Forums > Sailing General

Hit By Lightning Now Sinking

Reply
Created by Zzzzzz > 9 months ago, 12 Nov 2020
Zzzzzz
513 posts
12 Nov 2020 10:27PM
Thumbs Up

This is the follow on from the yacht hit by lightning , he now finds his bilge alarm is on and he can't keep up with the water.
what he does next is beyond words he goes over the side at night to look for the hole , pitch black you can see bull sharks in the torch light , I'm starting to think do I enjoy sailing this much.

samsturdy
NSW, 1659 posts
13 Nov 2020 11:49AM
Thumbs Up

He was dealing with a fairly large hole there. I seem to remember stuff called Kneadit that cures under water. I wonder
if it still exists and whether it would have helped reduce the size of the hole.

MorningBird
NSW, 2700 posts
13 Nov 2020 1:03PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
samsturdy said..
He was dealing with a fairly large hole there. I seem to remember stuff called Kneadit that cures under water. I wonder
if it still exists and whether it would have helped reduce the size of the hole.


Might have but the hull slime would have played havoc with kneadit as well. I carried it and another hole filling product on MB but it was more for dinghy repairs than the hull. I had pieces of an old sail onboard a few feet square I would have put over the hole in the hull. It should get forced in by the force of the water and hopefully would have jammed that hole. Not perfect but it would slow the inflow.

Zzzzzz
513 posts
13 Nov 2020 10:08AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MorningBird said..

samsturdy said..
He was dealing with a fairly large hole there. I seem to remember stuff called Kneadit that cures under water. I wonder
if it still exists and whether it would have helped reduce the size of the hole.



Might have but the hull slime would have played havoc with kneadit as well. I carried it and another hole filling product on MB but it was more for dinghy repairs than the hull. I had pieces of an old sail onboard a few feet square I would have put over the hole in the hull. It should get forced in by the force of the water and hopefully would have jammed that hole. Not perfect but it would slow the inflow.


Fothering John I think Captain Cook also used Dog ****

Ramona
NSW, 7732 posts
13 Nov 2020 6:07PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
MorningBird said..

samsturdy said..
He was dealing with a fairly large hole there. I seem to remember stuff called Kneadit that cures under water. I wonder
if it still exists and whether it would have helped reduce the size of the hole.



Might have but the hull slime would have played havoc with kneadit as well. I carried it and another hole filling product on MB but it was more for dinghy repairs than the hull. I had pieces of an old sail onboard a few feet square I would have put over the hole in the hull. It should get forced in by the force of the water and hopefully would have jammed that hole. Not perfect but it would slow the inflow.


Small jib with rope on the three corners and pull it over the hole.

Kinora
VIC, 187 posts
13 Nov 2020 7:30PM
Thumbs Up

I have heard of wrapping chain around the shrouds and throwing the loose end into the water when surrounded by lightening. The idea being that this provides a pathway to "ground" (in this case water) for the lightening bolt. This might avoid the charge blasting its way out through the metal fittings in the hull but, at the same time, it may make the boat a more attractive target. But if you're likely to be hit anyway, the added risk might be worth it.

Respect to the guy in the video, he did a very good job to save his boat.

K.

MorningBird
NSW, 2700 posts
13 Nov 2020 8:08PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Zzzzzz said..

MorningBird said..


samsturdy said..
He was dealing with a fairly large hole there. I seem to remember stuff called Kneadit that cures under water. I wonder
if it still exists and whether it would have helped reduce the size of the hole.




Might have but the hull slime would have played havoc with kneadit as well. I carried it and another hole filling product on MB but it was more for dinghy repairs than the hull. I had pieces of an old sail onboard a few feet square I would have put over the hole in the hull. It should get forced in by the force of the water and hopefully would have jammed that hole. Not perfect but it would slow the inflow.



Fothering John I think Captain Cook also used Dog ****

Yep, not my idea at all. As Ramona says you can use a full sail but I had an old torn No3 which I cut up to have more convenient sizes. I think they were a metre square. The weight of the water should force it into the hole but is was too much to go all the way through.

MorningBird
NSW, 2700 posts
13 Nov 2020 8:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Kinora said..
I have heard of wrapping chain around the shrouds and throwing the loose end into the water when surrounded by lightening. The idea being that this provides a pathway to "ground" (in this case water) for the lightening bolt. This might avoid the charge blasting its way out through the metal fittings in the hull but, at the same time, it may make the boat a more attractive target. But if you're likely to be hit anyway, the added risk might be worth it.

Respect to the guy in the video, he did a very good job to save his boat.

K.


I have heard of that tactic. My limited knowledge of lightning tells me it should work.

Jolene
WA, 1620 posts
13 Nov 2020 7:06PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Kinora said..
, it may make the boat a more attractive target. But if you're likely to be hit anyway, the added risk might be worth it.

K.



It may even make the boat less of a target if you take into account lightening rod theory

garymalmgren
1357 posts
13 Nov 2020 8:02PM
Thumbs Up

I have heard of wrapping chain around the shrouds and throwing the loose end into the water when surrounded by lightening.

If he was at anchor with chain he would have had a direct line from the anchor chain to the bow fitting, then up the forestay to the masthead.

Apparently lighting is not that predictable.
It doesn't always take the most direct (less resistant) route. Luck plays a huge role in lightning strikes.

gary



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Hit By Lightning Now Sinking" started by Zzzzzz