Can anybody advise?

I am 80kg. No surfing background, but i've been windsurfing for years.
Did my first SUP season on a Naish Nalu 10'10. The board is ok for flat water but way too big and I would like to get into surf his winter so up for sale it went.
My girlfriend has a Naish Mana 9'5 which I like better but I can do smaller.
Conditions Mediterranean, pretty mushy waves I guess.

Like the title says I need to decide between these 2 boards
I can get both boards new, the 2013 models for 1100??? each,
or..
slightly used Naish 8'10 wood 950???
slightly used Fanatic Allwave 8'10 800???

I like the windsurf option on the Allwave but I think it will be less performance than the Naish?
Don't realy fancy the wood look of the Naish.
Anything other to consider? One dealer tells me Starboard Converse 9x30 but dunno about Starboard.
The JP Wide Surf Body 8'10 was on my mind but they say it's too much of an expert board for me and he doesn't like te proportions.