Ha ha - never wore out an album as I used to listen to each shiny new record once - checking optimum record levels on a decent cassette deck - then transfer to cassette on the 2nd pass and tuck the fragile black platter back away and flog the cassette to death.
U2's 1st 4 albums copped an absolute hiding till the cass was all stretched and saggy sounding.. then I taped a new copy again.

EDIT: Oh also a cass given to me by a girlfriend with A-side: New Order - 'Low Life' with B-side: Blue Ruin - 'Such sweet thunder' got LOADS and LOADS of listens. Still have that cass today.

In recent years I got really stuck on the Eels Souljacker (till I had to ban it from my own car) and a compliation of The Be Good Tanyas.