo finish was thought about as well but the maritime authorities put that one to bed pretty quick due to shipping movements. That stetch of water is pretty well policed you are not even allowed to drive a jetski across without permission. They did all the best to help us out including a wide start and cutting out the middle marker. It was a tough paddle but was cool to see all the outer reefs around that area and some looked quite surfable on a sup.


mate, nice inside story. thanks for that . it would have taken some time trying to sort through all that red tape and stuff

cheers
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅