Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews

2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel

Reply
Created by Snowy > 9 months ago, 18 Jan 2012
puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
15 Feb 2012 11:10AM
Thumbs Up

bjw said...

I know snowy has made his choice, but I really think we need to discuss this more.


I can see by your avatar ur a glutton bjw.
Glutton for punishment obviously.

someawe
WA, 179 posts
15 Feb 2012 8:35PM
Thumbs Up

Best drifting kite(s)??

mywisdom
WA, 258 posts
15 Feb 2012 10:11PM
Thumbs Up

..and how much is this free resort weekend?

bjw
QLD, 3686 posts
16 Feb 2012 7:57AM
Thumbs Up

puppetonastring said...

bjw said...

I know snowy has made his choice, but I really think we need to discuss this more.


I can see by your avatar ur a glutton bjw.
Glutton for punishment obviously.



Hey don't be judgemental. Maybe Im just big boned??
Elvis suits add 5kg.

The BWS Rebel is a really fast powerfull highend kite with good low end and fast turning. It's better than the North Switchblade. Much better than the 2010.

Mask
WA, 293 posts
17 Feb 2012 7:27AM
Thumbs Up

The 2013 North Noise is said to be a 7 line kite with even more depower and canopy rigidity. Word is that Eppo and Saffer are drooling and have already placed orders.

Saffer
VIC, 4501 posts
17 Feb 2012 11:25AM
Thumbs Up

Ignore him, Eppo. Never argue with an idiot, they'll pull you down to their level and then beat you with experience.

woodys
WA, 218 posts
17 Feb 2012 4:54PM
Thumbs Up

someawe said...

Best drifting kite(s)??


You will find that it all depends on the current and the wind - working in combination.
Drift speed depends a lot too on whether the kite is LE down or Trailing Edge down.
When they are trailing edge down the BWS will sit lower in the water than the Rebel so will tend to drift faster - esp if its with the current. But if theres a strong upwind current then the Rebel may well drift faster.
With LE down its hard to pick the difference really. If you test them size for size then the BWS will drift faster as they are a larger cut for marked size than the Rebel (and most other brands) so will pick up more wind.
Trick is to get either of them back up before they drift too far.
Hope that helps.

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
17 Feb 2012 5:35PM
Thumbs Up

Lol. I reckon 7 lines would be about the only way a noise kite could like get remotely close to a rebels performance. But by then the quality improvements would come at a price so mask would be promoting the next cheap brand equivalent. Oh no another 4 pages of pointless banter.

Mask
WA, 293 posts
17 Feb 2012 10:32PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

Lol. I reckon 7 lines would be about the only way a noise kite could like get remotely close to a rebels performance.


Ha, ha , Eppo, glad to see you havent lost your sense of humour!

puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
18 Feb 2012 12:49AM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

Lol. I reckon 7 lines would be about the only way a noise kite could like get remotely close to a rebels performance.


I reckon it would take 7 lines to rein in the power of a Noise to bring back to somewhere near that of a Rebel

dave......
WA, 2119 posts
18 Feb 2012 2:09PM
Thumbs Up

A lower aspect kite will drift better. As I stated on my previous post in cross-onshore it is about the first kite movement just before you do your bottom turn. This puts the kite deeper in the wind window and then you can follow it. As for questions related to my previous post. I ride unhooked most of the time, and on a surfboard I can surf on the BWS is my choice, but my quiver is Best TS. It drifts without losing power, so does the BWS with a little more turning input required.
No kite will drift endlessly unless in perfect crossshore, and in cross-onshore you still need to turn your kite before you do a turn when going fast down the line.

Technique is still so much more important than the kite youre on. 4 pages f love for what people ride and give their "unbiased" opinions, Its called in marketing terms "post-purchase affintiy".

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
18 Feb 2012 3:47PM
Thumbs Up

Yep post purchase affinity, like that phrase.

puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
18 Feb 2012 9:09PM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...

Yep post purchase affinity, like that phrase.

sounds like ur a 'slave' to this theory eppo
Its a great concept to raise here on the forum where all-comers are asking advice from all other-comers.
Gotta be something super seriously wrong with your own final purchase choice if ur not prepared to re-inforce your decision as advise to others.
This is part of the problem of ppl taking opinions expressed here - even when completely well meaning and independent - as valid for them in their own space.

The vomit triggering, continual promotion of one kite above above all others is the forum pimps very poor & inaccurate advice. Esp given the range of independent preferences every kiter will have.
Just today I had a customer in who is probably the most 'brand' experienced kiter I know. He has owned; or at least flown extensively; every kite that has been released with claims of being 'great in the surf'. He works hard at testing every size of every kite out there. Not only is he a top level kiter but his continual, thorough checking of every kite that is released with any 'surf' credentials is almost neurotic.
At this point in time his, very knowledgable, quiver consists of 3 kites. Three M2 sizes and each size is a different brand of 'surf' kite. in his opinion (and Im not about to argue) is that he has selected the best high wind wave kite; the best average sea-breeze sized wave kite and the best light wind wave kite available on the market - each of which is a different brand.

Its 2012 guys - kites have come of age. Almost all of the known & established brands are pretty much the best there is - the absolute best - in your opinion - is probably the one you chose regardless of whether thats the right or wrong choice for anyone else.
Dont stress over it too hard guys. Just make sure the style of kite ur buying is right for your style of kiting and is one of the reputable known brands. Theres not a whole lot in it despite the hype & BS.

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
19 Feb 2012 4:38PM
Thumbs Up

Hey mask ran into a guy I've known for a while and he tells me he was one of the cofounders of the bws kite brand ( was sitting around with Ben one day and they thought hey let's make our own). He now travels with his family 7 months of the year kiting and making movies for bws.

And yes I've been moping about in an envious pit of sh1t with no bottom all day.

Anyhow he said he will give us a demo on the new model, so will report back. Can't wait.

Ps my life sucks. Lol.


As far as post purchase affinity, can't deny it nor can anyone, but I've also owned and flown many brands throughout every stage in the kite evolution and it has taken me a lot of money and a lot of time to find the one that suites me, and the rebel does. Especially in the last two years when I chopped and changed through 4 different kite makes as I was sick of not having a kite that 'thinks' and acts like I think it should, I was on an impartial mission and was more post neutral.

The kite that has sparked my interest so far is the Best TS. If I was a strapless sb rider, yes the bws would be high if not top on the list, along with the reo.

Anyhow there's more to it than post purchase affinity anyhow.

Pss my life sucks..

the walks
WA, 448 posts
19 Feb 2012 5:52PM
Thumbs Up

is this thread still going, just back from a weekend of wind with the mullaz crew in Dongarra
everyone there decided to try everyone elses kit (boards & kites)
1 question, what is the difference between the 2011 & 2012 noise, we only had a 2011 there so i may need a demo on a 2012 please phil, if there are any changes.

puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
20 Feb 2012 12:15AM
Thumbs Up

eppo said...
I've been moping about in an envious pit of sh1t with no bottom all day.



You is sad cos u got no bottom eppo
If I had a spare one Id lend it to you

puppetonastring
WA, 3619 posts
20 Feb 2012 12:25AM
Thumbs Up

the walks said...
question, what is the difference between the 2011 & 2012 noise, we only had a 2011 there so i may need a demo on a 2012 please phil, if there are any changes.


Hey Walks - if you were flying one of the original production kites - the ones that were first released to the pro team with a limited no. offered cheap on line to 'test team riders' then yes you probably do need to test drive one of the 2nd production run kites. Feedback from the small first production release was used to tweak the 2nd and consequent production runs. Nothing big I believe but obviously improved.

If you let me know whose kite you tested I can probably track it & let you know. Ur welcome to a demo kite anytime if you want to check for yourself. KSS demos are all 2nd (or later) production run kites.

keke
12 posts
20 Feb 2012 8:25AM
Thumbs Up

Atleast neither are made by best,lol

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
21 Feb 2012 3:47PM
Thumbs Up

Dunno about BWS but I demoed the 2012 9m Rebel over the weekend.

Me:
No affinity with any brand/shop
85kgs,
Intermediate
Freerider on TT and almost always do DWs. Like to boost big and smash mushy waves.


Used in 18-21 kts DW and 16-18kts static at Contos.


Simply an AWESOME kite!

A true all rounder.
Boosts very nicely and with forgiving landing if your timing is not 100%
Very nice in the waves.
great safety

Trucks of power in all aspects. No probs getting going at 16kts.
Good amount of power through the turns to stay moving on my twin tip but not overpowered. Will pivot turn fast if you want it, but I prefer a wider arc with power maintained and liked this option on the Rebel.

Bar is heavy-ish and kite 'feels' a little heavy in the air (compared to the 3 strut kites I am used to flying the last few years) but is easily compensated by shear power and finesse with that power. It is still agile enough for 80% of kiters I'd say

Finesse is the word. The Rebel does not flap, flutter - nuttin but sit there 100% composed and forming a perfect wing. It honestly does everything well, and most things very well.

I tried riding directly at the kite (to see if it would gently fall back into the window) a few times and could ony achieve a tiny bit of slackness in the lines as the kite perfectly tracked downwind with me, so the lines didn't get super slack.

Not sure this kite would be for rank beginners. Whilst it is very very well behaved and pretty good at relaunching there is serious power [}:)] and grunt on tap, so potential is there to maybe overcook a turn and cop a flogging.

Having said that the depower is great (speshly with the kite staying rigid and not flapping) and the 5th line safety is a winner IMO.

I'm not wild about the clam cleat on the Rebels (don't like clam cleats on any kites) but the extra throw allows better safety with the bar throw I guess.

Build quality is top o' the line. Bungy that keeps lines tucked away and snag free is a goody.

All up a serious kite for anyone who mixes it up a bit. Would like one a lot!

Ride one.

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
21 Feb 2012 9:18PM
Thumbs Up

Hey man how goes it Funksta! Getting out much? How's ya camping going with the family? You made some very insightful observations from one ride, though i would comment on them as you and I have always though alike...

Boosts very nicely and with forgiving landing if your timing is not 100%

....Yeh found the same, the 11m is even more forgiving - you can really pivot your body and throw the kite through any part of the wind window...

Will pivot turn fast if you want it, but I prefer a wider arc with power maintained and liked this option on the Rebel.

...Agreed, grab at the end of the bar and turn in straight onto the center lines and this kite will pivot like anything else, even in the bigger 11m size - allows for tight gibes and transitions...

Bar is heavy-ish and kite 'feels' a little heavy in the air (compared to the 3 strut kites I am used to flying the last few years) but is easily compensated by shear power and finesse with that power.

...Agreed it seemed a little heavy after flying the Cores, but the instant power alleviates this - also this means you have a real direct feel with the kite, and know where it is throughou the window without having to look - I actually appreciate it now...

Finesse is the word. The Rebel does not flap, flutter - nuttin but sit there 100% composed and forming a perfect wing. It honestly does everything well, and most things very well.

...Flapping is the aspect of a kite I hate most above all, especially in gusty conditions. Even the quality built Cores would flap somewhat and it really gave me the Sh1ts. This is the main reason I love this kite, the frame doesn't deform at all and this gives a real smooth feel at the bar end, couple this with instant power and an exremely short throw when you need it, yes it does most things well.

I tried riding directly at the kite (to see if it would gently fall back into the window) a few times and could ony achieve a tiny bit of slackness in the lines as the kite perfectly tracked downwind with me, so the lines didn't get super slack.

...yeh tried to explain this after daves (excellent points) post, I am yet to drop this kite, no matter how fast I have ridden at it, allows real tight turns onto a wave as it wraps around the window allowing you to slot into a wave, then catch the kite up. It does pull you off the wave if you don't use correct technique...

Not sure this kite would be for rank beginners. Whilst it is very very well behaved and pretty good at relaunching there is serious power [}:)] and grunt on tap, so potential is there to maybe overcook a turn and cop a flogging.

...Agreed funks, an intermediate rider would be fine due to the control you have, but as I find out if I loop incorrectly, it will punish you...

Having said that the depower is great (speshly with the kite staying rigid and not flapping) and the 5th line safety is a winner IMO.

..another reason I love it - get apparent wind up, set and leave, with minor adjustments of depower. You needn't sine this kite, just ride and have fun. Yeh the fifth line does contribute a lot the performance (tip, always tune your lines on a regular basis and Puertz taught us), but wouldn't want to drop this in the surf all twisted up, this is a definite limitation for me, but then again, don;t drop the kite a whole lot...

I'm not wild about the clam cleat on the Rebels (don't like clam cleats on any kites) but the extra throw allows better safety with the bar throw I guess.

...I still reckon they are better than a strap, the adjustment to shorten the length is awesome as I don't use a whole lot of depower through the center line and tend to use board edging...


All up a serious kite for anyone who mixes it up a bit.

...Yeh that's the key, it is a very good allrounder, non specific which suites my style.

TurtleHunter
WA, 1675 posts
21 Feb 2012 11:42PM
Thumbs Up

puppetonastring said...

eppo said...

Yep post purchase affinity, like that phrase.

sounds like ur a 'slave' to this theory eppo
Its a great concept to raise here on the forum where all-comers are asking advice from all other-comers.
Gotta be something super seriously wrong with your own final purchase choice if ur not prepared to re-inforce your decision as advise to others.
This is part of the problem of ppl taking opinions expressed here - even when completely well meaning and independent - as valid for them in their own space.

The vomit triggering, continual promotion of one kite above above all others is the forum pimps very poor & inaccurate advice. Esp given the range of independent preferences every kiter will have.
Just today I had a customer in who is probably the most 'brand' experienced kiter I know. He has owned; or at least flown extensively; every kite that has been released with claims of being 'great in the surf'. He works hard at testing every size of every kite out there. Not only is he a top level kiter but his continual, thorough checking of every kite that is released with any 'surf' credentials is almost neurotic.
At this point in time his, very knowledgable, quiver consists of 3 kites. Three M2 sizes and each size is a different brand of 'surf' kite. in his opinion (and Im not about to argue) is that he has selected the best high wind wave kite; the best average sea-breeze sized wave kite and the best light wind wave kite available on the market - each of which is a different brand.

Its 2012 guys - kites have come of age. Almost all of the known & established brands are pretty much the best there is - the absolute best - in your opinion - is probably the one you chose regardless of whether thats the right or wrong choice for anyone else.
Dont stress over it too hard guys. Just make sure the style of kite ur buying is right for your style of kiting and is one of the reputable known brands. Theres not a whole lot in it despite the hype & BS.


jeez that sounds like a complicated way of getting on the water and having fun.
I have ridden a few kites and what I found was your constantly changing the way you ride then you end up hurting yourself. Then you just want to get on one kite and concentrate on that since their all good just a bit different and you could have fun on any brand kite. As for the quickest drifting kite I found the wallend air drifted with the tide quicker than anything. leading edge up or down.

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
22 Feb 2012 2:25PM
Thumbs Up

puppetonastring said...

Just today I had a customer in who is probably the most 'brand' experienced kiter I know. He has owned; or at least flown extensively; every kite that has been released with claims of being 'great in the surf'.


is his name dave by any chance ?? :P

someawe
WA, 179 posts
22 Feb 2012 5:59PM
Thumbs Up

I use rebels, but Eppos constant 'gushing' about them is making me puke!

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
22 Feb 2012 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

As for the quickest drifting kite I found the wallend air drifted with the tide quicker than anything. leading edge up or down.






HA HA HA - I remember those matresses. Was flying the New Wave foils at the time...just as bad! Craig used to get some serious air though down scabs. The Wallie aris, blast from the past that one.


eppo
WA, 9735 posts
22 Feb 2012 8:28PM
Thumbs Up

someawe said...

I use rebels, but Eppos constant 'gushing' about them is making me puke!







Actually I was adding to comments made by Get Funky. Adding to some performance details. As for most posts I've read lately that are just damn drivel albeit somewhat hilarious, I couldn't give a flying pigs Sh1t about your so called 'Gushing' adverb. Contribute or piss off mate. What exactly do you add posting such trite.

ps Glad you like the rebels, how fantastic are they! LOL.



inside grunt
WA, 72 posts
23 Feb 2012 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

^^^ looks like you do give a sh|t, mind you is that a sht from a flying pig or pig sht that flies?

eppo
WA, 9735 posts
23 Feb 2012 9:07PM
Thumbs Up

Ah yes another superfluous post as is coming to be expected on this forum. The thread is about rebels and bws kites, so add something to the content or leave it. Or just partake in the lowest common denominator attempt of humor and do a play on words.

For gods sake contribute...

someawe
WA, 179 posts
23 Feb 2012 9:27PM
Thumbs Up

^^^ dude look how many red thumbs your getting! You must be spewing, so now your puking too!! Oh that's my contribution to light entertainment

getfunky
WA, 4485 posts
23 Feb 2012 11:00PM
Thumbs Up

Geez tuff cowd!

If I owned a Rebel I'd probably be talking and talking about it too.. they ARE that good IMO.

Most kites are hyped beyond a kn joke. Although I don't ride heaps of diff kites the Rebel is the first kite that has made me sit up and woot woot for some time.

Alas, not enough spendies in the pocket to buy a 2012 Rebel for me... yet.

Thumb away but at least Eppo isn't on the payroll and pimping a kite for $$$.

Same can't be said of some people in the previous 3-4 pages.

Jedibrad
NSW, 527 posts
24 Feb 2012 12:55PM
Thumbs Up

The 7 is little gem



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews


"2012 BWS Noise vs 2012 North Rebel" started by Snowy