Are Gath helmets ok for Kitesurfing??

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
hoskoau
hoskoau
NSW
100 posts
NSW, 100 posts
30 Oct 2008 3:35am
On the Gath Sports website they say:

"Gath Helmets Trade Off a percentage of impact absorption for a more close fitting layer of defence to better suit high performance extreme sports."

Obviously if I smack my head hard enough to cause the helmet to break its going to hurt what ever I had strapped to my cranium. I would think there that being hit in the head by a long board would cause more damage then hitting your head on a twin tip board. But what about the kite throwing you onto something.

Anyway just double checking that its cool to use my surf helmet when I'm kite surfing. If all else fails here is my backup plan.

lostinlondon
lostinlondon
VIC
1159 posts
VIC, 1159 posts
30 Oct 2008 9:31am
I wear a Gath Gedi, seems to be fine. Better than wearing nothing. It will protect you from board hits/collisions with others, but if you get dragged face first along the beach into a sea wall I guess it wouldn't be as good as a motorbike helmet!



theDoctor
theDoctor
NSW
5786 posts
NSW, 5786 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:17am
hoskoau said...

If all else fails here is my backup plan.




so what you are trying to say is, that pussies wear helmets...?
sci
sci
WA
762 posts
sci sci
WA, 762 posts
30 Oct 2008 8:55am
Only get one if you are paranoid about cracking your skull or you are particularly accident prone. The same people who wear gath helmets also tend to wear 2cm of body armour and a reel leash.

I used to wear one when I surfed 10ft offshore bombies in Ireland were you had a good chance of bouncing off the reef.But for kiting why bother?!
dism
dism
NSW
660 posts
NSW, 660 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:06am
If it makes you feel safer to try new stuff, then its good

You can't kite when your dead

Been a few of windsurfing incidents that helmets could have saved people
kapac
kapac
69 posts
69 posts
30 Oct 2008 9:43am
SCI - It's not about paranoia it's about anticipation. As much as I love the feel and the sound of the wind in my ears, I use a Gath helmet and won't kitesurf without one. Already it has saved me twice from having my ear ripped off by someone's lines and helped me avoid whiplash. I know someone who lost 6 months of his life (spent that time in ICU and can't remember a thing) after a 12 knt gust (!) lofted him. He thought pussies wore helmets.

It's all about personal preference but I'm surprised at how many people DON'T wear them. I don't mind if that makes me a pussy 'cos least I'm more likely to be a live one after the next kitemare.
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:14am
Hi guys,

If my memory serves me correctly, the Gath helmets have a little sticker in them in red writing that says, not to be used as an impact helmet. They are mainly to reduce cuts from reef and fin chops to the head as well as keep the sun off your dome.

If you want impact resistance then you need to look at a proper helmet designed for that kind of stuff like the Protec water range of helmets.







Nice helmets and have excellent padding.

Good winds,


richswing
richswing
WA
724 posts
WA, 724 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:48am
Hey Guys,

I saw some pics of a kiters accident I think in Brazil, sadly the guy lost his life. Before they removed the gruesome pictures they showed the guy lying on the ground bleeding out from his head - not a very nice sight at all.

It's is sad that that accident made me get a helmet but I do not want my family to see me like that and have to suffer because I was to cool to wear a helmet.

Places like Melville beach should be compulsory, especially after yesterday with those gusts coming through.

On the beach I don't think it is that necessary but I wear it anyway, so that when I am kiting it becomes second nature - just like wearing your seat belt in the car.

I bought one of the Protec helmets and I am really happy with it as I have an unusual shape head and normally find hats/caps/peaks unconfortable.

Kite boards/ kite specific surfboards are made a hell of a lot stronger than surfboards - surfboards usually have 2 layers of glass on top and 1 layer on the bottom except for the rail wear you have 3 layers due to the overlap. Kite surfboards have around 4 to 6 layers all round with some for of deck pad to prevent pressure dings. Big difference!

Kind regards
Rich
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
30 Oct 2008 10:51am
sci said...

Only get one if you are paranoid about cracking your skull or you are particularly accident prone. The same people who wear gath helmets also tend to wear 2cm of body armour and a reel leash.

I used to wear one when I surfed 10ft offshore bombies in Ireland were you had a good chance of bouncing off the reef.But for kiting why bother?!


Hey in that case why bother with a safety line or even checking the wind strength - just throw up ya biggest kite and hope for the best..

Mate, have you noticed the power a kite generates?

Helmets aren't for everyone but I hope you are kidding with the above comments Sci?? Unless of course you can't boost over 10ft and stay 200m from shore/obstacles at all times..

There has been several times when I have been extremely glad to be wearing a helmet (and vest) from getting smashed on the water alone. I value my melons contents over all else - hey but that's just daggy ol' me.


BTW Hoskoau - I used an original Gath for my 1st few seasons and it was ok for the odd bumps etc (better than nuttin) but now have a Protec Wake Ace and they are 300% better in every respect. As you progress and start to push the envelope for bigger boosts/tricks, I think a helmet is just as releveant as your gumby learning stage. Just to re-iterate - hey but that's just daggy ol' me.
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4103 posts
QLD, 4103 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:55am
richswing said...

Before they removed the gruesome pictures they showed the guy lying on the ground bleeding out from his head - not a very nice sight at all.


I kept a copy of those photos just to remind myself what being killed kiteboarding looks like, if anyone wants a copy drop me a PM.
dirtyharry
dirtyharry
WA
444 posts
WA, 444 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:29am
Kitehard said...

Hi guys,

If my memory serves me correctly, the Gath helmets have a little sticker in them in red writing that says, not to be used as an impact helmet. They are mainly to reduce cuts from reef and fin chops to the head as well as keep the sun off your dome.

If you want impact resistance then you need to look at a proper helmet designed for that kind of stuff like the Protec water range of helmets.







Nice helmets and have excellent padding.

Good winds,





That disclaimer is probably more to cover their arse so people don't go riding motorbikes with them and stuff like that. Anyway, wouldn't cuts from reef and fin chops be caused by impacts??

I can't see anything wrong with Gaths for kiting (not that I claim to have any reason to know either way - just a gut feeling).

Maybe Kitehard doesn't sell Gaths?

I don't know why I've suddenly started to join the anti-pimping crusade [}:)] Back in my box I go.
dism
dism
NSW
660 posts
NSW, 660 posts
30 Oct 2008 1:49pm
The first row of Protec helmets look like they are made of underwater equestrian events, but i'd wear all the others (esp. the last row look most like Gaths and protect allmost all the head)
au_rick
au_rick
WA
752 posts
WA, 752 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:53am
Gath's work well for kiting, nice and light, you forget you're wearing it.
I've been clobbered in the head a few times in the surf when I've goofed a move and they do the job just fine.
au_rick
au_rick
WA
752 posts
WA, 752 posts
30 Oct 2008 11:55am
dirtyharry said...

Kitehard said...

Hi guys,

If my memory serves me correctly, the Gath helmets have a little sticker in them in red writing that says, not to be used as an impact helmet. They are mainly to reduce cuts from reef and fin chops to the head as well as keep the sun off your dome.

If you want impact resistance then you need to look at a proper helmet designed for that kind of stuff like the Protec water range of helmets.







Nice helmets and have excellent padding.

Good winds,





That disclaimer is probably more to cover their arse so people don't go riding motorbikes with them and stuff like that. Anyway, wouldn't cuts from reef and fin chops be caused by impacts??

I can't see anything wrong with Gaths for kiting (not that I claim to have any reason to know either way - just a gut feeling).

Maybe Kitehard doesn't sell Gaths?

I don't know why I've suddenly started to join the anti-pimping crusade [}:)] Back in my box I go.



LOL, all my waterski gear bears stickers that say the use of this equipment may cause injury or death, does that mean I'm not gunna use it ???
andycass
andycass
QLD
85 posts
QLD, 85 posts
30 Oct 2008 1:32pm
I use both gaths and protec (I only wear one at a time) and severall times they have made the difference between saying 'ooh that could of hurt' and hospital. You only have one head so protect it.
sci
sci
WA
762 posts
sci sci
WA, 762 posts
30 Oct 2008 12:55pm
It is totally personal preference wether you wear a helmet - I do not care! There are those of us who are more safety conscious than others and that is your choice.

Kiting IS a dangerous sport and there is a good chance you are going to get BEAT at some point depending on location and conditions - so why not wear the nut protector in anticipation of that day.

I guess with respect to topic thread "Are Gath helmets ok for Kitesurfing??" Then yes!
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
30 Oct 2008 12:58pm
Hi Dirty Harry,


You said: "I can't see anything wrong with Gaths for kiting (not that I claim to have any reason to know either way - just a gut feeling).

Maybe Kitehard doesn't sell Gaths?

I don't know why I've suddenly started to join the anti-pimping crusade Back in my box I go."


No pimping, just expressing an opinion. We used to use the Gath's in the school, but they were often uncomfortable and had very little padding, just soft foam to make them fit better, not to protect your nut from impact.

I have a bunch of ex-school 2nd hand Gaths that I am happy to part with for a case of beer if you want em, But i sure wouldn't want to run into anything more solid with em than a surfboard.

Taken from Gath's Website:

"Gath Helmets Trade Off a percentage of impact absorption for a more close fitting layer of defence to better suit high performance extreme sports.

Gath protects against the more frequent sporting head injury caused by glancing blows rather than from a direct head first 'crash' into a fixed solid object, where serious injury is likely to occur regardless of helmet.

Gath provides a lightweight super snug fitting layer of defence against superficial head injury and water pressure induced ear perforation and the damaging effects from sun, wind and salt spray."


Good winds,



sunseeker
sunseeker
QLD
1203 posts
QLD, 1203 posts
30 Oct 2008 5:15pm
So in other words, if you expect to hit rocks or a brick wall with your head then the GAth is no good. If you are only going to hit your board or something similar then it is OK.
Smedg
Smedg
NSW
836 posts
NSW, 836 posts
30 Oct 2008 7:00pm
I think the ones posted in the pic by kitehard are probably safest. I wear a BMX helmet that is similar to the Ace Wake helmet. (use it on the pushie too). I actually bought a gath after having my tt get picked up by a barrel and spear into the back of my head causing stars, **** loads of blood and a nice big scars. (on an empty beach too so was lucky it wasn't worse, had to get in, pack everything myself while the white sandy beach was quickly turning red and brown with blood.)

Guy who sold me the gath said everyone buys them AFTER and injury. haha.

Anyway, don't like kiting in it at all. visor gets scratched by sand, so never used the visor, ear pieces whistle like its a cyclone from 12knots up and its a hassle to wear sunnies with it as there is no room for the arms, unlike more padded helmets. I reckon the 'disclaimer' about not being suitable to protect from impact or what ever it says is valid because there is only like 2 or 3 mm of padding and becoming unconscious in water is of coarse SOOOOOOOO much more scary than on land for obvious reason. my pushie helmet is perfect for me.

For the safety conscious:
Its said that the bigger wider floatier helmets pose more of a threat to neck injury when impacting with water, which makes sense but I'm personally a bit dismissive of this potential risk as haven't gone close to hurting my neck from this sort of situation yet.
Smooooth holeless outer shells are the safest for falling off anything on land, assuming its padded. This is due to the increased strength of the shell and the lack of snag points for if you slide. (The expensive, light aerodynamic, vented type pushie helmets are ****. (for pushies too) They are made to minimum safety standards with focus on weight and ventilation etc.

To conclude this essay...
If concerned about consciousness get something padded. If you are concerned about cuts only and kinda liked the Mighty Morphin Power Ranger look, go the Gath (but not the one you currently have, its ****. you need to up grade to this awesome one i just happen to have for sale)
Danger Mouse
Danger Mouse
WA
592 posts
WA, 592 posts
31 Oct 2008 1:24pm
Smedg said...

I wear a BMX helmet that is similar to the Ace Wake helmet. (use it on the pushie too). I


Does it look like this Smedg?


ianmac
ianmac
WA
267 posts
WA, 267 posts
31 Oct 2008 1:46pm
I have kiting for about a year now and have worn a gath lid everytime i go out while it may not be the optimum head gear it certainly keeps the sun off your lugs at least, i also self tested water impacts with the back of my head while learning to jump & can attest that i was very happy to wear it i also wear a vest which sucks up a lot pain when you come undone on some jumps. the idea of getting some injury although unlikely and not being able to kite keeps me wearing a lid & vest. i think fashion rules a lot of the outcomes
like boardies& Wetties LOL [}:)]
Kadkhah
Kadkhah
WA
381 posts
WA, 381 posts
31 Oct 2008 3:01pm
I'm using a Gath helmet cuz I'm to lazy to retrieve my board and I'm using a reel leash


and I'm using a vest cuz I'm too lazy to keep my self on the water while I'm trying to water relaunch in a low wind.

I know it all makes me look goofy but I'm relax and safe.
P.S. My Gath saved my life couple of times.


Good Wind
Alex
Smedg
Smedg
NSW
836 posts
NSW, 836 posts
31 Oct 2008 9:38pm
D_Meredith79 said...

Smedg said...

I wear a BMX helmet that is similar to the Ace Wake helmet. (use it on the pushie too). I


Does it look like this Smedg?





haha. yep goes well with the tall red flag on the back of my bike.
lostinlondon
lostinlondon
VIC
1159 posts
VIC, 1159 posts
31 Oct 2008 10:10pm
Kadkhah said...

I'm using a Gath helmet cuz I'm to lazy to retrieve my board and I'm using a reel leash


and I'm using a vest cuz I'm too lazy to keep my self on the water while I'm trying to water relaunch in a low wind.

I know it all makes me look goofy but I'm relax and safe.
P.S. My Gath saved my life couple of times.


Good Wind
Alex


No, no, no, no... don't start talking about leashes on this thread, damn this was a good and humorous discussion about the merits of different helmets!

<Having a Rain-man fit and slapping my hand against my head repeatedly>
dirtyharry
dirtyharry
WA
444 posts
WA, 444 posts
31 Oct 2008 8:34pm
Kitehard said...


No pimping, just expressing an opinion.



An opinion that promotes a product you sell at the expense of another (which sounds like pimping to me?). And a product which I think is reasonably well suited to the job in question.

Granted, the others may offer a greater level of protection. But would you care to estimate the number of kiting head injuries that have occurred to someone wearing a helmet which would not have occurred with a more protective helmet? Or, the number of head injuries in kiting which wouldn't have occurred with the helmets you're promoting but which would have occurred to some extent with a Gath type helmet?

Point being, it's like arguing over differnet quality of an air bag or seat belt in a car. You're that far ahead having one at all that it seems petty to argue about the quality of them.

I actually think you're posts are generally impartial, fair and very helpful and I don't for second deny that you're a positive contributor to the kiting community. But that post was unfair pimping IMO. However, that's just my OPINION
fver
fver
WA
453 posts
WA, 453 posts
31 Oct 2008 8:46pm
Hoskoau,

Go to a shop like Mainpeak or similar and have a look at the whitewater helmets, such as the Protec. You will immediately see that they protect significantly more than Gath helmets against impact (except the "underwater equestrian events" series, first row on the photo posted by Kitehard). Whitewater helmets have a thicker shell and a thicker (and adjustable to perfectly fit your nut) foam padding. You can also attach your sunnies to the helmet to minimise the risk of loosing them during harsh crashes.

Fred
spot1
spot1
WA
1588 posts
WA, 1588 posts
31 Oct 2008 9:24pm
what do you need a helmet for what are you going to hit
just to add to all the acc
helmet
glassers
pdf
any one want to add to the list
reel leash
steamer in summer
jonojonojono
jonojonojono
79 posts
79 posts
31 Oct 2008 9:25pm
^KitePants:-))Mobile Phone, Waterproof Bluetooth Headset, Wistle(why not) :-P
Steamer in summer I could be guilty, is it summer yet?


dism said...

The first row of Protec helmets look like they are made of underwater equestrian events, but i'd wear all the others (esp. the last row look most like Gaths and protect allmost all the head)


My horses keep dying on me, but the sport is progressing. I'm getting a 1000% depower horse soon.

I use a Gedi. Is nice.

sci said...
- so why not wear the nut protector in anticipation of that day.


Yes my cup makes me nuts feel invincible!

Kitehard said...

Gath protects against the more frequent sporting head injury caused by glancing blows rather than from a direct head first 'crash' into a fixed solid object, where serious injury is likely to occur regardless of helmet.

Gath provides a lightweight super snug fitting layer of defence against superficial head injury and water pressure induced ear perforation and the damaging effects from sun, wind and salt spray."




That they do very well. Are the Protecs better for repeated impacts with the water?

dirtyharry said...

Granted, the others may offer a greater level of protection. But would you care to estimate the number of kiting head injuries that have occurred to someone wearing a helmet which would not have occurred with a more protective helmet? Or, the number of head injuries in kiting which wouldn't have occurred with the helmets you're promoting but which would have occurred to some extent with a Gath type helmet?

Point being, it's like arguing over differnet quality of an air bag or seat belt in a car. You're that far ahead having one at all that it seems petty to argue about the quality of them.



So who can compare the GEDI vs ACEWAKE? Anyone. I can compare the GEDI vs older-Gath, Older-Gath is crap. :-))
sandman
sandman
WA
432 posts
WA, 432 posts
1 Nov 2008 12:15am
sunseeker said...

So in other words, if you expect to hit rocks or a brick wall with your head then the GAth is no good. If you are only going to hit your board or something similar then it is OK.


I think that pretty much sums it up... almost

One other point that I am surprised no one has bought up is whiplash, chuck a big helmet on and the weight of your head increases, therefore increasing the forces on your neck during a water crash.
A simular point is that of displacment, if the helmet it 'fat' you are not gonna part the water as easily as you crash, putting strain on your neck in a simular way.

IMO the basic gath is pretty low profile and very light so not gonna cause much of a whiplash problem, I used mine windsurfing all the time and survived some hairy mast knocks (dont bother now that I kite). as for sea walls and rocks...sounds like a dodgy place to kite.
lostinlondon
lostinlondon
VIC
1159 posts
VIC, 1159 posts
1 Nov 2008 2:29am
As I understand it, if your sustain a major blow to your helmet, (that includes dropping it) that's pretty much it for your helmet. The foam inside it compresses and even if the shell looks OK it still could be no good inside.

I use a helmet for snowboarding (v similar to the protec ones, it's a Burton), as I like going really really fast, hitting tree runs and the like.

If you were doing kickers/sliders etc I would go for one of those Protec ones. But as soon as you smash it on the slider I think thats it for it.

If you just like free-riding/waves etc I would think that a Gath would be fine, especially if you don't use a leash. I have been hit a few times by my board (I don't use a leash) but it's not so bad as you tend to be travelling at the same speed and direction as your board. I don't do big waves but that would be a different story I imagine with a twin-tip, especially if you use one of those Naish all wood jobbies.

One of the best aspects of wearing a helmet is the sun protection factor. I get a burnt head easily in the water.
lotofwind
lotofwind
NSW
6451 posts
NSW, 6451 posts
1 Nov 2008 9:55am
Pussies might wear helmets,but pussies get 9 lives....purrrrrrrr
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅