Mini Yacht doubts

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
veladaterra
veladaterra
84 posts
84 posts
16 Jun 2011 7:14pm
Hi there,

FISLY Mini Yachts will be one of the racing Class adopted in Italy. Some sailors here are starting to build or modify their yacht to fit in.

I wish to know:
- how to apply the 5.60 rule, if there's a precise way for measurement
- is a Seagull Standart' like mast (circular mast plus cambers in the zip pocket) allowed? Someone think about a wing section only looking at a Class 2 or 3 yacht...

I've tried to summarize MY rules here ruotenelvento.wordpress.com/2011/06/10/che-cose-un-miniyacht/ I hope I got it right, any suggestion very welcome.

Thank you

Cheers - Enrico
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
16 Jun 2011 9:16pm
Recently there was quite a lot of discussion on the FISLY Mini rule...This might answer some of the questions.
Mind you there wasn't much discussion on the actual / sail setup, mainly wheels and tyres.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Land-Yacht-Sailing/Construction/How-do-you-interpret-the-new-rule/
veladaterra
veladaterra
84 posts
84 posts
16 Jun 2011 8:31pm
Thank you Gizmo

I completely missed that thread . I've something to read now

Enrico

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
18 Jun 2011 9:55pm
the mast bit was cleared up by IKPSA
round mast and no aerodynamics/fairings , ie standart style
would have made an interesting experiment. I am playing with a cammed mast pocket at the moment, after seeing that chook2 has managed to do it without much problems
veladaterra
veladaterra
84 posts
84 posts
19 Jun 2011 7:16pm
Ok, wing section refers to mast AND sail.

During measurement pilot must be seated in the yacht?

Everything that looks so easy among friends pervaded with a sound sportmanship spirit could be different if you need to win a World Championship to promote the sales of your production yacht. Here in Italy if you say "standard wheel" you're referring to a 4.80/4.00 - 8, no doubt. Four pages of the other post taught me that a Mini with 16" bmx wheels fits the rule.

Please tell me if I've to post here or in HOW DO YOU INTERPRET THE NEW RULE

Cheers - Enrico
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Jun 2011 9:22pm
The measurement with the pilot seated, the reason is that due to chassis flex the back wheels might spread a little changing the measurement. And if you wanted to make a production yacht to fit the class this would needed to be taken into account.

It seems the other thread has expired for new posts, you might as well continue here or start another thread for the Mini Class.
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
19 Jun 2011 8:07pm
Gizmo said...

The measurement with the pilot seated, the reason is that due to chassis flex the back wheels might spread a little changing the measurement. And if you wanted to make a production yacht to fit the class this would needed to be taken into account.

It seems the other thread has expired for new posts, you might as well continue here or start another thread for the Mini Class.


I dont recall any mention of the pilot in the FISLY mini rules, Gizmo.
is this your personal interpretation ,or have I missed something.
the 5.6m rope rule is simply a 5.6m loop of rope on the ground within which all the wheels must fit. they were pretty clear on that

Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Jun 2011 10:12pm
That's from the class 5 rule isn't it ?..... I haven't read the mini rules recently...

Edit; pilot seated when measuring is class 5 NOT Mini Class...
From that previous thread .........

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
From the FISLY secretary -

These are the rules as voted on the GA of 14.10.2010 :

A Mini-yacht is :
- any assembled land or sand yacht that fits inside a continuous loop of rope 5.6 metre long.
- the wheel size is maximum 400 x 8
- the mast must be a circular tube; no wing section




Here is the proposal for refining to be voted on the next GA in September 2011 :



There is a proposal for adjustment of Mini-Yacht specifications on the measurement with the rope of 5.6 m.

'The rope must lie on the ground. The touching part of the tyres on the ground must fit inside the rope.
This adjustment will be proposed to vote on the GA at Hoylake in September 2011. Meanwhile it is recommended to respect it as a guideline.

Other proposal formulated in the meeting of 22.01.2011:
' wheel size is maximum 400x8' is to be changed to 'the tyre size'.

Alan
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
20 Jun 2011 8:25pm
What is the largest sail area you can legally have for a mini???
Is there a mast height requirement?

Or is it really that simple: inside the noted wheel measurements, a seat belt and go for it.
Test pilot 1
Test pilot 1
WA
1430 posts
WA, 1430 posts
20 Jun 2011 11:14pm
Chook2 said...

What is the largest sail area you can legally have for a mini???
Is there a mast height requirement?

Or is it really that simple: inside the noted wheel measurements, a seat belt and go for it.


Chook I think you will find that they don't use seat belts in europe. They seem to think that with beach sailing, if you have an accident and get knocked unconsious, sail into the sea and are wearing a seatbelt then you will drown. I think you would drown even if you didn't have a seatbelt on.
aus230
aus230
WA
1660 posts
WA, 1660 posts
20 Jun 2011 11:53pm
any sail size chook, but a round mast (not wing shaped)
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
21 Jun 2011 8:15am
There is no way I would leave my seat belt off.
Whether it is in the yacht, or the car.
It certainly saved me this past Easter at Lefroy, took about a week for the bruise to disappear where the belt had held me from being flung out the back.

Thanks for the sail size info, it seems a bit strange that it's not regulated but I'm not going to argue, I'm a large bloke and need the square meters in my LLM.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
21 Jun 2011 10:42am
Chook2 said...

Thanks for the sail size info, it seems a bit strange that it's not regulated but I'm not going to argue, I'm a large bloke and need the square meters in my LLM.



Its actually a double edge sword...
Go big sail = need to make yacht super strong to support it.
Go Big sail = harder to keep the wheels on the ground in strong wind.
Big sails less efficient at high speeds.
Big sails work well on soft surfaces.
Smaller sails better for hard surfaces and high speed.

By not having to measure sails is a bonus for the sport as it stops SO much arguing in measuring prior to a championships.
It also assists newcomers into the sport by using pre-loved sailboard sails.



Nikrum
Nikrum
TAS
1972 posts
TAS, 1972 posts
21 Jun 2011 11:55am
Yeah! I figured it would be a self regulating thing unless one carried a suit of sails for different conditions, then there is nothing to say that the wind won't get stronger during an event and you finish up spending your time getting straight! The reverse is true you go out in a strong wind and get becalmed in the middle of the Salt Lake. I can imagine that would be a bunch of fun on a stinker of a day
Ron
PS; Any stories to relate? Anyone?? (liitle Story on Nikrum's Page)
Chook2
Chook2
WA
1249 posts
WA, 1249 posts
21 Jun 2011 4:58pm
How refreshing that there are so few requirements.
It's a breath of fresh air in our current enviroment, that this can happen.

Now you point it out Gismo, it makes a lot of sence, thanks.
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
21 Jun 2011 9:49pm
veladaterra said...

Hi there,

FISLY Mini Yachts will be one of the racing Class adopted in Italy. Some sailors here are starting to build or modify their yacht to fit in.

I wish to know:
- how to apply the 5.60 rule, if there's a precise way for measurement
- is a Seagull Standart' like mast (circular mast plus cambers in the zip pocket) allowed? Someone think about a wing section only looking at a Class 2 or 3 yacht...

I've tried to summarize MY rules here ruotenelvento.wordpress.com/2011/06/10/che-cose-un-miniyacht/ I hope I got it right, any suggestion very welcome.

Thank you

Cheers - Enrico

reading the fisly rule on masts, only the mast must be round, that will mean the those awkward standart inserts and the big pocket will be fine to use

veladaterra
veladaterra
84 posts
84 posts
23 Jun 2011 10:12pm
landyacht said...


reading the fisly rule on masts, only the mast must be round, that will mean the those awkward standart inserts and the big pocket will be fine to use




On the other thread IPKSA (Alan, FISLY vice president) was clear: Standart' type mast AND sail are NOT allowed.

This three very simple rules were made to bring more people to the sport. Ironically the rules are pretty clear among who's in the sport, but they're so minimal that I've a lot of difficulties to explain them to whom has not seen a landyacht before.

Cheers - Enrico

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
23 Jun 2011 10:26pm
this is where the difference in the word of the rule and the intention of the rule doesnt match.
it make sit harder when we interprete things differently in the same language. many years ago we travelled all the way to Europe to discover that some of the rules that had determined the designs we took with us had been dropped, theyd just forgot to tell us , or interpreted them differently
lachlan3556
lachlan3556
VIC
1066 posts
VIC, 1066 posts
24 Jun 2011 2:23pm
veladaterra said...

On the other thread IPKSA (Alan, FISLY vice president) was clear: Standart' type mast AND sail are NOT allowed.



I read nothing in the rules to back this up, couldn't even say there was anything there that could be taken as such. I see a little (friendly) conflict at an event somewhere along the line
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
24 Jun 2011 4:36pm



Here are some pics from the Seagull "Standart" site of the sail setup, and i can see why it wouldn't be allowed.
www.char-a-voile.com/www-uk/standart.html



cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
25 Jun 2011 1:08am
If it is new technology that allows land yachts to go faster than before, why should it not be incorporated into the rules?????
IPKSA
IPKSA
177 posts
177 posts
10 Aug 2011 4:06am
I just love the way the miniyacht rule creates debate and interest !

Simple , keep to the rule and off you go !

Alan
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
10 Aug 2011 6:01pm
IPKSA said...

I just love the way the miniyacht rule creates debate and interest !

Simple , keep to the rule and off you go !

Alan

exactly Alan , we read the rule and reached a different Interpretation, based on what we read.
i would love the rules to be even simpler still, but bad luck to me.
strangely , tonight I started recutting a very fast successful windsurfer sail that has a large pocket, batten cams and even rollers on the cam.
Think of it as an experiment in finding out what is possible.
the next sail in line has a double batten /internal tensioning ssystem that would give a shape not unlike a standart, but easier to set up (maybe).
just because the yacht is mini, people really do underestimate them, last weekend we were sailing at 90kph consistently,in conditions that I would not sail a 5 or promo in.
Minis have an incredible potential , lets find out what it is,

Nikrum
Nikrum
TAS
1972 posts
TAS, 1972 posts
10 Aug 2011 11:03pm
OK! Paul now your getting into real speeds, what was the average wing speed for those trips??
Ron
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
12 Aug 2011 9:13am
Nikrum said...

OK! Paul now your getting into real speeds, what was the average wing speed for those trips??
Ron


the best 5 10sec runs were all over 89 and there was a 50 sec run over 89 as well.
one does like some consistency

Nikrum
Nikrum
TAS
1972 posts
TAS, 1972 posts
12 Aug 2011 6:33pm
Paul,
you didn't answer the Q? Wind Speed that got you there??
Ron

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
12 Aug 2011 7:03pm
Nikrum said...

Paul,
you didn't answer the Q? Wind Speed that got you there??
Ron



oh winD speeds. base speed was around40kph with gusts up to 50 at the end , got up to 60 later but we had left by then .
when a 2,2 is too much sail area you kinda have to pack up.
the main problem was that my tiny sail was too loose and baggy, the new ones are like drum skins with shape

cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
13 Aug 2011 2:20am
landyacht said...
the new ones are like drum skins with shape


Stop it. You are giving me a hard on.

nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
13 Aug 2011 1:24am
cisco said...

landyacht said...
the new ones are like drum skins with shape


Stop it. You are giving me a hard on.



Me too

Next thing you know he will be reinventing an Ezzy
Nikrum
Nikrum
TAS
1972 posts
TAS, 1972 posts
13 Aug 2011 11:01am
Thanks Paul.
Aren't those two below your reply "Just So Rude" Dirty, dirty boys.
That is the way to have a Sail, you could really get into a Drummers rhythm on mine. Tum Tum tuma tum tum tra ra a thrum thrum
Ron
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
13 Aug 2011 6:21pm
nebbian said...

cisco said...

landyacht said...
the new ones are like drum skins with shape


Stop it. You are giving me a hard on.



Me too

Next thing you know he will be reinventing an Ezzy

that sounds sad boys
well you know what to look out for now nebbian, especially picassos, they are brilliant to recut.
save all you mates old surf sails and I can make some crazy sexy sail with them







Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅