Right of way

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
alverstone
alverstone
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
3 Jan 2012 1:12pm
This was written after playing chicken with other kiters and poleys over the Christmas break, and as a reply to all the threads about rules on the water/leaners/Euros/whinging and how even the experienced screw up.

When you're on the water a STARBOARD tack - ie with the wind coming over the right shoulder - has right of way. It's a basic rule of the sea.
Those on port tacks - heading out to sea in a SW'ly at Dutch, heading 'in' to The Pond, heading towards Ardross at Melville, heading to Penguin at Shaolwater - should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit, if a poley, if faced with those coming at 'em on a opposite tack.
My dinghy instructor said the rule comes from the Vikings when their longships had steering oars on the right side of their sterns. This made them less manoeuvrable compared to a ship on an opposite tack coming towards them.
The steering oar of the port tack ship would have been on its leeward side and 'digging' deeper into the water, allowing the ship to bear away from the wind/oncoming vessel faster.
"Port" comes from the ships tying up with the steering oar-less side facing the wharf to protect the primitive rudder.
Or is this just a yarn spun to keep novice sailiors quiet?
Now could someone please explain how that affects the arcane rules waxheads apply when you take the kite in the surf?
Ahua
Ahua
WA
7 posts
WA, 7 posts
3 Jan 2012 3:09pm
Sailing rules still apply ie upwind sailor on the wave has right of way, first sailor/surfer on the wave has right of way. Look at windsurf wave sailing same thing.
You usually sail outside catch a swell and ride it in until the wave breaks. It's your wave first and most likely you are furthest upwind as well. If a surfer paddles into a wave it is usually given to him/her as kitesurfing or windsurfing in waves can get way more waves. Number one sailing rule is avoid a collision at all times.
ApatheticEnd
ApatheticEnd
WA
995 posts
WA, 995 posts
3 Jan 2012 8:36pm
alverstone said...

heading 'in' to The Pond... should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit...


Not to break balls man but if you spend 5 mins watching at the Pond you'll see the way the rotation works and the stbd rule doesn't fit with the geography. The upwind kiter (nearer the beach) has right of way so he has room to throw a trick. The rotation goes E to W. Once you reach the shallow end of the pond you turn and bear downwind to give way to kiters coming in who are about to throw down. If you take a stbd tack close to the upwind side, and try and insist by yelling "stbd" you're screwing it up for everyone and you're going to get a talking to about spacial awareness.

My $0.02


theDoctor
theDoctor
NSW
5786 posts
NSW, 5786 posts
3 Jan 2012 11:52pm
alverstone said...

This was written after playing chicken with other kiters and poleys over the Christmas break, and as a reply to all the threads about rules on the water/leaners/Euros/whinging and how even the experienced screw up.

When you're on the water a STARBOARD tack - ie with the wind coming over the right shoulder - has right of way. It's a basic rule of the sea.
Those on port tacks - heading out to sea in a SW'ly at Dutch, heading 'in' to The Pond, heading towards Ardross at Melville, heading to Penguin at Shaolwater - should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit, if a poley, if faced with those coming at 'em on a opposite tack.
My dinghy instructor said the rule comes from the Vikings when their longships had steering oars on the right side of their sterns. This made them less manoeuvrable compared to a ship on an opposite tack coming towards them.
The steering oar of the port tack ship would have been on its leeward side and 'digging' deeper into the water, allowing the ship to bear away from the wind/oncoming vessel faster.
"Port" comes from the ships tying up with the steering oar-less side facing the wharf to protect the primitive rudder.
Or is this just a yarn spun to keep novice sailiors quiet?
Now could someone please explain how that affects the arcane rules waxheads apply when you take the kite in the surf?



Sorry to burst your bubble captain stubing....

But your yacht rules ain't gonna account for much but a punch to your head in the pond
tgladman
tgladman
WA
500 posts
WA, 500 posts
3 Jan 2012 11:06pm
What are "Vikings"?
shodan
shodan
WA
60 posts
WA, 60 posts
3 Jan 2012 11:21pm
Real response on a Texas drivers liecence test:

Q. Who has right of way at an unsign posted 4 way intersection.

Learner drivers answer: the pickup truck with the gun rack.

Realism at it's best.

Only in Texas.
kiteboy dave
kiteboy dave
QLD
6525 posts
JBFletch
JBFletch
QLD
1287 posts
QLD, 1287 posts
4 Jan 2012 9:59am
had the same problem on the lake up north over chrissy.

i just resorted to this.
(dont worry, no poledancers where harmed in this photo)



saltiest1
saltiest1
NSW
2568 posts
NSW, 2568 posts
4 Jan 2012 11:36am
so what if safety bay isnt the only place to kite? ^^ btw poley is on port tack. evil poley.
alverstone
alverstone
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
4 Jan 2012 9:52am
ApatheticEnd said...

alverstone said...

heading 'in' to The Pond... should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit...


Not to break balls man but if you spend 5 mins watching at the Pond you'll see the way the rotation works and the stbd rule doesn't fit with the geography. The upwind kiter (nearer the beach) has right of way so he has room to throw a trick. The rotation goes E to W. Once you reach the shallow end of the pond you turn and bear downwind to give way to kiters coming in who are about to throw down. If you take a stbd tack close to the upwind side, and try and insist by yelling "stbd" you're screwing it up for everyone and you're going to get a talking to about spacial awareness.

My $0.02





alverstone
alverstone
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
4 Jan 2012 9:55am
alverstone said...

ApatheticEnd said...

alverstone said...

heading 'in' to The Pond... should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit...


Not to break balls man but if you spend 5 mins watching at the Pond you'll see the way the rotation works and the stbd rule doesn't fit with the geography. The upwind kiter (nearer the beach) has right of way so he has room to throw a trick. The rotation goes E to W. Once you reach the shallow end of the pond you turn and bear downwind to give way to kiters coming in who are about to throw down. If you take a stbd tack close to the upwind side, and try and insist by yelling "stbd" you're screwing it up for everyone and you're going to get a talking to about spacial awareness.



My $0.02








Oops. I get your point, stand corrected and withdraw The Pond from the rule - it's a 'special' place for 'special' people - Alverstone.

Glug
Glug
WA
106 posts
WA, 106 posts
4 Jan 2012 11:41am
Mate as a racing sailor I can tell you the rules are better applied to sailing yachts, windsurfers and even kite boarders racing upwind and downwind around a track.

Sure in theory Port and Starboard still apply to recreational kiters, but in practice most kiters are beam reaching back and forth and if your slightly more downwind of a kiter heading towards you you maintain your line and drop the kite a little, and if you are upwind raise your kite a little. When in doubt just adjust your line and make it clear what your intentions are. Thats it. Easy.

Trying to place rules over recreational kites will be largely ignored and dangerous for anyone around someone trying to assert their 'right' to starboard right of way.
alverstone
alverstone
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
4 Jan 2012 1:19pm
KIT33R said...

We went to a lot of trouble at NSWKBA to prepare this "Code of Conduct" for safety on the water. Hope it helps.

http://www.nswkba.com.au/coc




The following below is taken from the Code mentioned above.
Thanks!!!

The following Right of Way guidelines should be adhered to when Kite Surfing: (courtesy of WAKSA)
There is no absolute right of way - All parties should take any action necessary to avoid a collision.


When two riders are on opposite tacks and there is a need to alter course to avoid collision, the port tack rider (left shoulder forward) shall alter course and/or kite position in order to keep clear of the starboard tack rider (right shoulder forward) who should maintain the same course and speed.


When two or more riders are on the same tack with kite lines overlapped, the upwind rider(s) shall keep their kite high and the downwind rider(s) keep their kite low.


When two riders are on the same tack and are not overlapped, the rider behind shall ensure the rider ahead is aware of the rider approaching from behind.


Never deliberately manoeuvre into a right of way position so that it interferes with another water user. If you are behind another kite heading into the beach, turn early to allow the lead rider plenty of room to turn. Always check for other water users before water-starting, jibing, relaunching a kite or recovering a board.


A rider shall not jump if there is any danger of possible collision with another rider.


When wave riding, the first rider on the face of a wave has right of way. This may override the starboard tack rule. Give way to surfers even if they drop in on your wave.


Give way to surfers and other water users when in the surf, at all times.


Do not tack out through a surf break that is occupied by surfers.


All riders should be aware of and abide by all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations.
alverstone
alverstone
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
4 Jan 2012 1:29pm
tgladman said...

What are "Vikings"?


For real? Oh well, here goes ....
They are the Scandanavian 9th century equivilent of FIFO mine workers. They would get on 90ft longships from Denmark, Norway or Sweden and raid/rape/pillage parts of England, and France, after their compatriots settled Iceland, discovered Newfoundland and traded as far as the Black Sea. Big hairy blokes with helmets with horns on their heads who fathered all those blonde backpacking lovelies with scantanavian bikinis who distract you from holding an edge at the beach.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
4 Jan 2012 6:44pm
I think maybe this thread needs clarification for noobs (?)
Do what you do at the pond. If it is all kiters out, do what you do. Who cares.

However, if there are others out at a 'mixed' spot, yachties and windsurfers will assume that kiters know about starboard having ROW, and that the kiters will comply.

A noob reading this would think the rules don't apply to them. No, they may not apply at the pond as it is different, but pretty much everywhere else they do.

And waxhead rules about "first on wave owns it" still apply no matter if you can do 50m runs thru the break
CRUZIN
CRUZIN
WA
55 posts
WA, 55 posts
4 Jan 2012 6:51pm
the pond should be no different, one set of rules/guidelines, starboard has right of way then everybody should know what the other is doing, its not that hard
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23649 posts
WA, 23649 posts
4 Jan 2012 6:56pm
CRUZIN said...

the pond should be no different, one set of rules/guidelines, starboard has right of way then everybody should know what the other is doing, its not that hard


Hey that is what I was going to say but I'm trying not to upset the kiters
rdunlop
rdunlop
WA
57 posts
WA, 57 posts
5 Jan 2012 4:29pm

I liken the 'Pond' to an events location like a race track or sportsground. Experienced Kiters are performing freestyle tricks and the layout, wind direction and topography determine the rotation and jumping area. International yachting rules just don't apply. Freestyle best describes a kiter engaging in rapid changes of direction, height and position that can not be anticipated by another watercraft. Pond rotation rules ensure the safety of those in the jump and tricks area, forget the sailing rules, no traffic lights at Wanneroo Raceway.
alverstone said...

This was written after playing chicken with other kiters and poleys over the Christmas break, and as a reply to all the threads about rules on the water/leaners/Euros/whinging and how even the experienced screw up.

When you're on the water a STARBOARD tack - ie with the wind coming over the right shoulder - has right of way. It's a basic rule of the sea.
Those on port tacks - heading out to sea in a SW'ly at Dutch, heading 'in' to The Pond, heading towards Ardross at Melville, heading to Penguin at Shaolwater - should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit, if a poley, if faced with those coming at 'em on a opposite tack.
My dinghy instructor said the rule comes from the Vikings when their longships had steering oars on the right side of their sterns. This made them less manoeuvrable compared to a ship on an opposite tack coming towards them.
The steering oar of the port tack ship would have been on its leeward side and 'digging' deeper into the water, allowing the ship to bear away from the wind/oncoming vessel faster.
"Port" comes from the ships tying up with the steering oar-less side facing the wharf to protect the primitive rudder.
Or is this just a yarn spun to keep novice sailiors quiet?
Now could someone please explain how that affects the arcane rules waxheads apply when you take the kite in the surf?


PBR
PBR
WA
7 posts
PBR PBR
WA, 7 posts
5 Jan 2012 4:41pm
Based on Ray Finkle rules...if the ball isn't held laces out you will miss wide right every time.

If you run into someone blame Dan Marino.
eppo
eppo
WA
9790 posts
WA, 9790 posts
6 Jan 2012 12:00am
Like the shoulder rule rather than starboard, port stuff. So in WA on south wester heading out to sea (left should forward) you give way to dudes coming into shore getting ready to line up for a wave. Makes sense..farq the pond by the way, you guys can have it.
Plummet
Plummet
4862 posts
4862 posts
6 Jan 2012 3:54am
if everyone turns right then theres no problem!...
JY77
JY77
QLD
89 posts
QLD, 89 posts
6 Jan 2012 6:48am
Posted 03/01/2012, 3:09 pm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahua
Sailing rules still apply ie upwind sailor on the wave has right of way, first sailor/surfer on the wave has right of way. Look at windsurf wave sailing same thing.
You usually sail outside catch a swell and ride it in until the wave breaks. It's your wave first and most likely you are furthest upwind as well. If a surfer paddles into a wave it is usually given to him/her as kitesurfing or windsurfing in waves can get way more waves. Number one sailing rule is avoid a collision at all times.


Sailing rules say when on the same tack, windward boat must keep clear. Should read your blue book again.
yeehaa
yeehaa
QLD
123 posts
QLD, 123 posts
7 Jan 2012 11:32am
alverstone said...

This was written after playing chicken with other kiters and poleys over the Christmas break, and as a reply to all the threads about rules on the water/leaners/Euros/whinging and how even the experienced screw up.

When you're on the water a STARBOARD tack - ie with the wind coming over the right shoulder - has right of way. It's a basic rule of the sea.
Those on port tacks - heading out to sea in a SW'ly at Dutch, heading 'in' to The Pond, heading towards Ardross at Melville, heading to Penguin at Shaolwater - should drop their kites or bear downwind a bit, if a poley, if faced with those coming at 'em on a opposite tack.
My dinghy instructor said the rule comes from the Vikings when their longships had steering oars on the right side of their sterns. This made them less manoeuvrable compared to a ship on an opposite tack coming towards them.
The steering oar of the port tack ship would have been on its leeward side and 'digging' deeper into the water, allowing the ship to bear away from the wind/oncoming vessel faster.
"Port" comes from the ships tying up with the steering oar-less side facing the wharf to protect the primitive rudder.
Or is this just a yarn spun to keep novice sailiors quiet?
Now could someone please explain how that affects the arcane rules waxheads apply when you take the kite in the surf?



Sod off if your upwind raise your kite. Downwind lower your kite and bear off slightly. Next thing you'll want us to get a licence to have fun
coffeebean
coffeebean
WA
54 posts
WA, 54 posts
7 Jan 2012 11:29am
h aha ha ha viking shipss
tgladman
tgladman
WA
500 posts
WA, 500 posts
7 Jan 2012 1:41pm
i should have asked where the relevance is.
check your calender, its 2012.

alverstone said...

tgladman said...

What are "Vikings"?


For real? Oh well, here goes ....
They are the Scandanavian 9th century equivilent of FIFO mine workers. They would get on 90ft longships from Denmark, Norway or Sweden and raid/rape/pillage parts of England, and France, after their compatriots settled Iceland, discovered Newfoundland and traded as far as the Black Sea. Big hairy blokes with helmets with horns on their heads who fathered all those blonde backpacking lovelies with scantanavian bikinis who distract you from holding an edge at the beach.


eppo
eppo
WA
9790 posts
WA, 9790 posts
7 Jan 2012 9:59pm
Plummet said...

if everyone turns right then theres no problem!...




Whoh that's even simplier. Yeh everyone turn right! And stop confusing us with your sailing sh!t, for us mere mortals. Yeh everyone turn right, spot on!
saltiest1
saltiest1
NSW
2568 posts
NSW, 2568 posts
8 Jan 2012 1:32am
PBR said...

Based on Ray Finkle rules...if the ball isn't held laces out you will miss wide right every time.

If you run into someone blame Dan Marino.




finkle, einhorne. einhorne, finkle....
Nalu
Nalu
WA
5 posts
WA, 5 posts
8 Jan 2012 8:22am
JY77 said...

Posted 03/01/2012, 3:09 pm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahua
Sailing rules still apply ie upwind sailor on the wave has right of way, first sailor/surfer on the wave has right of way. Look at windsurf wave sailing same thing.
You usually sail outside catch a swell and ride it in until the wave breaks. It's your wave first and most likely you are furthest upwind as well. If a surfer paddles into a wave it is usually given to him/her as kitesurfing or windsurfing in waves can get way more waves. Number one sailing rule is avoid a collision at all times.


Sailing rules say when on the same tack, windward boat must keep clear. Should read your blue book again.


I think you should read the question again:
It was about wave riding/sailing/surfing and not talking about the same tack and boats racing etc You probably shouldn't kite in waves if you don't like it, and definitely don't go out in Hawaii.
You won't find them in a Blue book but you will end up with a Black eye if you don't follow them.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅