hello everyone! i will be extremely happy if you guys can help me to choose a new board

i'm moving form 10 footer to something shorter, lighter, easier to turn and something to improve my wave riding

female
beginner
hight: 168cm /5.5 ft
weight: 53kg /116.8 lbs
waves -home spot: small, mushy, chop

possible options:
FANATIC ALL WAVE 8'3" / 8'5"
FANATIC PROWAVE 8'9"
STARBOARD POCKET ROCKET
STARBOARD WIDE POINT
(or any other starboard surf models)
NAISH MANA
NAISH HOKUA

what do you think would suit me best?
i'm much more interesting in buying fanatic or starboard models.
all i ask is thin rails, wide and short board, stability and shape, that would bring me to next level of paddle surfing.

what do you think?

thank you!