Yes, The Island is a very good choice. Hopefully it is a surf-a-bout format. Plenty of good waves around the island, for variations conditions.
I remember surfing at Western Cowes one day, when I was about 16 or 17. I think it was at the rocky reef at the end of Bella Vista Rd. It was fun and small. You wouldn't think you would find a wave here, on the wrong side of the island!!
www.google.com:443/mapsbella vista rd, cowes, phillip island, vic