Divorce question

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
R0CKSTAR
R0CKSTAR
35 posts
35 posts
12 Jan 2011 10:31am
My mate is going through a messy divorce and is in the process of getting a lawyer, but in the interim I thought I'd post here, see if anyone who's been through similar **** can advise. He's just received some doco from his ex's lawyer stating he needs to attend a mediation session in court, the same doco also stated she wants 80%! Their financial circumstances are pretty even, so 80% seems pretty high.

- he's a tradie earning $60K
- she's an Admin Assistant earning $40K
- they own a $900k house with $150k mortgage (which he lives in & is trying to sell)
- they have two kids with 50/50 custody
- they were together 10 years

Would a court really grant someone in this position 80%? Also he cannot sell the house, she's insisting he drop the price significantly, can a court order him to keep on dropping the price until he sells the house? Any advice would be appreciated.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23645 posts
WA, 23645 posts
12 Jan 2011 10:34am
I'll buy the $900 house from him today, sight unseen.

If he owes $150K on it he'll have some shortfall though

Little Jon
Little Jon
NSW
2115 posts
NSW, 2115 posts
12 Jan 2011 1:38pm
My sister-in-law went through a divorce and the husband never attended anything, even the court hearings or the information requests. In the end the Judge was powerless to do anything.
whippingboy
whippingboy
WA
1104 posts
WA, 1104 posts
12 Jan 2011 11:09am
Yeah mate been there.

The rules depend on who gets custody, and the total amount of assets (including sports equipment, guitar collections and cars).

IF they are going 50/50 custody, that is how a court will apportion the assets 50/50.

I ended up getting 25%, and Im still pretty upset (6 years later)

The problems usually occur when there is a dispute over who gets custody.

Avoid lawyers if possible 'cause they'll clean you out.

Child support also depends on the level of custody.

Good luck to your brother and make sure he gets plenty of support.

getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
12 Jan 2011 12:03pm
It's not quite as bad as it used to gbe but if you are a bloke going through a divorce get used to bending over and thinking of England.

The only diff these days is the depth is not quite as bad as it used to be.

I say this cause if your mate expects a fair outcome he is garaunteed to get himself deeper into depression and anger that may last the rest of his life.

If there is animosity between the couple its will almost definately play against him.

Try to placate the ex and expect the worse, don't expect fairness it doesn't exist in the family courts. The family court is stuck in the 50s with a bloke = provider and mum = nuturer philosophy set in stone. Simple as that.

That's just how it is so he can waste energy fighting it and get more angry, or use his energies to make the best of what he ends up with and move forward/away from the negative sh!t.


upwind
upwind
QLD
166 posts
QLD, 166 posts
12 Jan 2011 4:48pm
Mate, went through it all quite a few years back, if he wants to get rid of her ,it is probably worth sacrifising some thing, ...worked for me anyway, and I have no feelings of guilt or any of that crap, knowing that she is happy with what she got! And I am FREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
Cassa
Cassa
WA
1305 posts
WA, 1305 posts
12 Jan 2011 2:50pm
getfunky said...

It's not quite as bad as it used to gbe but if you are a bloke going through a divorce get used to bending over and thinking of England.

The only diff these days is the depth is not quite as bad as it used to be.

I say this cause if your mate expects a fair outcome he is garaunteed to get himself deeper into depression and anger that may last the rest of his life.

If there is animosity between the couple its will almost definately play against him.

Try to placate the ex and expect the worse, don't expect fairness it doesn't exist in the family courts. The family court is stuck in the 50s with a bloke = provider and mum = nuturer philosophy set in stone. Simple as that.

That's just how it is so he can waste energy fighting it and get more angry, or use his energies to make the best of what he ends up with and move forward/away from the negative sh!t.








So True GF
tightlines
tightlines
WA
3509 posts
WA, 3509 posts
12 Jan 2011 3:11pm
If she already has a lawyer he will def have to get one, yes they are bloody expensive but they are not all bad and if you get a good one they may be able to get it sorted quick, IMO that is one of the main things.

There is heaps that they take into consideration (super, custody etc) but I doubt very much that she would end up with anywhere near 80% or even 70% if going 50/50 with custody.
If he can avoid making it a battle of lawyers great but if she is being unrealistic that is the road he will have to go down, I think a lot of women listen to friends etc and think they will end up with more than they usually get so lawyers are inevitable (sometimes her lawyer is the one telling her she will get more to perpetuate things).

Divorce was (at the time) by far the worst experience of my life but now a few years down the track it turns out that it was one of the best things to happen to me.....it's not all bad.
longwinded
longwinded
WA
347 posts
WA, 347 posts
12 Jan 2011 4:25pm
Am there now.
1. Get a good lawyer. Have just watched my $700 an hour lawyer chew up and spit out her $300 an hour job. Remember that the cost comes out nearly the same in the end as the leg work is done by junior lawyers and clerks in a big law firm and the expensive one directs the show and then appears front and centre on the day. Using a small office lawyer means you will be paying for them to do all of it.
2. Go to the mediation. Remember that her documents are only a first round offer. Like any offer, there is always ambit in the first claim. Mediation is by far the best way out and a hell of a lot cheaper. Doesn't look good if you go straight to court without seriously trying dispute resolution and the court wont let you into the system unless you have a certificate from the mediation providers stating that you have tried and it failed.
3. If mediation fails, be prepared for a long wait for your day in court.
4. In the interim, go do some courses such as Mums and Dads forever. The judge will generally order that one or both parents attend this course and they take time to get into. If you knock it out before you are ordered then you are in front and it looks good to the court, not only that but you will find they really help you refocus on what is important and give skills for co-parenting into the future.
5. Be realistic about your expectations in the outcome for example if mediation lands at 55-45 then seriously assess whether the 10% is worth all the extra bitterness.
6. DONT BE PETTY! It is a very painful process but dont get dragged into the mud with namecalling etc. Think of the parent you want your kids model themselves on and stand tall. It will pay off in time.

Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23645 posts
WA, 23645 posts
12 Jan 2011 6:14pm
longwinded said...

2. Go to the mediation.
6. DONT BE PETTY! It is a very painful process but dont get dragged into the mud with namecalling etc. Think of the parent you want your kids model themselves on and stand tall. It will pay off in time.




2. In WA, mediation is now mandatory before you can even lodge docs at Family Court.

6. Bloody oath. Make sure you tell him to be the 'bigger person' and not resort to all the petty sh!t. Usual divorce scenario - She calls him a name and he will wear it. He calls her a name and suddenly he has a restraining order and is labelled a violent wife beater psyco in Court. Implore him to be nice!
Flux
Flux
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
12 Jan 2011 6:27pm
Difficult time! been there, probably the worst you'll ever experience at this phase.
But it gets better I'm so glad to be free also!!

In answer to your questions there is no way she can get 80% she's dreaming, given the equality in family income of both is within 20% of each other.

On the information you have posted the split is most definitely going to be 60/40 to wife.(that scenario would be for a Dad that had the kids part time i.e every second wkend).
If the custody is 50/50 then maybe he can find a more equitable financial cut?

The problem is that everyone gets in her ear and all they advise is to fleece the man for all he's worth in what ever way they think "is there god given right".

My advice
1st get a statutory declaration from the family courts to say they both have formally split(reason because she can continue to divide all asset wealth up until lodged with the family courts),
Then drop her like a sack of potato's accept 65% loss of assets as the worst outcome and settle at that figure he will need to lawyer up if she has already, just get the lawyer to draw up a formal asset settlement doco and custody doco for her to sign and offer it to her lawyer for acceptance.
She will hold out as advised by her lawyer and the lawyer wheels will begin to spin.
At that time sack your lawyer and use the knowledge gained thus far and doco templates that they have already written up to counter with your own settlement figure and try to get her to settle and sign this way and outside of court.

The courts cannot order him to drop his house price.

It is in his best interest to settle out of court and pay her out as quick as possible.
Beware of a thing called spousal maintenance and her trying to take the kids interstate or overseas make sure you put stops on the kids passports etc.

Good friends he will need. Goodluck.

Salatiela
Salatiela
NSW
378 posts
NSW, 378 posts
13 Jan 2011 12:14am
Poor bugga,

Just keep the kids in mind, remind him that in a 50/50 arrangement is just the beginning at some stage it'll change pending who 'moves on' first and the fact you'll have to talk to the women often...
( kids routine, schooling, diet, swimming lessons, shoes, movies / dvd's, new girlfriend position in the relationship - he's gunna be in contact with the ex for the rest of his life)
Support him to keep it clean, it's a long road ahead...It's all about the kids.
PelicanPete
PelicanPete
QLD
67 posts
QLD, 67 posts
12 Jan 2011 11:34pm
I have been through it, but no kids involved.

I had a buddy that beat the system, but he is an obstinate bastard, He didn't engage the solicitor, and read the law books himself. Every letter he got from her solicitor, he replied to requesting clarity on point 1, and when that was clarified he would ask for clarity of point 2. in the end at $50 a letter it cost her heaps, and he learnt more about the whole process.
When they had their day in court, because he had been on the books, he shut the solicitor down. Solicitor ended up leaving town.

The other thing to consider is cutting back your work to cater to more custody time, and it reduces the income stream for Child support. I know guy who even stopped work. It discourages the "Lady" from thinking that there is a gravy train.

Try staying un emotional, never meet with them alone, My X told me that I was obviously upset, and it would be okay if I hit her. I roared laughing instead.
If you are having a meeting with them and their phone rings, if they answer it, leave the room. It's a set up power play to belittle you. All physocology stuff and games people play.

While you try and minimise the cost of Solicitors, try and keep the girlfriends from giving her advice. Some of those bitter and twisted individuals love to keep the fight happening, it gives them something to live for.

Its not an easy road, but most of the people I know, and from my own experince heal quite well afterwards, and move on, replace the finances, and are happy with their lot.

Good Luck....
NasiGoreng
NasiGoreng
VIC
260 posts
VIC, 260 posts
13 Jan 2011 9:58am
1) put the ownership of any assets in a trust asap (means he doesnt own them and cant be counted as an asset)
2) remove ex from super beneficiaries list
3) seek legal advice pronto as she can access half his super
4) if house is in just his name deffo put under a trust. - see accountant or fin advisor
it will be safe.
4.5) act quickly, DONT do nothing, my mate did nothing and came out pennyless.
5) hire hit man.
DYGuy
DYGuy
5 posts
5 posts
13 Jan 2011 8:05am
Been there too, nasty, nasty business, worst time of my life.
Only way to get through it, as many have already stated …. Mediation……. Damm hard though!
Think of the kids.
The only ones who benefit are the lawyers.

Keep one thing in mind …………… at the end is freedom!!
Man it’s good!!
Cheers
shark
shark
WA
361 posts
WA, 361 posts
13 Jan 2011 8:54am
horrible time for your bro, mines been thru it also, and there are no winners-only degrees of losing.

Some good advice here...
but f++k there is some STUPID advice also??
Flux
Flux
WA
533 posts
WA, 533 posts
13 Jan 2011 12:27pm
shark said...
Some good advice here...
but f++k there is some STUPID advice also??

I was just thinking the same!

I'm afraid if you think hiding your money in trusts or spending it all etc, will help your mistaken as the courts will ask for ALL financial records every single statement on every single financial interest you have for the past 2 years if money has just vanished or if you don't give full disclosure to the courts/lawyers and the courts find out they will rule heavily in favour of her and she will reap the benefits.

If she is already deluded into thinking she is entitled to 80% already you will most certainly have a court battle on your hands but remember the children are the important thing here and your money is still going to be providing a roof over there heads.
wheelnut
wheelnut
WA
90 posts
WA, 90 posts
13 Jan 2011 3:18pm
What does a bushfire, earth quake, flood and a wife have in common?

One day one of them will get your house !!!!
Toots
Toots
WA
271 posts
WA, 271 posts
13 Jan 2011 7:45pm
reminds of me of that shane jacobson line on that dunny movie "Dont get married, just find someone you hate, and buy them a house"
JB Mel
JB Mel
QLD
297 posts
QLD, 297 posts
14 Jan 2011 7:40am
wheelnut said...

What does a bushfire, earth quake, flood and a wife have in common?

One day one of them will get your house !!!!


They don't call em housekeepers for nothin'
arkgee
arkgee
NSW
639 posts
NSW, 639 posts
14 Jan 2011 11:26am
try and avoid anger...it will end up costing him heaps...when I went through it I likend it to driving an old car with f#*ked radiator...keep going till she starts to overheat then pull over for awhile till she cools down...lots of short trips will get you there....try and do it all at once and she's gonna blow...the light at the end of the tunnel is freedom.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
14 Jan 2011 12:39pm
Agree completely about staying focussed on kids welfare.

Have yet to see a split where one, or both, parents didn't use the squids as collateral/leverage. Selfish and disgusting - no matter who starts it.

As for representing yourself in court - NO KN WAY JOSE!! Stop watching LA law re-runs and wise up. One success story would be outwayed by 100s of dudes/dudettes that got royally shafted by much better equiped adversaries.

Try to get ya mate keep it civil AT ALL TIMES. Even if only for his own peace of mind and self worth.
e0422713
e0422713
WA
975 posts
WA, 975 posts
15 Jan 2011 8:23am
stop work/ go kiting/ liquidate all assets real fast and go to maui..................now lets talk about custody.....
Bigwavedave
Bigwavedave
QLD
2057 posts
QLD, 2057 posts
15 Jan 2011 11:09am
Get rid of your mates and their advice.

Tell her to do the same.

In 5 years she will apologise for reaming you of all the assets and it will be all gone.

For the sake of the kids do this:

One third for her

One third for you

One third for the kids in a trust account that needs two signatures.

It's always the financials that cause the bitterness.


Oh ...... sack the lawyers and do it through Lifeline.

bigbird49
bigbird49
SA
1 posts
SA, 1 posts
15 Jan 2011 12:14pm
My bit of advice DO THE MEDIATION can save you ****loads,,will cut down court time to ,, Good lawer helps .
stribo
stribo
QLD
1628 posts
QLD, 1628 posts
16 Jan 2011 7:00pm
Tell him to buy a chainsaw and give her what she's asking for. 80 percent of everything Would be great but probs not the best advice.
50/50 custody ? No such thing... You may have the kids for 50 percent of the time but CSA will only see one parent as the primary custodian. That is how she will get her 80 percent... It's very hard for the male to get to be the primary custodian.Unless she agrees to make him the primary.He is buggered.It would take a court case that very few men win.
Also if he earns more money than the soon to be ex he will still have to pay her child support even though he looks after them 50/50.
What a great and fair system.Makes me fkn wild..
Best thing he could do is cut his loses and make the best deal he can and go do some form of surfing for the next few years.Make sure you tell him its a far better option than a short swing from the shed rafters.He will seriously consider this in the next few years.So keep a good eye on him.Keep him talking etc.
clarkee
clarkee
WA
220 posts
WA, 220 posts
17 Jan 2011 12:07am
stribo,great advise i took up windsurfing during my divorce its a fkn hard time so yeh get your mate windsurfing he will thank you for it
skeer
skeer
WA
32 posts
WA, 32 posts
17 Jan 2011 12:36am
yep never married but got screw over just the same with 2 kids time heals but bewhere next time and dont fall for some little italian kite surfer chick either they burn too! sorry bad experence lols
e0422713
e0422713
WA
975 posts
WA, 975 posts
17 Jan 2011 1:49pm
i got 6 percent of assets because the chidren were young/ and the judge said i can bounce back easily.....


after bankruptcy ... nothing will stop the gravy train unless u do.............
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
17 Jan 2011 2:10pm
I just worked out that I will pay $93 600.00 by the time my daughter is 18. I dont have any custody and I never really had a relationship with the mother.

Im not happy but there is no way out of it. I can understand the animosity that people display over these things, its frustrating to say the least
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
17 Jan 2011 7:38pm
NasiGoreng said...

1) put the ownership of any assets in a trust asap (means he doesnt own them and cant be counted as an asset)
2) remove ex from super beneficiaries list
3) seek legal advice pronto as she can access half his super
4) if house is in just his name deffo put under a trust. - see accountant or fin advisor
it will be safe.
4.5) act quickly, DONT do nothing, my mate did nothing and came out pennyless.
5) hire hit man.


I can tell you that 1 and 4 don't mean a thing, even if you have done this any assets not at arm's length can be deemed yours, and included in settlement

3 and 4.5 are worth exploring

If you do 5 also get a good criminal lawyer too...
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅